Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Cookie spots in Central Park West Historic District

A fresh cookie is the only thing that will fix this craving.

Based on 122 Opinions
+119
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Levain Bakery image 1
Levain Bakery image 2
Levain Bakery image 3
View all

Small, modern bakery offers incredible cookies with rich, dense textures and bold flavors like dark chocolate peanut butter. Quaint interior creates a social media-worthy vibe with warm, sweet aromas. Limited seating adds to the cozy atmosphere perfect for enjoying treats.

Cookies here have a rich, dense texture and come in flavors like dark chocolate peanut butter and lemon. They taste incredibly delicious and stand out as some of the best ever eaten.

People are saying

"I found the cookies here to be large and perfectly soft."

"I found the cake here to be unique and delicious."

"I loved their baguette with butter and jam."

Good to know

1

Eating inside Levain Bakery is not allowed; it is a take-out only location.

2

There is usually a very long line outside Levain.

3

If you want a hot cookie, you need to mention it while ordering, not after.

02
By the Way Bakery image 1

Small bakery offers gluten-free treats like almond and chocolate chip cookies with rich flavors. Space is festive and cute, perfect for safe, tasty options without cross contamination. Brownie cookies and coconut cake add unique, dairy-free delights.

Gluten-free and dairy-free options include almond cookies and chocolate chip cookies that are well decorated. Brownie cookies and coconut cake also stand out among the cookie selections.

People are saying

"I loved their gluten-free cakes; they were so moist and flavorful."

"These allergen-friendly desserts are the best I've ever had."

"I found the gluten-free cookies to be amazing."

Good to know

1

The bakery is gluten free and dairy free.

2

You can find many gluten-free pastries, cakes, and sweets at this bakery.

3

There is no place to sit in the bakery.

03
Délice Macarons image 1

Traditional French patisserie offers a warm atmosphere with indoor and outdoor seating. Chocolate chip cookies deliver rich flavor, while authentic macarons and almond croissants showcase true Parisian charm.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with a rich, satisfying flavor. Other treats like kouign amann and Almond Croissant also deliver excellent texture and taste.

People are saying

"These macarons are delicious with potent, satisfying flavor."

"I thought the croissant was the best I've ever had."

"You have to try the chocolate chip cookie; it's exceptional."

Good to know

1

You should go early to Délice Macarons because they sell out fast.

2

There is a line out the door every weekend morning.

3

The baguettes are only available on the weekend.

04
Sandwell image 1
Sandwich shop

Small sandwich shop shines with in-house baked bread and a cozy, well-lit space. Cookies stand out with Nutella-inspired flavors and a gluten-free option. Busy vibe and classic rock music add energy to the fresh, affordable menu.

Cookies here come in soft, chewy oatmeal and crispy varieties. Nutella-inspired flavors and a gluten-free option add tasty choices.

People are saying

"I found the sandwiches here to be super tasty and delicious."

"I thought the bread was probably the best sandwich bread I have ever had."

"These homemade cookies are soft, chewy, and wonderful."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers gluten-free bread and breadcrumbs for sandwiches.

2

Expect longer wait times due to limited staff preparing food.

3

The price for a gluten-free sandwich is $12, which is reasonable for the area.

05
La Farine Pâtisserie et Café image 1

Bright, elegant bakery offers a Parisian atmosphere with cozy seating and natural light. Chocolate chip cookies are gooey and flavorful, while Madeline cookies bring a light citrusy taste. Upstairs lounge and outdoor tables make it perfect for relaxing or working.

Chocolate chip cookies come out perfectly gooey and bursting with flavor. Madeline cookies offer a light and citrusy taste that stands out.

People are saying

"The pastries here are phenomenal and taste so balanced."

"It's a cute, cozy spot perfect for a quiet coffee break."

"The chocolate chip cookie is large, flat, and chewy."

Good to know

1

Gloves should be worn when touching food and removed before returning to the register.

2

Expect 8-10 minutes to get your order taken if there's one person ahead.

3

Prices are higher than at Starbucks and other local cafes.

06
Crumbl image 1
Cookie shop

Cookie factory offers fresh baked aroma in a modern, Instagrammable space with visible dough-making. Cookies are warm and soft, each with a unique taste that makes them addictive. Atmosphere stays calm despite crowds in this small, clean, pink-toned shop.

Cookies come out fresh, warm, and soft every time. Each cookie has a unique taste that makes them addictive and amazing.

People are saying

"I found the cookies here to be amazing and delicious."

"These cookies are a huge hit with kids; it's so kid friendly!"

"I found hair in my delivery cookie, it was concerning."

Good to know

1

The kiosk does not accept cash; bring a card for purchases.

