Top 6 Gluten-Free Ice Cream Shops to Delight in Colorado Springs

Your curated guide to gluten-free dining options, with detailed reviews and recommendations for safe celiac-friendly meals.

Colonel Mustard's Sandwich Emporium

1412 S 21st St, Colorado Springs, CO 80904, USA
Gluten Free IconAccommodating Gluten-Free
Ice CreamSeafoodDeliveryDinnerPet FriendlyKid FriendlyLunchOutdoor SeatingTake AwayVegan OptionsVegetarian OptionsBeerBread ItemsSandwichesBreakfastBrunch
A charming spot featuring a vast selection of mustards, fun ice cream flavors, and a cozy patio with lovely views perfect for relaxing!

People are saying
View more
Stephanie C
Stephanie C
They are excellent with allergy requests! They use local GF breads and it makes going and getting to a sandwich shop so easy! Who knew that you could have gluten-free sandwiches that were so good and so easy to find! Definitely a loyal customer now

Menu
View menu
Gluten-free options are marked

Mici Italian

3707 Bloomington St, Colorado Springs, CO 80922, USA
Gluten Free IconAccommodating Gluten-Free
Ice CreamItalianPizzaAllergen FriendlyDairy Free OptionsDeliveryDinnerKid FriendlyLunchTake AwayVegetarian OptionsVegan OptionsRestaurant
Known for its standout pizza and unique menu options, this spot consistently impresses with flavor and a lively atmosphere.

People are saying
View more
MOLINA FAMILY
MOLINA FAMILY
Quite good…one of few pizza places that offers gluten free. I don’t generally like too much tomato sauce… I forgot to ask for light sauce and It was not until I had almost finished my pizza before I realized it… I have to say I didn’t notice because the sauce is very good. The customer service was excellent! Being from the east coast I’m particular about pizza … and this passes! My only issue is the Gluten free crust could be better 🤷🏻‍♀️Will return for sure! They also offer other gluten free options on their menu :)

Menu
View menu

Josh & John's

329 N Tejon St, Colorado Springs, CO 80903, USA
Gluten Free IconCeliac friendly
Ice CreamDeliveryTake AwayPet FriendlyKid Friendly
With a charming VW bus vibe and an array of unique flavors, this local gem promises a delightful sweet escape and great photo ops!

People are saying
View more
Casey Cromwell
Casey Cromwell
They have gluten free and/or dairy free ice cream flavors clearly marked on the main menu and keep sealed pints of each flavor for allergy orders that they use a clean scooper for. The employee was super educated on allergens & happy to take the extra couple minutes to get my ice cream from the separate pint. We loved my gluten & dairy free pb chocolate ice cream & my bf’s salted peanut butter ice cream!

Menu
View menu
Gluten-free options are marked

Colorado City Creamery

2602 Colorado Ave, Colorado Springs, CO 80904, USA
Gluten Free IconAccommodating Gluten-Free
Ice CreamDeliveryTake AwayKid Friendly
Impressive attention to detail with top-notch service and quick lines, though cleanliness could use some improvement.

People are saying
View more
hilikus 45
hilikus 45
Went Friday night around 9pm. They were very busy but the line moved very quickly. The staff do not seem to clean in between customer as our table was sticky, the floor needed mopped, and the topping bar needed cleaned. All in all the ice cream was very good. Staff was knowledgeable on what was gluten free!

Menu
View menu

Five Star Food Stop

4621 Austin Bluffs Pkwy, Colorado Springs, CO 80918, USA
Gluten-free options
MexicanIce CreamDeliveryTake AwayDessertsGrocery Store
Known for having the best pizza in town with fresh toppings that'll leave you craving more!

People are saying
View more
Catherine Bradley
Catherine Bradley
Gluten Free Pizza was the best in Town! We called and asked they said the Best in town.

Menu
View menu

Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

7866 N Academy Blvd, Colorado Springs, CO 80920, USA
Gluten-free options
Ice CreamDeliveryTake Away

People are saying
View more
Cameron van Batum
Cameron van Batum
Rita’s is one of my favorite places the be because the employees there are so kind! Tonight I stopped into Rita’s, the two girls working were so nice. Claire was so sweet and personable! She made me laugh so hard and helped assist me with finding the best dairy free and gluten free flavors! Faith was so energetic and makes the atmosphere so enjoyable!! I am always so pleased when I come in, but tonight was extra special! I hope they are always working when I come in! If I could rate this more stars I would.

Menu
View menu

© 2025 Atly - Your Local Guide to Gluten-Free Dining