Make My Cake
6.7 • Bakery
Small, unassuming bakery offers varied baked goods including unique flavors like sweet potato and caramel cake with dual frostings. Atmosphere feels quiet and early-closing, with desserts often available only by late afternoon or early evening. Customers find some items like cheesecake brownie and pasta salad stand out for quality.
View menu
"I liked some cakes but found others dry and stale."
36
"I love their rich red velvet and sweet potato cakes."
16
"I hate how they overfill drinks with ice and charge extra."
2
Good to know
1
The bakery charges 75 cents extra for light ice, making drinks nearly $10.
2
Call ahead for custom cakes to ensure they have enough time to prepare.
3
The bakery closes at 7 PM, so plan your visit accordingly.
2380 Adam Clayton Powell Jr Blvd, New York, New York, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Ma Smith's Dessert Cafe
Charming small mom-and-pop bakery with a cozy four-table layout and friendly, old-school ambiance.
Especiallymade_ByB
Innovative bakery delivering perfectly preserved cupcakes with creative, vegan-friendly flavors and impeccable icing.
The Original Cake Man Raven
Renowned for its exceptional cake quality, this appointment-only bakery offers freshly iced confections with a personalized touch.
Explore 91K locations in NYC!
I have been using it now for 3 months and it saves me so much research. Reduces the need to call and double check every time.
Michael L.Adventurous Diner
How did I not know these places existed?! Atly's scoring is a lifesaver, now I can finally find THE spot without wasting time Googling my life away.
Clara D.Frequent Traveler