What's Cookin'
9.1 • Caterer
Old-school diner with a family-owned vibe offers a pleasant, family-friendly atmosphere where locals gather and staff know names. Reasonable prices pair with solid breakfast and sandwich options, making it a favored spot despite limited parking.
View menu
"I thought the breakfast here was the best."
6
"The homemade iced tea is delicious and not watered down."
3
"I found amazing food and service at this hidden gem."
2
Good to know
1
The prices at What's Cookin' are reasonable for the quality of food.
2
Street parking is available, but it can be challenging to find a spot.
3
Expect a busy environment, especially during breakfast and lunch hours.
201 Main St, New Milford, New Jersey, United States
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
New Milford Deli and Bagels
Cozy deli with freshly baked rolls, a welcoming atmosphere, and affordable, quality food served by friendly staff.
Fresh & Fancy Farms
Quaint, thoughtfully decorated farm with beautiful florals, gold-accented place settings, and a welcoming, homey atmosphere.
Pancho's Burritos
Lively spot featuring big video screens and a fun, music-filled atmosphere with a cozy, cute setting.
