Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to New York

Cool makeup stores

A makeup store that feels genuinely cool, rather than just another sterile retail environment.

Based on 542 Opinions
+539
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
DIGISO image 1
DIGISO image 2
DIGISO image 3
View all
Health and beauty shop

Small shop filled with wide variety of Korean skincare and makeup alongside Asian snacks and cute collectibles. Atmosphere feels calming and comfortable with clean, organized layout and lively music. Offers affordable products but no returns on skincare or makeup.

Offers a wide selection of Korean makeup and skincare products that are affordable and popular. Includes unique beauty items alongside blind boxes and cute charms.

Vibe feels very cool and cute with a relaxed atmosphere. The place stands out as genuinely cool without trying too hard.

People are saying

"This skincare store has a great selection of K-beauty products."

"I found the Korean makeup and skincare here to be really cute and affordable."

"This makeup store has so many great Korean beauty products."

Good to know

1

The store offers a wide range of skincare and makeup products.

2

Expect to find affordable Korean skincare and makeup options.

3

The selection includes snacks alongside beauty items.

02
Abracadabra image 1
Costume store

Huge costume store filled with horror, goth, punk, and drag outfits and scenographic decorations creates a spooky, immersive atmosphere. Magic trick demonstrations and a resident magician add interactive entertainment. Frequented by fans of cosplay and Halloween, it offers an extensive selection for all ages.

Offers a wide selection of SFX makeup, prosthetics, and glittery makeup products. Provides professional makeup services with impressive results at higher prices.

Magic trick demonstrations deliver epic wow moments. The store offers a wide selection of SFX makeup, contact lenses, prosthetics, masks, and costumes that feel one-of-a-kind.

People are saying

"This makeup store has a wide variety of glittery products."

"This place is so cool, with tons of options and accessories."

"I found so many fun Halloween activities and decorations here."

Good to know

1

Costumes range from $50 for simple ones to $120 for more elaborate ones.

2

The store has a no refunds/exchange policy.

3

The online inventory does not match what is in store.

03
Glossier NYC image 1
Beauty supply store

Store resembles an art installation with a subway-themed design and pink pastel tones. Atmosphere feels modern and welcoming, encouraging product experimentation without pressure. Amenities include a selfie station, claw game, and comfortable seating with free Wi-Fi.

A friendly staff explains products in detail and helps find specific makeup needs. The space feels like a comfortable lab for experimenting with high-quality cosmetics and includes exclusive items supporting local charity.

Conveyor belt technology stands out as a cool feature. The store's design targets girls but feels very modern. Service also feels super cool and tech-savvy.

People are saying

"The makeup store staff are so friendly and knowledgeable."

"It's a relaxing spot with a modern, welcoming atmosphere and sofas to rest."

"The employees here are so nice and friendly, it's rare."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait of about 30 minutes before entry due to capacity limits.

2

The store is wheelchair accessible with a ramp located to the right upon entry.

3

Prices for items start around $10, making them great for souvenirs.

04
Lip Lab Soho image 1
Cosmetics store

Small space with bright artificial lighting and comfortable seating creates a chill atmosphere. Energy feels inviting and kind, encouraging creativity and relaxation. Appointments are required, and the experience focuses on crafting custom lipsticks with attention to color and texture.

Offers a custom makeup experience where products are made exactly to your request. Provides a fun, hands-on way to create cosmetics.

Watching the custom lipstick manufacturing process live feels very cool and unique. The ability to fully customize your lipstick to personal preferences adds a distinct touch to the experience.

People are saying

"The staff here makes creating your own lipstick and lip gloss a fun activity."

"I loved customizing my lipstick shade, finish, scent, and even naming it."

"It's so cool you can customize the entire lipstick."

Good to know

1

Appointments are needed at Lip Lab Soho.

2

Expect a $20 fee per person for the party package with a minimum spend of $65.

3

Your custom shade can be re-purchased easily, and re-purchases are about 30% less expensive than the initial tube.

05
Macy's image 1
Department store

Nine-story department store spans a city block with original wooden escalators dating back to the 1920s, creating a unique historical feature. Bright lighting and large seasonal displays contribute to a grand and welcoming atmosphere. Families frequent the spacious playroom, while shoppers enjoy convenient amenities like an on-site pub and quick-service food options.

Offers a wide variety of cosmetics and fragrances including Mac makeup. Prices can be very good during special offers, with options suitable for teenagers and luxury beauty products available.

Wooden escalators stand out as a cool feature to see in person. Plenty of photo opportunities for kids add to the fun atmosphere despite the building's age.

People are saying

"I found Macy's to be a huge department store selling just about everything."

"This Makeup Store is huge and has a wide variety of beauty products."

"The old wooden escalators are really cool and historical."

Good to know

1

Macy's hosts seasonal events and the famous Thanksgiving Day Parade.

2

Students should carry their student ID to receive discounts.

3

Reservations are now required to enter Macy's.

06
Saks Fifth Avenue image 1
Department store

Department store offers luxurious atmosphere with spacious layout and designer merchandise across many floors. Exterior features impressive light shows and elegant decorations that create a festive vibe. Shoppers find unique brands and a stylish, well-organized environment throughout.

Offers a huge variety of high-end cosmetics from brands like Dior and Tom Ford. Staff like Julie, Luis, and Ivanna provide knowledgeable help, and makeup artists such as Charnelle create a comfortable experience.

A very cool light show runs at night, adding a unique vibe. The building shows great architectural value with interesting details like the elevators on lower floors.

People are saying

"The service here is truly luxurious, with attentive staff and stunning packaging."

"I thought the light shows here were really cool, especially during the holidays."

"The staff at the Makeup Store's cosmetic section are so helpful."

Good to know

1

Saks often hosts exclusive events and promotions.

2

Returning items in-store provides a faster refund than returning by mail.

3

If they donโ€™t have an item, they can always get it in a few days for store pick up or home delivery.

Discover more

New York, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...