The Cookie Odyssey
8.9 • Bakery
Bakery offers varied cookie selection with soft, chewy textures and unique flavors like banana chocolate chip. Atmosphere feels casual and cozy with limited seating and some display disorganization. Occasional issues with open-door ventilation invite bugs, affecting overall environment.
View menu
"These cookies are warm, gooey, and incredibly delicious."
70
"The chocolate chip cookies have melty chocolate and a chewy center."
16
Good to know
1
The cookie display is often disorganized, making it hard to choose.
2
On hot days, the shop sometimes leaves the door open, inviting bugs.
3
The prices at the shop are considered amazing by many customers.
1414 2nd Ave, New York, New York, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Cococasa Kitchen
Creative baker crafting luxurious custom cookies with unified themes, stunning designs, and personalized packaging.
Crumbl
Small, clean and modern cookie shop with a welcoming atmosphere and delightful aromas.
Teuscher Madison
Renowned for finest Swiss chocolates and a unique variety of chocolate-filled toys, delighting lovers for over 41 years.
