Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 places for pecan pie and birthday cake in New York City

Based on 776 Reviews
+773
User
User
User
Updated
01
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 1
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 2
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 3
View all
🥧 Pecan Pie
🍰 Birthday Cake
🚫🌾 Gluten Free
🍰 Carrot Cake
More

Cozy bakery with rustic wooden accents and beautiful decor creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. Comfortable seating indoors and outdoors supports relaxed visits, though loud music sometimes fills the space. Cakes and desserts stand out as memorable and excellent offerings.

People are saying

"I ordered a birthday cake that was stunning and delicious."

"I love ordering custom birthday cakes here."

"They nail custom and special diet birthday cakes."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for custom cake orders, especially for weekends.

2

The bakery offers a variety of gluten-free and vegan options.

3

Cakes are prepared in advance and may not be freshly baked.

02
Ceremonia Bakeshop image 1
Ceremonia Bakeshop image 2
Ceremonia Bakeshop image 3
View all
🥧 Pecan Pie
🍰 Birthday Cake
🍪 Chocolate Chip Cookies
🍫 Chocolate
More

Small bakery with limited indoor seating and plenty of outdoor tables creates a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Music and community vibe make it feel like a local gathering spot. Known for unique pastries and standout baked goods.

People are saying

"I love their fresh and tasty pastries."

"Their cakes are always delicious and look great."

"The cinnamon rolls are simply amazing."

Good to know

1

The bakery is small with limited outdoor seating available.

2

Expect a 30-minute wait on Saturday mornings.

3

Call ahead on weekends to avoid long wait times.

03
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery image 1
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery image 2
Crumbly Cafe & Bakery image 3
View all

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery

🍰 Birthday Cake
🥧 Pecan Pie
🍮 Pudding
🥐 Bakery
More

Cozy spot with warm atmosphere and tasty baked goods aroma. Pecan pie offers rich, sweet flavor that pairs well with other desserts. Birthday cakes are creative and personalized, featuring fun themes like volcano or unicorn.

People are saying

"The birthday cake looked amazing and tasted great."

"They make birthday cakes that are fun and unique."

"Their birthday cakes look great and taste amazing, even last minute."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers many gluten-free options for those with dietary restrictions.

2

Seating is limited to fewer than five people, so plan accordingly.

3

They have seasonal coffee options that change regularly.

04
Nita's Bakery image 1
Nita's Bakery image 2
Nita's Bakery image 3
View all
🥧 Pecan Pie
🍰 Birthday Cake
🍫 Chocolate
🍨 Desserts
More

European bakery with authentic Romanian pastries fills the air with the aroma of fresh baked goods and buttery croissants. The atmosphere feels welcoming and nostalgic, reminiscent of traditional Romanian bakeries. Only cash payments are accepted, emphasizing a local, family-run vibe.

People are saying

"I love how fresh and delicious the pastries are."

"The bakery offers a great variety of tasty treats."

"The Romanian pastries taste just like back home."

Good to know

1

The bakery only accepts cash for payment.

2

Customers buy Cozonac from Nita Bakery for every Romanian Easter and Christmas.

3

The bakery offers a variety of cakes with detailed descriptions.

05
Buttercup BakeShop image 1
Buttercup BakeShop image 2
Buttercup BakeShop image 3
View all
🥧 Pecan Pie
🍰 Birthday Cake
🍮 Pudding
🛋️ Cozy
More

Small cupcake shop offers unique flavors like banana cream pie and red velvet cheesecake in a warm, pink interior with soft jazz. Butter pecan pie delivers a rich, buttery flavor rivaling southern styles. Custom birthday cakes feature personalized messages and popular flavors like red velvet.

People are saying

"Their custom birthday cakes taste amazing."

"The Birthday Cake service was so patient and helpful."

"I thought the pecan pie was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers gluten-free options, ensuring a variety for dietary needs.

2

Prices for baked goods are clearly posted outside the shop.

3

There is usually no long wait at this cupcake shop.

