The Original Attilio's Pizza
7.2 • Pizza restaurant
Pizza restaurant offers tons of seating and a friendly atmosphere despite occasional chaos during busy times. It serves real Jersey pizza with a wide variety of options, including gourmet slices like Buffalo chicken and cheese steak. Consistency stands out, making it a local favorite with many picking up food regularly.
View menu
"I'd drive hours for this pizza; it's the best in the area."
22
"The bread here is so soft and warm."
4
"The takeout pizza quality isn't the same as dining in."
2
Good to know
1
Pizza slices are not available after 8:30 pm, despite the restaurant being open until 10 pm.
2
The restaurant charges a $1.00 convenience fee on orders.
3
Expect to pay around $21 for a spinach roll and two slices of pizza.
4057 Asbury Ave, Tinton Falls, New Jersey, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
URBAN PIZZA
Casual eatery known for amazingly greasy pizza with amazing cleanliness and fair pricing.
Domino's Pizza
Under new local family management, this spotless pizzeria offers a wide range of customizable toppings with consistently fresh, high-quality ingredients.
Anna's Restaurant
Cozy, nicely updated interior with clean, comfortable seating and a wide, extensive menu featuring generous portions.
