Big space with rustic wood interior and low lighting creates an intimate, classic vibe. Atmosphere shifts from understated elegance to a louder, sports bar-like energy. Known for incredible pizza with perfect crusts and a quirky, pizza-themed decor.
"The place has a cozy, vibey atmosphere I enjoy."
"I loved the unique flavors and fresh pizzas."
Good to know
Get there early as it fills up quickly.
They do not take reservations.
You have to order from the app and there is no interaction with a server.
Open kitchen reveals Neapolitan-style pizzas baking in a large brick oven, creating a luxe interior with spacious table arrangements. Atmosphere balances upscale yet unpretentious vibes, with a chill lounge downstairs and lively main floor. Full bar and outdoor seating add to the varied energy throughout the space.
"The pizza tastes just like in Naples and is really big."
"The place has a cozy vibe and the food is delicious."
"The pizza is so thin I need a fork and knife to eat it."
Good to know
Reservations are highly recommended, as the restaurant can reach capacity.
Pizza making classes for adults are offered regularly at the restaurant.
Be mindful of the pre-club crowd on Friday nights after 8PM.
Limelight ™ Original Famous Coal Fired Brick Oven Pizzeria NYC
Old church converted into a lively pizza spot with coal fired brick oven and cheetah print chairs under a disco ball. Atmosphere feels chaotic and cramped, with music from a phenomenal singer adding energy. Outdoor seating offers a great city view away from traffic noise.
"I loved the pizza, but some found it off."
"I think their coal-fired pizza is the best."
"I enjoyed the food and the warm atmosphere there."
Good to know
The restaurant only accepts cash payments, no credit cards.
Pizza is available until 5 AM, perfect for late-night cravings.
Expect a long wait for food during peak hours, especially on weekends.