06
Barking Dog Hell’s Kitchen image 1
Barking Dog Hell’s Kitchen image 2
Barking Dog Hell’s Kitchen image 3
View all
🍰 Birthday Cake
🥧 Pecan Pie
🐶 Pet Friendly
🐶 Dog Friendly
More

Outdoor seating in a quiet plaza offers a relaxed vibe away from city noise, with pet-friendly amenities including a pup menu and water bowls. Indoor space is compact but well-utilized, featuring a small bar and dome setup. The atmosphere balances calmness and casual comfort near a busy theater district.

People are saying

"The food and drinks here are delicious with a great vibe."

"It's a great spot to hang out with your dog and enjoy good food."

"The service here is amazing and makes every visit special."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers $5 beers from 3-6 PM.

2

Bring your dog for a discount during happy hour.

3

Barking Dog has a Valentine’s Special Dinner with a three-course meal and Prosecco.

07
Artuso Pastry Shop image 1
Artuso Pastry Shop image 2
Artuso Pastry Shop image 3
View all
🥧 Pecan Pie
🍰 Birthday Cake
🥐 Pastry
🎂 Cheesecake
More

Spacious bakery with old-school charm and a family atmosphere offers a wide selection of colorful, fresh pastries and cakes. The place feels cozy and clean, inviting guests to enjoy the simple, delicious surroundings while exploring traditional treats.

People are saying

"I loved the birthday cake; it tasted wonderful."

"I love that I can get last-minute birthday cakes with lots of filling."

"I always get the best birthday cakes here for my family."

Good to know

1

You need to get a ticket as you enter.

2

The numbered ticket system should always be used.

3

Some items sell out towards the end of the day.

08
NY Bakery and Desserts NoMad image 1
NY Bakery and Desserts NoMad image 2
NY Bakery and Desserts NoMad image 3
View all
🥧 Pecan Pie
🍰 Birthday Cake
🍨 Desserts
🍮 Pudding
More

Luxurious bakery with beautiful interior and wide dessert selection offers a clean, chill atmosphere with free wifi and good seating. The vibe is cute and relaxing, making it a popular spot for breakfast or late-night treats.

People are saying

"I loved the wide selection of tasty desserts."

"I really enjoyed the friendly vibe and clean place."

"The Dubai chocolate was the best I've had."

Good to know

1

The bakery is open late at night for sweet treats.

2

Expect a 3% credit card fee on purchases.

3

The shop offers a wide variety of pastries and desserts.

09
Little Pie Company image 1
Little Pie Company image 2
Little Pie Company image 3
View all
🥧 Pecan Pie
🍰 Birthday Cake
🥧 Key Lime Pie
🎂 Cheesecake
More

Open kitchen reveals bakers crafting pies, filling the air with buttery pastry aroma. Small, cozy space offers outdoor shaded seating and a homey atmosphere. Constant flow of people creates a pleasant, relaxed vibe.

People are saying

"The pecan pie here has an amazing abundance of pecans."

"The pecan pie tastes amazing with perfect sweetness."

"I love the Mississippi Mud Pie as much as the pecan pie."

Good to know

1

Little Pie Co offers 50% off select pies at 7 PM daily.

2

Pre-order pies for holidays like Thanksgiving to ensure availability.

3

Expect high prices; pies can cost around $64 each.

10
New York Bakery Café image 1
New York Bakery Café image 2
New York Bakery Café image 3
View all
🍰 Birthday Cake
🥧 Pecan Pie
🥐 Bakery
🍫 Chocolate Mousse
More

Bakery shines with rich pecan pie and funfetti birthday cakes. Cozy seating and soft music create a warm ambiance. Staff offers great customer service for custom orders.

People are saying

"They were so kind and helpful with my birthday cake order."

"I always get perfect birthday cakes here."

"Their themed birthday cakes never let me down."

Good to know

1

Cakes are available for birthdays and special events.

2

You need to order custom cakes at least a day in advance for special occasions.

3

They are open nearly until midnight.