The Fish Store
8.5 • Seafood restaurant
Small dining room offers a cozy hometown vibe with a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Fresh seafood features prominently, including lobster and oysters praised for quality and taste. The spot stands out as a hidden gem with a strong local feel and competitive prices.
View menu
"The seafood here is so fresh, I loved the stuffed flounder."
76
"The Japanese food, especially the sushi, is so fresh and delicious."
15
"The food here is amazing, especially the tuna and soup."
15
Good to know
1
The seafood sampler offers the best deal regarding price and quality.
2
The prices at The Fish Store are competitive.
3
The portions are large enough for another dinner.
836 Montauk Hwy, Bayport, New York, United States
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Momos Too Sports Bar & Grill
Cozy, clean sports bar with a lively atmosphere, offering seasonal menus and friendly, attentive service.
Mizu Ken Sushi
Quiet, clean ambiance with great prices, offering an amazing dining experience despite simple decor.
Bayport Athletic Recovery
Inviting, immaculately clean wellness center offering peaceful, restorative sauna and cold plunge experiences.
