Old Mill Tavern
8.5 • Restaurant
Older establishment with nostalgic decor featuring cop and firehouse memorabilia creates a cozy bar vibe with ample seating. Atmosphere feels warm and pleasant, easygoing with friendly, chatty people but not loud. Outdoor picnic tables welcome dogs, adding to the relaxed, inclusive setting.
View menu
"The bar's buffalo wings were outstanding and perfectly cooked."
30
"I thought the burgers were fantastic and cooked to perfection."
22
"It's a cozy place with a lot of heart and character."
8
Good to know
1
Parking lot and entrance are wheelchair accessible.
2
The kitchen closes at about 8:45 pm.
3
The bar closes between 9 and 10 pm depending on how busy it is.
55 Rte 24, Chester, New Jersey, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Jersey Mike's Subs
Clean, well-maintained sandwich shop known for freshly made food and solid ingredients with consistent quality.
Sub Pub
Cozy, clean sub shop with a diverse menu and affordable pricing, cherished for over 20 years.
Benito's Trattoria
Cozy Italian eatery featuring authentic flavors, a welcoming atmosphere, and a charming outdoor seating area.