2

A box of 4 cookies costs $17.99.

3

The menu changes every week, with new cookies every Monday.

07
Chip City image 1
Dessert shop

Strong aroma of fresh baked cookies fills a cozy, lively space. Unique, creative flavors like the vegan chocolate chip offer a gooey, crispy texture. Frequent flavor changes keep the experience dynamic and exciting.

Cookies come out fresh and delicious with a gooey and crispy texture. The vegan chocolate chip cookie is thick and moist, offering a caky interior and lightly crisp exterior.

People are saying

"These cookies are amazing and super yummy."

"These cookies have unique, decadent flavors and gooey centers."

"The staff is super sweet and really great with kids."

Good to know

1

Chip City has weekly drops of cookies.

2

They only make the Lucky Charms cookie on St Patty's.

3

The earlier you go, the better chance you have at getting limited edition cookies.

08
Sote Coffee Roasters image 1

Cozy shop feels like a rural European home with warm energy and stylish plants. Chocolate chip cookies are perfectly chewy with flaky salt. High-quality beans and excellent pastries make it a must-visit spot.

Chocolate chip cookies come perfectly chewy with flaky salt on top. Options include a scone and muffin, but the cookie stands out for its gooey texture.

People are saying

"I had the best coffee I've ever tasted."

"It's a cozy spot with a genuinely homey feel."

"I found the coffee exceptional, especially the cookie."

Good to know

1

The entrance is stroller and walker friendly with no stairs.

2

The café is super busy on Sunday mornings; arrive early.

3

Expect a wait during peak hours, especially on weekends.

09
Milk Bar image 1
Dessert shop

Cozy space buzzes with great vibes and cute interior. Cornflake and corn cookies offer unique flavors that delight. Music lifts the mood despite the hot, humid air and no seating.

Cornflake cookie and corn cookie stand out with unique flavors. Cookies taste delicious and offer a variety of options.

People are saying

"I thought the cookies here were the best I've ever had."

"The soft serve ice cream here is so creamy and delicious."

"It's a perfect late night spot for a sweet treat."

Good to know

1

Coffee is 50% off after 2pm.

2

Milk Bar advertises a $1 soft serve on the 16th of every month.

3

Desserts are priced at $4 each.

10
Billy's Bakery - Upper West Side image 1

Spacious bakery offers butter cream cookies known for rich flavor and cookie sandwiches with sweet chocolate chip and vanilla. Seating is ample with free WiFi, though atmosphere can feel dim and grimey. Prices vary, some treats are well worth the cost.

Butter cream cookies stand out with their rich flavor and are a frequent choice. Cookie sandwiches, especially the chocolate chip/vanilla combo, offer a tasty option with a bit of sweetness that some might find slightly high.

People are saying

"These cupcakes are truly delicious and taste like real vanilla."

"I loved the delicious chocolate chip and butter cream cookies."

"They went above and beyond to help us with our baby's diaper bag."

Good to know

1

The establishment only accepts card payments.

2

The upper West side location is open until 10:00 p.m.

3

There is no parking available near the bakery.

11
Orwashers Bakery image 1

Bakery offers fresh aroma and lively atmosphere with seating by large windows and outdoor terrace. Black and white cookies shine with rich flavor and great texture. Bread and pastries impress with high quality and distinct tastes.

Black and white cookies stand out with a rich, sweet flavor and a very good texture. Other options include chocolate chip, banana bread, and oatmeal raisin cookies, with some mini cookies priced at $12.50 for six.

People are saying

"The bakery's pastries and breads are perfectly made and delicious."

"Their breads are freshly baked and taste wonderful."

"I found the chocolate chip cookie to be buttery, chewy, and awesome."

Good to know

1

On street parking is a challenge and a matter of luck if you have a car.

2

They only offer paper cups and no ceramic cups.

3

The large latte is overpriced.

12
Crave Fishbar Upper West Side | Raw Bar & Seafood restaurant image 1

Seafood restaurant offers fresh fish dishes in a lively, ship-inspired setting. Warm homemade cookies, especially the huge chocolate chip, make a comforting dessert. Cocktails add to the upscale casual vibe perfect for groups or casual dining.

Warm homemade cookies come with a scoop of ice cream, making a comforting dessert. The chocolate chip cookie stands out as huge and impressive.

People are saying

"I loved the great selection of fresh oysters."

"The staff made me feel like a superstar during Happy Hour."

"The chocolate chip cookie is divine and to die for."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6 PM with discounted cocktails, wine, beer, and food.

2

The restaurant offers an oyster happy hour with oysters priced at $1.50 each on Saturdays.

