Maria’s Pizza
6.4 • Pizza restaurant
Tiny space with vintage decor featuring red ceilings and religious iconography creates a nostalgic atmosphere. Italian music plays softly while staff work in synchronized rhythm behind blazing hot ovens. Counter service offers hand-made pizza that reflects tradition.
View menu
"I loved the classic Italian pizza here, it felt like a core memory."
186
"I really enjoyed the delicious garlic bread."
8
"I feel nostalgic about growing up eating here."
7
Good to know
1
Maria’s Pizza has no inside dining; it's counter service only.
2
The small pizza costs $22, and the large pizza is $26.
3
Parking is very limited at this location.
5025 W Forest Home Ave, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Di Stefano's Pizza Palace
Nostalgic old school pizza place with Italian American kitsch, cozy no-frills ambiance, and a family-owned, quality-focused approach.
Makes Cents Variety Store
Nostalgic shop boasting a vast collection of vintage toys, retro games, and wrestling memorabilia in a classy, engaging atmosphere.
Leon's Frozen Custard
Vintage 1950s drive-in with iconic neon signage, serving classic frozen custard recipes in a nostalgic setting.
