Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Cookies and cream milkshakes in New York

A chocolate milkshake with the texture of cookies and cream is exactly what is needed.

Based on 702 Opinions
+699
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Bareburger image 1
Bareburger image 2
Bareburger image 3
View all
Hamburger restaurant

Small space offers a cozy, family-friendly vibe with chic decor and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Music plays softly, creating a relaxed energy. A bar serves gluten-free and affordable beers, complementing the handcrafted burgers and sliders.

People are saying

"I found the burgers here juicy and delicious."

"The gluten-free options here are plentiful and amazing."

"You have to try the chocolate milkshake; it's the very best."

Good to know

1

The $1 PBR happy hour is from 12-7 PM, Monday to Friday.

2

The restaurant offers a BOGO Taco Tuesday deal.

3

They have specials during the week, including tacos on Tuesdays and ice cream sundaes on Sundays.

02
Vegan On The Fly image 1
Vegan restaurant

Narrow indoor space contrasts with a heated outdoor patio under a canopy. Rich, creamy chocolate milkshake shines with a strong flavor, while cookies and cream milkshakes vary, some perfectly sweet, others with a weird aftertaste. Atmosphere mixes vulgar music inside with immaculate vibes outside.

Rich and creamy with a strong chocolate flavor, the milkshake stands out as a highlight. The PB & Chocolate version adds a tasty twist that blends peanut butter smoothly with chocolate.

People are saying

"The vegan chopped cheese is exactly what I was looking for."

"The gyro here is so good, like a halal cart."

"You have to try their amazing milkshake; it's a must-have."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is takeout only until further notice.

2

The restaurant offers a meat-free platter and loaded fries on Fridays.

3

There is no public restroom available at the restaurant.

03
Hershey's Chocolate World image 1

Chocolate shop buzzes with immersive sensory experience and colorful decor. Milk Chocolate Milkshake offers a rich, creamy texture with deep flavor. Cookies and Cream shake balances sweetness with a smooth, chocolatey finish in the Sโ€™mores bar.

Milk Chocolate Milkshake stands out with its rich, creamy texture and deep chocolate flavor. It pairs well with other chocolate creations like Hershey's Kisses and s'mores.

Cookies and cream shake stands out with a rich, creamy texture and balanced sweetness. The Sโ€™mores with cookies & cream bar combines classic flavors with a smooth, chocolatey finish.

People are saying

"I found a really varied selection of Hershey's Chocolate here."

"It's a fun, kid-friendly experience with interactive chocolate making."

"You have to try the Cookies and Cream milkshake; it's so good."

Good to know

1

Hershey's central location in Times Square makes it easily accessible.

2

The establishment only accepts plastic payments.

3

There are no restrooms available for anyone, including paying customers.

04
5 Napkin Burger image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Hamburger restaurant with butcher shop decor and an open layout featuring large windows for people watching. Atmosphere ranges from quiet and cozy during dinner to loud and busy near Times Square. Outdoor terrace seating with heaters adds a comfortable option for cooler weather.

People are saying

"The food here is attentive and professional."

"I found the burgers to be juicy and packed with flavor."

"You have to try the onion rings; they're amazing and huge!"

Good to know

1

Booking a reservation is recommended to avoid a wait.

2

Five Napkin has 2 Happy Hours most days: M-F from 3-6 and S-Th 9-close.

3

Going during Happy Hour makes the food much cheaper.

05
Cubby's image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Small hamburger restaurant offers a warm, fun atmosphere with non-screen tabletop games that engage all ages. Clean, open space features marble counters and nostalgic decor with a youthful twist. Burgers stand out as a distinctive culinary highlight in the city.

The cookies and cream shake stands out with a rich, creamy texture and strong cookie flavor. It sits alongside other flavors like sโ€™mores chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry.

People are saying

"I thought the burgers here were amazing and high quality."

"The milkshakes here are amazing, truly next level."

"You have to try the burgers; they're the best in Hell's Kitchen."

Good to know

1

You need to pay cash to avoid the credit card fee.

2

Cubby's has a deal for Beacon students: burger, fries, soda, and ice cream for $15.

3

Take out is available for those on the go.

06
Fulton Burger Park Slope ( Brooklyn ) image 1

Exposed brick walls and clean, cozy interiors create a casual and relaxed vibe. Quiet atmosphere with well-chosen music and friendly energy invites comfortable dining. Burgers come with crispy fries, and gloves are provided to keep hands clean, adding a thoughtful touch.

The cookies and cream milkshake stands out with its rich, creamy texture and balanced sweetness. It blends crushed cookies smoothly into the shake for a satisfying treat.

People are saying

"These burgers are juicy, flavorful, and made with high-quality meat."

"These sweet potato fries are perfectly crispy and flavorful."

"I had the best truffle burger I've ever eaten."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has a $13.50 lunch special available until 4 PM.

2

A gluten-free bun is available for those with dietary restrictions.

3

Fries are included with all burger orders.

07
Jerrell's BETR BRGR image 1
Vegan restaurant

Outdoor seating dominates with limited indoor space, creating a casual, takeout-focused setting. Warm and inviting atmosphere blends with a neighborhood greasy spoon vibe. Staff generosity and unique burger presentation add to the experience.

The cookies and cream milkshake stands out for its creamy texture and filling quality, almost like pudding. The chocolate version impresses with rich flavor, making it a popular choice over vanilla.

People are saying

"I thought the vegetarian burger was one of the best I ever had."

"The waffle fries here are delicious and cooked to perfection."

"The chili fries were rich, hearty, and among the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Everything on the menu is completely vegan.

2

The seating is all outdoor, which may not be ideal on a super hot summer day.

3

You have to order online as there wasn't anyone taking in-person orders.

08
Burger By Day image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Bright, modern space with colorful walls and inspired photos creates a vibrant atmosphere. Music played by staff adds to the friendly, welcoming vibe that suits relaxing with friends. Seating is limited but sufficient, blending a cozy feel with a clean, cheery environment.

Cookies and cream appears as a creamy, solid ice cream that can be quite frozen. The shake delivers a classic cookies and cream flavor that matches expectations well.

People are saying

"These smash burgers are delicious and cooked just right."

"I thought the chicken sandwich was the best I have ever had."

"The tater tots here are really crispy."

Good to know

1

The pricing is reasonable, ranging from $6 to $15 depending on the meal.

2

Meals come with a burger, sliders, and a drink of your choice.

3

Thereโ€™s no space to sit since vendors occupy all the tables and chairs.

09
Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer - 35th St image 1

Hamburger restaurant with nostalgic 90โ€™s wall art and a roof terrace bar overlooking a city landmark. Loud music and multiple TVs create a busy, energetic atmosphere that can make conversation difficult. Offers heated outdoor seating and a lively bar area popular for cocktails.

Milkshake has a rich chocolate flavor and a smooth texture. It pairs well with burgers and fries.

Shakes here feature a Cookies and Cream CrazyShake known for its rich flavor and creamy texture. The Cookies 'n Cream Supreme milkshake stands out as a signature choice, often paired with other popular shakes like strawberry shortcake.

People are saying

"You have to try the milkshakes; they're the biggest and best I've ever had."

"I tasted the best burger I have ever had."

"I enjoyed the Cookies and Cream shake; it was delicious and worth the hype."

Good to know

1

Happy hour menu features discounted items, perfect for budget-friendly dining.

2

Customers must seat themselves and order via their phone from the table.

3

Reservations are not accepted; expect a wait during peak hours.

Discover more

New York, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...