The Pizza Heist
8.2 • Pizza restaurant
Pizza spot offers old school style pizza with thin crust, plenty of cheese, and cup-and-char pepperonis. Wings come crispy with juicy inside, cooked to perfection. Pricing stays affordable, drawing crowds especially for two-slice specials and large one-topping deals.
View menu
"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."
23
"I found the food here to be consistently great."
14
"I love the boneless wings, they're delicious char BBQ."
1
Good to know
1
The Monday large pizza special costs $13 after tax.
2
Expect a busy atmosphere before Bills games.
3
Parking can get tight during rush hours.
231 Aurora St, Lancaster, New York, United States
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Pizza 151
Bright, welcoming pizzeria with a unique open-air setup, featuring generous, non-acidic sauce pizzas and a clean, orderly kitchen.
Muscarella's Pizzeria Lancaster NY
Warm, welcoming pizzeria known for its fresh ingredients and perfectly balanced cheese, sauce, and dough ratio.
Papa's Pizza Oven
Phenomenal pizza oven spot renowned for high-quality, best-in-area pizza and exceptional customer service.
