Sheepshead Baygels
7.7 • Bagel shop
Old style deli with classic registers and a dark, slow atmosphere offers NYC-style hand rolled bagels with a crisp outside and soft inside. The vibe feels welcoming and patriotic, attracting those seeking authentic bagel flavors reminiscent of Brooklyn.
View menu
"I thought these were the best bagels in the area."
22
"These Local Spot bagels are crispy outside and pillow-soft inside."
6
"The breakfast staff here are so kind-hearted and helpful."
6
Good to know
1
Sheepshead Baygels only accepts cash payments; credit cards are not accepted.
2
There is an ATM on-site if you forget cash.
3
The orange juice costs $14, which is quite high.
2095 NJ-35, Holmdel, New Jersey, United States
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Holmdel Bagel Market
Small, clean bagel shop known for fast, affordable, and delicious offerings with a warm, friendly atmosphere.
Slice
Affordable, customer-focused POS system offering quick setup, seamless integration, and lifetime equipment warranty.
Rook Coffee
Casual coffee spot known for New Orleans-style brews with a clean restroom and modest ambiance.
