Petee's Café
8.8 • Cafe
Small space offers comfy window seating and a variety of pie slices served in plastic containers. Atmosphere feels cluttered and constrained with a pop-punk take-out vibe after renovations. Quiet spots near windows provide a cozy meeting environment despite loss of previous garden and bar areas.
View menu
"I thought the banana cream and sour cherry pies were the best."
20
"The chocolate pie here is sensational and melts in your mouth."
10
"This cafe's pie is so good, it's like visiting Grandma."
8
Good to know
1
The establishment opens at 11:30AM, not 11AM as stated online.
2
Expect possible wait times until 1PM for fresh pies.
3
Limited seating is available, but spots can usually be found.
505 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, New York, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Peck's
Gorgeous café featuring a quiet, cozy backyard patio and welcoming staff, offering a beautiful, comfortable ambiance.
TB Coffee House
Modern, minimalist café featuring a cute backyard deck, bright cozy ambiance, and friendly service.
Head Hi
Spacious, architecturally thoughtful coffee shop featuring a curated gallery and book pedestals in a peaceful ambiance.
