New Milford Bagel Express
8.2 • Bagel shop
Small, no-frills bagel shop with a hole-in-the-wall feel and cash-only policy. Bagels stand out as great and delicious, especially the breakfast options, while hot sandwiches are less impressive. Pricing tends to be higher than nearby alternatives.
View menu
"I thought the bagels here were amazing and tasted like true New Jersey bagels."
11
"I found the breakfast bagels very delicious."
2
Good to know
1
They only accept cash payments, so plan accordingly.
2
Prices have recently increased; check for current rates.
3
Expect a no frills experience with basic bagel offerings.
506 River Rd, New Milford, New Jersey, United States
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
The Tailored Ham
Cozy, spotlessly clean bagel shop offering freshly baked bagels and great breakfast sandwiches in a welcoming atmosphere.
BorderLine Bagel & Deli
Warm, welcoming bagel shop once praised for hand-rolled bagels and a friendly atmosphere, now facing quality concerns.
Burger King
Clean, remodeled fast-food spot with a phenomenal $3 breakfast deal and a nice, neat atmosphere.
