Surprise Scoop
5.2 • Ice cream shop
Minimalist space with no seating or counter creates a bare, unfinished feel. Atmosphere is casual and simple, centered on a mystery flavor concept where customers receive surprise ice cream flavors. The vibe is low-key and informal, with a focus on unique, creamy ice cream served through a pickup window.
View menu
"The ice cream flavor is a surprise, and it's fun to guess."
14
"The caramel ice cream is delicious, thick, and not too airy."
6
"The chocolate here is reasonably priced for NYC."
3
Good to know
1
Bring a list of allergies when ordering to ensure safe choices.
2
Surprise Scoop offers a unique and fun ice cream experience.
3
No unusual or gross flavors are served, ensuring a pleasant experience.
139 1st Ave, New York, New York, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
A Man and His Sandwich Tours
Engaging food tour featuring authentic local sandwiches, inclusive dietary options, and expert storytelling in a lively atmosphere.
Panna II Garden Indian Restaurant
Vibrantly decorated with millions of Christmas lights, this narrow, cozy space offers a unique, colorful ambiance despite its cramped seating.
Cure Thrift
Chic, museum-like vintage shop featuring high-end curated furniture and clothing with a captivating 70s vibe.
