Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots for Sicilian pizza perfect for celebrations in New York City

Based on 813 Reviews
+810
User
User
User
Updated
01
Amuni image 1
Amuni image 2
Amuni image 3
View all
๐ŸŽ‰ Celebration
๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡น Italian Food
๐Ÿฅ— Salad
More

Backyard patio offers a cozy outdoor space with Sicilian-style plants that create a home-like atmosphere. Small and intimate setting feels casual and real, resembling a neighborhood spot rather than a gourmet or hip restaurant.

People are saying

"I love the authentic Sicilian dishes and fresh flavors."

"Vincent's personal touch makes dining special here."

"It's a small spot with a cozy vibe."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers authentic Sicilian and Italian specialties.

2

Reservations are recommended for large groups or special events.

3

The restaurant has a lovely patio for outdoor dining.

02
Brooklyn's Homeslice Pizzeria II image 1
Brooklyn's Homeslice Pizzeria II image 2
Brooklyn's Homeslice Pizzeria II image 3
View all
๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐ŸŽ‰ Celebration
๐ŸŒ™ Late Night Spot
๐Ÿ• Pizza
More

Bright, clean pizzeria with a modern take on a classic style offers a comfortable, lively atmosphere with good music and positive energy. The place feels fuss-free and inviting, attracting people who appreciate top-quality pizza and a warm vibe.

People are saying

"I think this place has some of the best pizza around."

"I love how clean and fresh this place feels."

"The grandma and Sicilian slices are seriously delicious."

Good to know

1

The place is open late, making it perfect for a late night snack.

2

There is no parking available; paid street parking is required.

3

The price of cheese slices is $2.75, and 2 slices cost $5.00.

03
Giacomo's Pizza and Restaurant image 1
Giacomo's Pizza and Restaurant image 2
Giacomo's Pizza and Restaurant image 3
View all
๐ŸŽ‰ Celebration
๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐Ÿ• Margherita Pizza
๐Ÿ• White Pizza
More

Pizza restaurant offers indoor and outdoor seating with big windows providing a spectacular view. Atmosphere feels cozy and well decorated, with a lively vibe supported by music and a dedicated party space. Guests enjoy a notable wine and beer selection alongside highly praised pizza.

People are saying

"The pizza slices were big, tasty, and hit the spot."

"The cocktails and beers were tasty and well chosen."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm with discounted drinks and appetizers.

2

The breakfast pizza slice is available only until 12 PM.

3

You can get 5 large slices of a random variety of pizza for $5-6.

04
Emmy Squared Pizza: Midtown West image 1
Emmy Squared Pizza: Midtown West image 2
Emmy Squared Pizza: Midtown West image 3
View all
๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐ŸŽ‰ Celebration
๐Ÿ˜Ž Chill
๐Ÿฝ๏ธ Lunch Spot
More

Dark minimalist interior sets a laid-back atmosphere with bar seats and large TVs showing sports. The vibe is warm and inviting, blending a cozy feel with lively energy from music and game broadcasts. Seating is ample, supporting both casual gatherings and relaxed dining.

People are saying

"I loved the fresh ingredients and great vibe here."

"The pizza tastes good but feels pricey sometimes."

"I keep coming back because I really like it."

Good to know

1

Expect a 20-25 minute wait for pizza during peak hours.

2

Reservations are not required, and seating is usually available.

3

The restaurant does not sell pizza by the slice.

05
La Villa image 1
La Villa image 2
La Villa image 3
View all
๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐ŸŽ‰ Celebration
๐Ÿฅ˜ Food
๐Ÿฝ๏ธ Dinner Spots
More

Small, intimate restaurant with wood-burning oven and stylish decor creates a warm, family vibe reminiscent of Italy. Atmosphere is cozy yet lively, often noisy with a casual but cool setting. Outdoor seating adds flexibility to the dining experience.

People are saying

"The food is delicious and the place feels cozy."

"I can't wait to come back here soon."

"The food tastes fresh and really delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant can host large parties, accommodating over 20 people.

2

Reservations are recommended for large groups to ensure availability.

3

The NYC special pizza is available for takeout.

