Mister Softee
7.8 • Ice cream shop
Small ice cream shop with warm, welcoming atmosphere and busy, fast-moving lines. Offers soft serve with rich, creamy texture and some hard ice cream, plus souvenirs and waffle options. Interior feels cramped with limited seating and notable photo-friendly decor.
View menu
"The ice cream here is really, really good."
63
"The soft serve here is so rich and creamy."
16
"Stepping inside felt like a truly nostalgic experience."
7
Good to know
1
Parking is very limited and challenging to navigate.
2
Expect long lines, but they move quickly.
3
Prices are high, with three medium and two small cones costing $31.
195 Carleton Ave, East Islip, New York, United States
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
MR SOFTEE STORE / HAMPTONS SOFT ICE CREAM INC
Charming, classic ice cream shop with a cute bench and a fun, lively atmosphere featuring large, varied servings.
Friendly's
Cozy, family-friendly restaurant with a nostalgic old-school American vibe and consistently clean, welcoming atmosphere.
