Old Town Bagels
7.7 • Bagel shop
Freshly baked bagels are large, full, and delicious, drawing a steady crowd that keeps the shop busy. The atmosphere feels inviting despite limited decor, and food is typically ready upon arrival with reasonable prices.
View menu
"These bagels are delicious and always fresh."
16
"The staff here is so nice and welcoming."
5
"The bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich was perfect."
2
Good to know
1
Expect long lines during peak hours due to high demand for bagels.
2
Bagels and coffee typically cost over $10.
3
The bagels are freshly made throughout the day.
Old Town Rd, Port Jefferson Station, New York, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Better On A Bagel Deli
Busy, clean establishment offering a large selection of fresh bagels with great value pricing.
IHOP
Bright, super clean eatery with a cheerful, cozy atmosphere offering classic breakfast fare.
Panera Bread
Clean, friendly café with a peaceful atmosphere offering fresh, quality food despite smaller portions and higher prices.
