Top 5 Gluten-Free Pizzerias to Delight in Lancaster

Your curated guide to gluten-free dining options, with detailed reviews and recommendations for safe celiac-friendly meals.

Clarksburg Cider

4493 Walden Ave, Lancaster, NY 14086, USA
Gluten Free IconCeliac friendly
PizzaDedicated GF MenuCiderDessertsSandwichesDeliveryOutdoor SeatingBar
A stellar cider house in Clarksburg with dry, small-batch selections and the availability of crowlers; noted for its slightly higher price point.

People are saying
View more
Laura Lee
Laura Lee
The cider here is excellent. Really interesting flavors I really love the strawberry basil. You can get gluten-free buns! They have gluten-free poutine. Which was absolutely delicious. My only issue was with the waitress waitress. The service was adequate. Not exceptional but adequate. We didn't ask for much or anything additional outside of our drinks and dinner. So we were not high maintenance diners. My partner left an 18% or 20% tip. I think it was like either $15 or $20. He just tapped one of the offerings on the machine. He felt this was an adequate tip for the service. The waitress was apparently not happy with the tip and asked us about it before we left. It was extremely uncomfortable and almost shaming. It wasn't like we left a dollar or just some pocket change. I'm not sure if we will be returning as my partner was rather bothered.

Menu
View menu
Dedicated gluten-free menu

Lancaster's Broadway Deli

5430 Broadway, Lancaster, NY 14086, USA
Gluten Free IconAccommodating Gluten-Free
LunchDinnerKid FriendlyTake AwayVegetarian OptionsVegan OptionsDedicated GF Kitchen SpaceBread ItemsFriesPastaPizzaSandwichesCafeDeliveryOutdoor Seating100% GF
A hidden gem with top-notch meat quality and fresh ingredients, plus a variety of tasty options that'll keep you coming back for more!

People are saying
View more
nichole brothers
nichole brothers
We went last weekend for the first time and everything was excellent!!! The portions are huge too and everything is just so fresh and good quality products they use! My boyfriend is gluten free and they can make anything gluten free and take cross contamination very seriously!! We can't wait to go back!!

Menu
View menu

Picasso's Pizza

5413 Broadway, Lancaster, NY 14086, USA
Gluten-free options
LunchDinnerOpen LatePizzaDeliveryTake AwayKid Friendly
Expect consistently great pizza with a unique crunchy thin crust that leaves a lasting impression!

People are saying
View more
Jason Diehl
Jason Diehl
Their pizza overall is great. My girlfriend has celiac disease, and we tried their gluten-free pizza recently. She and i were very impressed as it was very good also. It was a little greasy, but I've noticed that all gluten-free food with crust/breading tends to be that way. Will definitely order from here again!

Menu
View menu


Two Guys Pizza

3987 Walden Ave, Lancaster, NY 14086, USA
Gluten-free options
LunchDinnerOpen LatePizzaDeliveryTake AwayKid FriendlyBread Items

People are saying
View more
Mark Morlock
Mark Morlock
Two guys nailed it!!! The best! Gluten free fingers and gluten free rolls!! No one else around has these two but them!! It was delicious!!

Menu
View menu

© 2025 Atly - Your Local Guide to Gluten-Free Dining