Mehaffies Pies
8.8 • Bakery
Handmade pies dominate the selection with wide flavor variety and freshness. Atmosphere feels sterile rather than cozy, lacking typical bakery warmth. Customers often pre-order to avoid shortages, reflecting high demand and limited availability.
View menu
"I thought their pies were the best I could get."
68
"I considered the cookies to be the best I have ever eaten."
8
"I thought the food here was always great."
4
Good to know
1
Pre-ordering a month in advance should prevent running out of pies.
2
Buying uncooked frozen pies allows you to avoid long lines.
3
They offer individual slices, cheesecakes, and tiny pie bites called 'haffies'.
3013 Linden Ave, Dayton, Ohio, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
The Hearth Community Place Food Pantry
Community-focused food pantry offering donated perishables and staples, with a welcoming indoor setting and prayer support.
Lee's Famous Recipe Chicken
A clean and tidy exterior contrasts with an outdated interior in this longstanding fried chicken spot.
Elsa's Mexican Restaurant
Neighborhood spot with a fun, divey vibe, featuring intimate seating and a surprisingly nicer interior than its exterior.
