New Yorkers 1st Choice
PB&J with Tay image 1
PB&J with Tay image 2
PB&J with Tay image 3

PB&J with Tay

9.9 • Sandwich shop
💎 Hidden Gems
🍫 Rocky Road
Unique
🕊️ Peaceful
💭 Nostalgic
👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Kid Friendly
🇺🇸 American Food
🛋️ Comfortable
🛋️ Cozy
🏘️ Local Spot
🍽️ Lunch Spot
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🥘 Food
🥪 Sandwich
🍮 Pudding
More
Antique decor and vintage plates create a cozy, home-like setting that feels like stepping back in time. Laidback and friendly energy fills the space, welcoming small groups and families with books and games for kids. Watching sandwiches made fresh adds a personal touch to the relaxed, eclectic atmosphere.
View menu
People are saying

"I loved their delicious Peanut Butter And Jelly sandwiches."

"You have to try the award-winning banana pudding."

"The owner's genuine pride and positive energy make this place a hidden gem."

Good to know

1

The restaurant does not provide ADA access due to stairs to the second floor.

2

Anyone in a wheelchair or with a disability may find access difficult.

3

There is plenty of parking available nearby.

Map showing 5335 McCullough Ave
PB&J with Tay
9.9
5335 McCullough Ave, Olmos Park, Texas, United States
Discovery made simple

Explore 91K locations in NYC!

I have been using it now for 3 months and it saves me so much research. Reduces the need to call and double check every time.

Michael L.
Michael L.Adventurous Diner

How did I not know these places existed?! Atly's scoring is a lifesaver, now I can finally find THE spot without wasting time Googling my life away.

Clara D.
Clara D.Frequent Traveler