Starrlight Pizza
8.9 • Pizza delivery
Personal-sized pizzas feature sourdough crust with creative toppings and a chewy texture. Bread offerings include cinnamon raisin and olive loaves that are consistently well-made. Ordering online is straightforward, though wait times can be longer than expected.
View menu
"I found the pizza here to be amazing and delicious."
21
"I thought their sourdough bread was amazing."
10
"The bread at this Local Spot is always perfect."
7
Good to know
1
Expect a wait time of about 55 minutes during peak hours.
2
Vegan options are available, including a vegan sourdough pizza.
3
Pizzas are personal-sized, not as large as some might expect.
95 Starr St Pickup Window, 95 Starr St, Brooklyn, NY, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Tony's Pizza
Classic old school NYC Italian pizza shop with spacious outdoor seating, clean tile walls, and a lively, homey atmosphere.
Sal's
Authentic old school Italian pizza spot with vintage 80s decor, clean indoor seating, and large street-facing windows.
Ops
Cozy, rustic pizza joint with a provocative natural wine list, offering a warm, intimate atmosphere and honest, perfected dishes.
