Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots where pumpkin pie meets apple pie in New York City

Based on 751 Reviews
+748
User
User
User
Updated
01
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 1
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 2
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 3
View all
🥧 Apple Pie
🥧 Pumpkin Pie
🍰 Birthday Cake
🚫🌾 Gluten Free
More

Cozy bakery with rustic wooden accents and beautiful decor creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. Comfortable seating indoors and outdoors supports relaxed visits, though loud music sometimes fills the space. Cakes and desserts stand out as memorable and excellent offerings.

People are saying

"I love ordering custom cakes that look and taste amazing."

"The bakery offers a great variety of tasty treats I enjoy."

"I trust this bakery to deliver quality every time."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for custom cake orders, especially for weekends.

2

The bakery offers a variety of gluten-free and vegan options.

3

Cakes are prepared in advance and may not be freshly baked.

02
Sixteen Mill Bakeshop image 1
Sixteen Mill Bakeshop image 2
Sixteen Mill Bakeshop image 3
View all
🥧 Apple Pie
🥧 Pumpkin Pie
🥗 Vegetarian
🥛 Dairy Free
More

Minimalist bakery space offers a cozy, intimate atmosphere with friendly energy. Gluten-free and refined sugar-free baked goods stand out for their quality and inventiveness. Regulars appreciate the gluten-free focus, refined sugar-free products, cozy vibe, and minimalist design.

Good to know

1

All baked goods are gluten-free and refined sugar-free.

2

The bakery offers a variety of vegan options alongside gluten-free items.

3

Payment methods include credit cards and mobile payments.

03
The Noortwyck image 1
The Noortwyck image 2
The Noortwyck image 3
View all
🥧 Apple Pie
🥧 Pumpkin Pie
🍮 Rice Pudding
🍞 Bread
More

Upscale New American restaurant with an open-air front and natural light creates a cozy yet sophisticated atmosphere. Decor blends simple elegance with a relaxed vibe, making it ideal for casual dining or a dinner date. Street-side seating offers people watching in an eclectic urban setting.

People are saying

"The food is fresh, creative, and delicious."

"The wine list offers great variety and quality."

"I highly recommend this place for any occasion."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to ensure a table, especially on weekends.

2

Expect to pay around $20 for an omelette.

3

The kitchen may close early, so check ahead if dining late.

04
Westville Dumbo image 1
Westville Dumbo image 2
Westville Dumbo image 3
View all
🥧 Apple Pie
🥧 Pumpkin Pie
🥗 Healthy Foods
🤙 Casual
More

Modern space combines indoor and outdoor seating with a plant-filled courtyard that feels like a garden patio. Atmosphere stays cozy and welcoming with retro music playing softly. Guests enjoy a spacious, elegant setting that blends inside-outside dining.

People are saying

"It's a cozy spot with great food and vibe."

"The food is fresh, tasty, and offers great options."

Good to know

1

Happy hours are until 7 PM with great drink promotions.

2

Tuesday cocktails are $10, making it a budget-friendly option.

3

Reservations are recommended for weekend brunch to avoid long waits.

05
Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery image 1
Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery image 2
Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery image 3
View all

Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery

🥧 Pumpkin Pie
🥧 Apple Pie
🍮 Pudding
🥗 Vegetarian
More

Small shop with cozy atmosphere and charming decor offers best cupcakes and delicious banana pudding. Relaxed vibe contrasts with busy city surroundings. Limited seating encourages quick visits rather than long chats.

Good to know

1

Prices for cupcakes are around $3.50 each, which is reasonable for NYC.

2

The bakery offers vegan cupcakes and chocolate chip cookies.

3

Hygiene practices are questionable; staff do not wash hands between serving customers.

06
Kerber's Farm image 1
Kerber's Farm image 2
Kerber's Farm image 3
View all
🥧 Pumpkin Pie
🥧 Apple Pie
🧁 Muffins
🇺🇸 American Food
More

Bright, spacious bakery with white and light wood decor and fresh flowers on tables creates a welcoming, cozy atmosphere blending coastal grandmother style with a clean, farm feel. Seating is limited despite generous indoor space, and vintage details add charm. Early opening hours and free WiFi support a relaxed, inviting pace.

People are saying

"I love their pies and tasty pastries."

"I thought the pumpkin pie was the best I had ever had."

"I enjoyed the apple pie here."

Good to know

1

Expect a 20-minute wait for food during busy weekend mornings.

2

The savory pie is a popular choice among regulars.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash is also welcome.

07
Le Monde image 1
Le Monde image 2
Le Monde image 3
View all
🥧 Pumpkin Pie
🥧 Apple Pie
🥞 Brunch
🍽️ Lunch Spot
More

Parisian bistro style defines the space with rustic decor and old world charm. Atmosphere blends cozy elegance with lively, sometimes loud, energy. Outdoor seating maintains the French bistro vibe and welcomes dogs.

People are saying

"The food was delicious and the atmosphere inviting."

"Jason made the experience fun and memorable."

"It's a cozy spot with authentic French vibes."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended during peak times, especially if Columbia is in session.

2

The bottomless mimosa brunch costs $25 per hour.

3

The restaurant offers a fixed price menu on Christmas Eve.

08
Little Pie Company image 1
Little Pie Company image 2
Little Pie Company image 3
View all
🥧 Pumpkin Pie
🥧 Apple Pie
🥧 Key Lime Pie
🎂 Cheesecake
More

Open kitchen fills air with buttery pastry aroma while bakers craft pies. Cozy space with outdoor shaded seating invites relaxation. Try the mini pumpkin pie for a fresh taste or the sour cream walnut apple pie for a unique twist.

People are saying

"I really love their sour cream apple pie."

"I've never had an apple pie this good before."

"I loved the pumpkin pie; I wished we could eat it year round."

Good to know

1

Little Pie Co offers 50% off select pies at 7 PM daily.

2

Pre-order pies for holidays like Thanksgiving to ensure availability.

3

Expect high prices; pies can cost around $64 each.

09
Carnegie Diner & Cafe image 1
Carnegie Diner & Cafe image 2
Carnegie Diner & Cafe image 3
View all
🥧 Pumpkin Pie
🥧 Apple Pie
🍟 Diner
🤩 Lively
More

Upscale diner with cramped seating and dim lighting creates a classic yet hectic atmosphere. Live music and a small patio add to the vibe, while bottomless mimosas and standout dishes like the burger and French toast draw attention. Crowds fill the space, making it lively but noisy.

People are saying

"The food here tastes amazing and hits the spot."

"The apple pie pancakes make a great breakfast."

"Some say the apple pie tastes good, others don't."

Good to know

1

Make reservations for Easter Sunday to ensure a spot.

2

Unlimited mimosas for $20 are available every day all day.

3

Bottomless mimosas and waffles are available on Sunday morning.

10
Petee's Pie Company image 1
Petee's Pie Company image 2
Petee's Pie Company image 3
View all
🥧 Apple Pie
🥧 Pumpkin Pie
🥧 Pecan Pie
🥧 Cherry Pie
More

Cozy space with intimate vibe and warm, buttery aromas draws pie lovers. Apple pie shines with fresh Hudson Valley apples and a crisp, buttery crust. Pumpkin pie is popular but can taste like supermarket versions and sometimes has burnt edges.

People are saying

"I found the apple pie here to be delicious."

"I love how the apple pie stays crisp with a buttery crust."

"The apple pie feels like a perfect treat to celebrate."

Good to know

1

Pies are sold by the slice or whole.

2

Prices for pies range from $7.25 to $8 per slice.

3

There is limited seating in the pie shop.