3

Brunch includes a 'Drink like a fish' option for 90 minutes of unlimited drinks.

13
Holy Schnitzel image 1
Kosher restaurant

Spacious kosher spot shines with art deco ceiling and wood tables. Loud music and a cool chandelier set a lively mood. Freshly baked cookies pair perfectly with rice bowls for a sweet finish.

Cookies come as a sweet treat alongside rice bowls. They have a freshly baked feel and are often shared during meals.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and fresh."

"The Kosher food here is served with amazing, friendly care."

"Ben gave us cookies and was very nice."

Good to know

1

Holy Schnitzel provides a Kosher option on the Upper West Side and Harlem.

2

The ordering is efficient by touch screen.

3

You can call ahead to order for pick up.

14
Noi Due Gelato image 1
Ice cream shop

Cozy shop with ample seating offers a strong waffle aroma and a unique gelato selection including kosher and vegan options. Cookies in cream flavor shines, while some like Lotus feel bland. Pareve cookies and cakes add variety to the menu.

Cookies in cream flavor stands out as a solid choice. Some cookie flavors like Lotus and cookies & cream come off as bland, but the shop offers pareve cookies and cake options too.

People are saying

"The gelato here is amazing and delicious."

"I found the dairy-free gelato options to be amazing and delicious."

"I loved the incredible choices of gelato."

Good to know

1

Noi Due Gelato has kosher certification, ensuring everyone can enjoy their gelato.

2

The gelato shop offers dairy Cholov Yisroel, pareve, and special holiday flavors.

3

Good non-dairy and vegan options are available.

15
Insomnia Cookies image 1
Dessert shop

Small, clean shop offers warm, fresh cookies with a tempting smell that draws crowds. Friendly service adds to the welcoming atmosphere. Known for late-night treats, it’s perfect for a sweet stop after bars.

Warm, fresh baked cookies fill the air with a tempting smell. The chocolate peanut butter cookie melts in your mouth, and the service is consistently friendly and welcoming.

People are saying

"These cookies are warm, soft, and absolutely delicious."

"The chocolate chunk Brookie was soft, warm, and delectable."

"The delivery was quick and the cookies tasted really good."

Good to know

1

The store may not open on time; check before visiting.

2

Orders through Uber Eats often face fulfillment issues due to inventory.

3

Vegan cookies are advertised but may not be available.

16
Picky Barista image 1
Coffee shop

Small coffee shop offers a cozy vibe with wood decor and books for a relaxed feel. Cookies taste homemade, with the walnut meringue standing out and vanilla priced at one dollar. Plenty of indoor and outdoor seating with open garage doors adds fresh air and comfort.

Cookies have a made-at-home taste and are not too sweet. Vanilla cookies sell for one dollar each but are small, while the walnut meringue cookie stands out as good.

People are saying

"I thought the coffee here was excellent and delicious."

"It's a super cozy place, perfect for reading."

"The staff here are so welcoming and kind, making the cookies even the cookies feel of the cookie experience warm."

Good to know

1

There is a happy hour at this place.

2

The Picky Barista location holds events like standup comedy.

3

This coffee shop doesn't allow computers on the weekend.

17
maman image 1
Coffee shop

Cozy space with exposed brick and floral decor offers a family-oriented vibe and quiet chats. Chocolate chip cookies shine with rich flavor, while unique tahini and chocolate cookies complement the specialty baked goods.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with or without nuts, showing high quality and rich flavor. The tahini cookie and chocolate cookie also offer unique tastes that complement the excellent pastries.

People are saying

"I thought the coffee was good, especially the salted tahini latte."

"The ham and cheese croissant was perfectly balanced and delicious."

"I found the chocolate chip cookie to be amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

The café stops food service at 4 PM and only serves pastries afterward.

2

Expect long lines, especially on weekends.

3

The café is a no-laptop zone, so plan accordingly.

18
William Greenberg Desserts image 1

Bakery shines with authentic black and white cookies featuring traditional icing and cakey texture. Pastries are affordable and diverse, pleasing many tastes. Gluten-free treats stand out for great flavor, filling a key gap for dietary needs.

Black and white cookies here are super cakey with authentic flavor and traditional icing colors. Gluten-free options taste great and fill a big gap for those avoiding gluten.

People are saying

"I came here for the iconic Black And White Cookie."

"Their chocolate seven-layer cake is insane, with pillowy cake."

"I came for the iconic black and white cookie."

Good to know

1

The shop has a good selection of gluten-free options.

2

Visitors can pop into the bakery while strolling along Amsterdam.

3

They offer a variety of baked goods beyond just cookies.

