Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots for peanut butter and jelly breakfast sandwiches in New York City

Based on 110 Reviews
+107
User
User
User
Updated
01
Park Cafe image 1
Park Cafe image 2
Park Cafe image 3
View all
🥪 Breakfast Sandwich
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
Cafe
🏷️ Affordable
More

Small, cozy space with well-lit interior and comfortable seating for chatting or working. Atmosphere feels friendly and nostalgic, enhanced by homemade treats and occasional free samples. Quiet vibe invites relaxed visits without rushing.

People are saying

"The owner's sweet and friendly service makes the Breakfast Sandwich special."

"I enjoyed the fresh and tasty breakfast sandwiches."

"The breakfast sandwiches have great portions and value."

Good to know

1

The cafe offers coffee, tea, breakfast, lunch, and sweets.

2

Pricing is very affordable.

3

The shop does not have much space to sit in.

02
Bear Donut image 1
Bear Donut image 2
Bear Donut image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🥪 Breakfast Sandwich
🍞 Brioche
🍰 Tiramisu
More

Small shop serves colorful mochi donuts with a standout PB&J brioche base that stays moist and flavorful. Mochi breakfast sandwiches offer a unique chewy texture and a sharp vinegary sauce for contrast. Space feels cute and upbeat with limited seating for quick visits.

People are saying

"The chewy donuts have fun, tasty flavors."

"I can't get enough of the peanut butter and jelly donut."

"The limited edition peanut butter and jelly donut really hit the spot."

Good to know

1

The breakfast waffle donut is only available between 8AM - 2PM.

2

Mochi donuts cost $3.75 and larger donuts cost $5.

3

Bear Donut does not have seating inside.

03
Leon's Bagels image 1
Leon's Bagels image 2
Leon's Bagels image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🥪 Breakfast Sandwich
🥯 Bagel With Lox
🍳 Eggs
More

Small bagel shop with a charming old-school New York vibe and cute takeout window. Atmosphere feels welcoming and friendly, attracting a fun crowd. Setup focuses on grab-and-go service with outdoor benches for quick bites.

People are saying

"The bagels are fresh, chewy, and really tasty."

"It's a small, no-seat spot with awesome branding."

"I can't wait to come back for more bagels."

Good to know

1

Leon's Bagels only offers take-away service.

2

Expect to visit early for breakfast around 8 am to avoid queues.

3

The bagels are made to order from a small storefront.

04
Gotan image 1
Gotan image 2
Gotan image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🥪 Breakfast Sandwich
🍳 Breakfast
🍪 Biscuits
More

Coffee shop offers calm atmosphere with big airy windows and power outlets. PB&J toast shines with rich flavor and pairs well with avocado toast. Breakfast sandwiches on fresh biscuits deliver strong flavor with spicy mayo and tomato tapenade.

People are saying

"I loved the spacious vibe and tasty food."

"The coffee and drinks here are top-notch."

"The breakfast sandwich here is incredible, especially on a fresh biscuit."

Good to know

1

This café does NOT have wifi.

2

Reservations are recommended at Trends, especially on weekends.

3

They do not accept bills larger than $20.

05
Hani’s bakery + café image 1
Hani’s bakery + café image 2
Hani’s bakery + café image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🥪 Breakfast Sandwich
🍫 Hot Chocolate
🎂 Cheesecake
More

Long, narrow space with minimalist design and thoughtful details creates a warm, cozy atmosphere despite limited seating. Busy and popular, it offers counter seating where people watch pastry making, adding to the inviting vibe. Dog-friendly touches and outdoor seating extend the welcoming feel.

People are saying

"The pastries are creative and mostly delicious, though some feel too sweet or pricey."

"Some loved the peanut butter and jelly cake, others found it lacking."

"I wish they’d bring back the peanut butter and jelly cake."

Good to know

1

Be prepared to wait for a seat on weekends due to high demand.

2

Seating is limited, and most customers opt for takeout.

3

The price for three pastries is around $40.

06
Curley's Bagels image 1
Curley's Bagels image 2
Curley's Bagels image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🥪 Breakfast Sandwich
🐟 Whitefish
🏘️ Local Spot
More

Bagel shop with a clean, renovated interior and no indoor seating creates an upbeat, lively atmosphere. Benches outside offer a place to sit and enjoy the surroundings. The vibe feels friendly and cozy despite the busy, loud environment.

People are saying

"The bagels here taste fantastic and fresh."

"The coffee and drinks have great flavor."

"I thought that Breakfast Sandwich was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

BEC is available twice a week.

2

This place is take out only.

3

Customers should get there early because there’s always a line.

07
Amy's Bread image 1
Amy's Bread image 2
Amy's Bread image 3
View all
🥪 Breakfast Sandwich
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🛋️ Cozy
🥐 Croissant
More

Small bakery with cozy, quiet atmosphere and exposed brick interior invites relaxed mornings. Seating is limited but comfortable, with some outdoor tables under red umbrellas. Offers a wide selection of breads and pastries praised for quality and flavor.

People are saying

"I love the tasty pastries and cakes here."

"It's a cozy spot with great bread variety."

"The sticky buns here are the best."

Good to know

1

The bakery does not have a restroom available for customers.

2

Expect the ham and cheese biscuits to run out quickly during busy hours.

3

Prices for coffee and quiche are around $12, making them affordable.

08
Daytime image 1
Daytime image 2
Daytime image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🥪 Breakfast Sandwich
🛋️ Cozy
🥐 Croissant
More

Cozy cafe on a quiet side street offers limited seating with sunlit windows filled with plants. The atmosphere is chill and neighborly, though music can be loud for the small space. Frequent crowds form on weekday mornings, creating a lively but tight environment.

People are saying

"I love the chill vibe and great coffee here."

"The sandwiches here are always tasty and fresh."

Good to know

1

Parking in the area is generally a nightmare.

2

The line is generally long and moves slowly.

3

The seating is insufficient at the location.

09
Bagel Market image 1
Bagel Market image 2
Bagel Market image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🥪 Breakfast Sandwich
🥪 BLT
🚫🌾 Gluten Free
More

Spacious bagel shop with plenty of seating both indoors and outdoors, including a quiet terrace. Atmosphere feels casual and buzzing, with a corporate diner vibe and friendly, quick service despite busy crowds. Offers a rare dine-in option for a bagel place, making it convenient for small groups to eat together.

People are saying

"The breakfast sandwiches taste good but feel pricey."

"Some find the breakfast sandwiches great, others not so much."

"I found the breakfast sandwiches to be great."

Good to know

1

You need to order and pay on the right side before waiting for your number.

2

The restaurant closes at 3:30 PM and the kitchen closes 10 minutes prior.

3

The bagel shop is not open on weekends.

10
Best Bagel & Coffee image 1
Best Bagel & Coffee image 2
Best Bagel & Coffee image 3
View all
🥪 Breakfast Sandwich
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🍳 Breakfast
🥯 Bagels
More

Small bagel shop offers wide variety of cream cheese flavors and customizable bagels with an impressive assembly line. Seating includes indoor and outdoor tables, though space can feel crowded and loud with a hectic atmosphere. Menus hang from the ceiling, adding a unique visual element to the space.

People are saying

"The breakfast sandwiches are tasty and let you pick your bagel."

"I found the breakfast sandwich to be amazing."

"I got an amazing breakfast sandwich really fast."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait of up to 30 minutes during rush hour from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m.

2

Seating is limited, and it gets crowded at peak times.

3

The shop closes at 4 p.m., so plan your visit accordingly.