Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to New York

Chocolate chip cookies and bagels

A bakery that respects the chocolate chip cookie as much as the bagel, rather than treating it like a secondary impulse buy.

Based on 739 Opinions
+736
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Sundays Off Café image 1
Sundays Off Café image 2
Sundays Off Café image 3
View all

Small, beautifully designed coffee shop with an artsy, cozy vibe and outdoor seating. Quiet atmosphere with great music playing consistently. Offers homemade bagels and cookies, creating a unique neighborhood spot.

Homemade chocolate chip cookies stand out with their freshly baked quality and rich flavor. They are made in house alongside bagels and consistently deliver a really good taste.

Bagels come freshly baked and made in house with options like the everything bagel with cream cheese and garlic butter. Pastries and bagels consistently deliver rich flavor and satisfying texture.

People are saying

"This coffee's maple sage cinnamon latte is an amazing, yummy blend."

"I loved their homemade bagels; the texture and flavor were amazing."

"I experienced the best coffee I have ever had."

Good to know

1

They close early on Saturdays.

2

There is no indoor seating.

3

The coffee shop offers pastry options.

02
Annie's Social image 1
Coffee shop

Modern coffee shop with separate dog playroom and dual entrances keeps dogs and humans comfortable. Atmosphere stays quiet and cozy, attracting friendly, chatty dog lovers. Space feels bright and clean with floor-to-ceiling windows and well-organized flow.

Soft and moist with a rich chocolate presence, the chocolate chip cookies pair well with coffee. They stand out as a go-to treat alongside other pastries.

Fresh bagels come with a good amount of cream cheese. Several food options include a variety of bagels and pastries.

People are saying

"It's a dog friendly cafe with a separate, clean indoor room for pups."

"You can bring your dog to socialize and enjoy these bagels."

"I found the chocolate chip cookies to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Dogs can only enter the dog activity area through the back door.

2

Annie’s Social asks that all dogs are fully vaccinated and well behaved.

3

The hours of operation are weekdays from 7 AM to 7 PM and weekends from 8 AM to 6 PM.

03
Librae Bakery image 1

Open kitchen with glass viewing showcases bakers at work, creating a modern, natural decor atmosphere. Space includes indoor and outdoor seating but often feels crowded and competitive for seats. Aromatic scents of za'atar and pistachio fill the air, adding to the sensory experience.

Tahini adds an umami punch to the chocolate chip cookie, making it gooey and melt-in-your-mouth. The chocolate cookie offers a rich, intense flavor like a death by chocolate dessert.

Jerusalem bagels stand out with their unique texture and sweet and salty flavor. Large size makes one enough, often paired with labne for dipping or spreading.

People are saying

"I found the pistachio croissant crispy, creamy, and delicious."

"The chocolate chip cookie was blissfully dark and buttery."

"The Jerusalem Bagel with labneh is amazing."

Good to know

1

Seating is quite limited if it’s busy, especially during the day.

2

Get here early because the place gets packed.

3

You should avoid the lines by visiting during the week.

04
Red Gate Bakery image 1

Small shop with cozy, nostalgic atmosphere and fresh baked cookie aroma. Bakers work visibly behind the counter, creating an intimate, welcoming vibe. Limited indoor space with only one small outdoor table emphasizes its charming, boutique feel.

Chocolate chip cookies here get a lot of attention, especially the toffee chocolate chip variety. Some batches have very little chocolate, mostly toffee bits, which can be disappointing if expecting rich chocolate.

Everything bagel cookie blends garlic with cookie sweetness. Other bagel-related treats include miso peanut butter and bagel cookies with savory and sweet notes.

People are saying

"The chocolate chip cookie was crispy, warm, and one of a kind."

"You have to try the pickled PB&J bar from the bakery; it's dense and rich."

"These chocolate chip cookies are exceptionally good and chewy."

Good to know

1

The cookie shop opens at 11 AM.

2

They sell out quickly, so arrive early.

3

Red Gate is not open late.

05
Edith’s Sandwich Counter image 1

Sandwich shop offers tiny, lively diner space with counter and outdoor seating that invites people watching and casual gatherings. Atmosphere feels cozy and welcoming, with a classic diner vibe and fun music. Crowds gather especially during busy hours, creating a community-focused energy.

Cookies come out incredibly thin with a chewy center. They offer a texture unlike typical chocolate chip cookies, making them stand out.

Bagels come toasted with a perfect mix of fluffy and crunchy textures and a hint of heat. The bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich with a latke on an everything bagel stands out as very yummy and amazing.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwich was creative, elevated, and delicious."

"You have to try the tahini coffee slushy; it's so good."

"I loved the shakshuka-inspired bagel with tamagoyaki."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as the line can be around 30 minutes on weekends.

2

Expect to pay over $15 for a bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich.

3

The establishment has a vegetarian wrap option available.

06
Orwashers Bakery image 1

Artisanal bakery layout with a display case to the left creates a cozy and comfortable atmosphere. The space offers outdoor seating and fills with the aroma of fresh bread. Known for wide variety of baked goods including bagels, babkas, and croissants, it maintains a long-standing reputation for quality.

Large chocolate chip cookies feature Valrhona dark and milk chocolate chips with a crisp exterior and soft interior. They rank among the best in the city alongside other standout pastries.

Bagels come out perfectly baked with a great texture and taste. The lox bagel stands out as affordable and flavorful, often paired with cream cheese, salmon, capers, and onion. A variety of options include bialys with tofu cream cheese and chives.

People are saying

"I found the sourdough bread to be one of the best I'd ever tasted."

"The pastries here are fantastic, especially the croissants and donuts."

"I had the best chocolate chip cookie of my life here."

Good to know

1

If you have an online pick-up order, have your confirmation email ready.

2

Customers should expect to wait a long time for their drinks.

3

There is no sitting area in the bakery; it's just take out.

07
Siena Bakehouse image 1
Breakfast restaurant

Bakery offers a cozy interior with comfortable seating and a bright, clean space. The atmosphere feels friendly and inviting, though occasional loud phone calls can disrupt the vibe. Small tables with power outlets support light work alongside enjoying pastries.

Edges of the chocolate chip cookie offer a crisp texture, while the middle stays soft and mushy. Opinions on the cookie vary, with some finding it over the top and others not enjoying it.

Crunchy everything bagels come loaded with smoked salmon and keep you full for hours. The egg bagel offers a tasty, well-made option, while the croissant-like bagel adds a slightly salty, balanced bite.

People are saying

"The croissants here are unbelievably fresh and crispy."

"I found the chocolate chip cookie to be that good."

"You have to try the egg bagels; they're super tasty."

Good to know

1

Breakfast is served every day during the holiday.

2

Expect to pay about $48 for a breakfast combo of 3 coffees and pastries.

3

They charge you 3% for payment by credit card without informing you.

Discover more

New York, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...