06
Surf City Pizzeria image 1
Surf City Pizzeria image 2
Surf City Pizzeria image 3
View all

Surf City Pizzeria

๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐ŸŽ‰ Celebration
๐Ÿฆž Seafood
๐Ÿฝ๏ธ Dinner Spots
More

Decor mimics a 1940s pizzeria with old Italian music and real flowers on tables. Atmosphere feels cozy and lively, with both indoor and outdoor lounge seating. A Zoltar fortune teller machine adds a unique touch amid friendly, energetic vibes.

People are saying

"The pizza tastes authentic and really hits the spot."

"I highly recommend trying this place when you're nearby."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times during summer weekends due to high foot traffic.

2

Parking can be challenging; allow extra time to find a spot.

3

The pizzeria is located right across from the Cyclone roller-coaster.

07
Il Piccolo Bufalo image 1
Il Piccolo Bufalo image 2
Il Piccolo Bufalo image 3
View all
๐ŸŽ‰ Celebration
๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐Ÿ›‹๏ธ Cozy
๐Ÿฝ๏ธ Lunch Spot
More

Open-air dining with authentic Italian feel and Little Italy flair creates a chill atmosphere. Decor includes adorable buffalos lining booths and a visible brick oven adding to the theme. Music inside is fantastic, enhancing the overall vibe.

People are saying

"The food was hit or miss, but some dishes stood out."

"I loved the laid-back vibe and some tasty dishes here."

Good to know

1

An 18% tip is automatically added to the bill.

2

The restaurant requires cash payments; card payments incur additional fees.

3

Expect to pay full price for menu items, as specials may not apply.

08
Lazzara's Pizza Cafe image 1
Lazzara's Pizza Cafe image 2
Lazzara's Pizza Cafe image 3
View all

Lazzara's Pizza Cafe

๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐ŸŽ‰ Celebration
๐Ÿ›‹๏ธ Cozy
๐Ÿ’Ž Hidden Gems
More

Second-story setting with an old-school, regal feel and tin stamped ceiling creates a cozy, authentic New York atmosphere. Small and intimate space fits about 20 people, offering a quiet retreat from city noise. Music and TV screens add casual energy while maintaining a warm, welcoming vibe.

People are saying

"The pizza tasted good but seemed pricey and sweet."

"I think this place has some of the best pizza around."

"Lots recommend it, but some say watch out."

Good to know

1

They donโ€™t offer pizza by the slice; only half or whole pies are available.

2

If there are two or more of you, youโ€™re required to order a whole pizza.

3

Expect a line during peak hours, but wait times are usually 15-20 minutes.

09
Pizza Boy II image 1
Pizza Boy II image 2
Pizza Boy II image 3
View all
๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐ŸŽ‰ Celebration
๐Ÿ• Pizza
๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡น Italian Food
More

Small space with homey vibe and local charm offers a quiet atmosphere despite busy surroundings. Outdoor seating provides a decent option for dining. Known for authentic, classic NYC-style pizza with some of the best slices in the area.

People are saying

"I love coming here for great pizza every time."

"The pizza always tastes fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

Pizza slice costs $4.50, and a margherita pizza is $25 over the phone.

2

Pizza Boy II accepts card and Apple Pay for convenience.

3

You can get 2 slices and a soda for $5.50.

10
Bar Primi Penn District image 1
Bar Primi Penn District image 2
Bar Primi Penn District image 3
View all
๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐ŸŽ‰ Celebration
๐Ÿคฉ Lively
โšก Energetic
More

Spacious Italian restaurant with jaw-dropping design and a gorgeous outdoor patio featuring a fireplace and bar. Vibrant and lively atmosphere, often loud, suited for groups and social gatherings. Well-curated wine list and distinctive cocktails complement the energetic vibe.

People are saying

"I love the great vibe and tasty food here."

"The desserts, especially the strawberry fantasia, are amazing."

Good to know

1

Reservations should be made a week before visiting the restaurant.

2

Expect a line out the door before dinner service starts at 5 PM.

3

The restaurant is suitable for groups with a decent menu and wine options.