Pizza Supreme
8.0 • Pizza restaurant
Square pizzas stand out with thick sauce and crisp crusts delivering a familiar, consistent taste. The space includes 12 tables and a TV, creating a casual, straightforward dining spot. Staff handle food without gloves, reflecting a relaxed approach to food safety.
View menu
"I found the pizza here to be amazing and really good."
35
"The food here is delicious and fresh."
9
"The Italian food, especially the square pie, has an incredible mozzarella and crisp crust."
2
Good to know
1
There is a fee for credit card payments.
2
Prices at Pizza Supreme are on the higher side.
3
Staff handle food without gloves, raising food safety concerns.
678 Stewart Ave, Garden City, New York, United States
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Bleecker Street Pizza
Popular pizzeria in a super clean food court offering an almost endless choice of pies at decent prices
Enzo’s Pizza Of Garden City
Welcoming, clean neighborhood pizza joint serving extremely hot, unreal food at great prices.
il Gufo
Gorgeous Italian restaurant featuring a dark teal lacquered private room and an open front for vibrant summer dining.