19
Alice's Tea Cup image 1

Small tea house offers a whimsical Alice in Wonderland theme and soft cookies with a delicate crust. Kids love wearing fairy wings and fairy dust, adding fun. Outdoor seating stays cozy with heat lamps despite the compact space.

Soft cookies with a delicate crust stand out here. They pair well with jams and clotted cream for added flavor.

People are saying

"I thought the scones were super delicious and the best I've had."

"The tea shop's Alice in Wonderland theme makes it feel magical and cute."

"The Alice in Wonderland decor is a delightful touch."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for weekend brunch to ensure seating.

2

Brunch is only available on weekends, with a limited menu.

3

High tea and lunch menus are offered on weekdays.

20
Modern Bread and Bagel image 1

Gluten-free bakery shines with best gluten-free bagels and black and white cookies that offer generous portions and great taste. Outdoor seating includes a heated patio with benches, creating a modern and inviting vibe despite limited indoor space. Service moves slow but the artisanal bread is worth the wait.

Black and white cookies stand out with a delish taste and generous portions, sometimes including extras for free. The rainbow cookie offers a delightful alternative with a sweet, colorful twist.

People are saying

"I found the gluten-free bagels to be the best I've ever had."

"I found amazing vegan options, like cream cheese and cupcakes."

"I can't believe how amazing these bagels are, even gluten-free!"

Good to know

1

Everything at this place is gluten free.

2

The entire restaurant is dedicated gluten-free, making it a must-visit for any Celiac or gluten-sensitive people.

3

You should order ahead and pick it up to avoid waiting in the long line.

21
Patis Bakery image 1
French restaurant

Small bakery offers chocolate toffee cookies with rich flavor and a nice variety of baked goods. Cozy seating and chic decor create a warm, bright vibe like a European coffee shop. Loud rap music adds energy but can make conversations hard to hear.

Chocolate toffee cookies stand out with their rich flavor. A nice selection of cookies and baked goods fills the display.

People are saying

"I loved the coffee and lattes here."

"I found the kosher pastries here to be the most delicious I ever had."

"I thought their chocolate chip cookies were soft and among the best."

Good to know

1

Credit cards are not accepted; cash only for payments.

2

The establishment closes at 10 PM, so plan your visit accordingly.

3

They charge an automatic 15% tip before service is provided.

22
Peacefood - Upper West Side image 1

Open layout and close tables create a loud, bustling atmosphere with constant kitchen noise. Vegan desserts shine with a Grasshopper cookie and a unique cookie sandwich. Hipster vibe blends relaxed, cozy elements with energetic service and outdoor seating.

Vegan desserts include a Grasshopper cookie and a cookie sandwich that stands out. Cookies range from gooey and crispy textures to double chocolate chip paired with cheesecake for balance.

People are saying

"This dairy-free place has truly delightful, creative vegan food."

"This lunch spot's un-chicken cutlet was crisp and tasty."

"The grasshopper cookie sandwich with vegan mint cream is huge."

Good to know

1

Expect at least an hour and a half wait if ordering online.

2

The bakery only sells slices of cake and does not sell whole cakes.

3

The restaurant has a policy that prohibits customers from eating outside food.

23
Mast Market image 1
Organic food store

Organic food store offers artisan goods and local produce in a sleek, cozy space. Chocolate chip cookies are fresh and flavorful, packed in disposable containers. Enjoy high-quality coffee and unique ice cream flavors in a lively, family-friendly setting.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with their great flavor and freshness. Cookies come in disposable plastic containers for single use.

People are saying

"The coffee here is great, and the staff is super friendly."

"This market has a wonderfully chill atmosphere and welcoming staff."

"I thought the chocolate chip cookie here was great."

Good to know

1

Seating at the café is fairly limited.

2

The prices at the café/market are quite expensive.

3

You receive a $1 credit when you bring back the glass bottles.

24
Barachou Upper West Side image 1

Tiny bakery offers a cozy spot with charming atmosphere and fresh scents. Creme brulee cookie shines with rich flavor, while chocolate chip cookies can be dry. Known for exceptional cream puffs and delicious pastries, it draws those seeking quality treats.

The creme brulee cookie stands out with a rich flavor that lingers. Chocolate chip cookies tend to be dry and inconsistent, sometimes disappointing.

People are saying

"These croissants are the best I've had, even better than in France."

"I found the passion fruit cream puff life-changing."

"I'd definitely try the flan cake again; it's a solid choice."

Good to know

1

Currently, there is only room for one party to sit down.

2

You need to visit at an off-time if you want to sit down.

3

Prices for cream puffs start at $3+, and tarts are $6-7.

Discover more

Central Park West Historic District, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...