Top 6 Gluten-Free Pizzerias to Enjoy in Central Park West Historic District, New York

316 Columbus Ave, New York, New York, United States
Gluten Free IconCeliac friendly
DeliveryKid FriendlyLunchTake AwayDinner
This Italian spot offers a relaxing and classy ambiance with spacious indoor and charming outdoor areas where pets are welcome. Known for its dedicated gluten-free menu, it provides a welcoming setting ideal for celebrations or casual gatherings, ensuring a comfortable experience for those with gluten sensitivities.

People are saying
View more
Rachel Dawes
Rachel Dawes
AMAZING! This Italian restaurant was so unbelievably delicious and as someone with Celiac, this is my new favorite place! We shared the GIANT gluten free meatball and the garlic cheese bread as apps, he had the regular veal parm and he loved all of it. I had the GF chicken parm, which I haven’t had in years! Portions were enormous and it tasted so good! I will definitely return!!!

Menu
View menu
Dedicated gluten-free menu

502 Amsterdam Ave, New York, New York, United States
Gluten Free IconCeliac friendly
DeliveryKid FriendlyLunchTake AwayDinner
This neighborhood gem offers a cozy vibe and energetic spirit with gluten-free options baked in a separate oven ensuring safety and flavor. The lovely staff and great atmosphere make it a perfect spot for those seeking authentic Italian dining with abundant gluten-free choices.

People are saying
View more
Erik Webb
Erik Webb
I had high hopes after seeing the reviews and the gluten-free options. The owner and staff were surprisingly hostile to our party as first timers, commenting directly to us (and others) throughout the meal about how absurd it was that we did not have cash on hand for payment. Very bizarre, and something I’ve never experienced before. The gluten-free pizza tasted worse than a Domino’s pizza, and was twice the cost ($25). I can’t recommend much about this venue.

Menu
View menu
Gluten-free options are marked

432 Columbus Ave, New York, New York, United States
Gluten Free IconAccommodating Gluten-Free
DeliveryKid FriendlyLunchTake AwayDinner
This cozy, air-conditioned spot offers a relaxing atmosphere with a lovely view near the museum. Known for its friendly staff and gluten-free pizza options, it provides a safe and enjoyable dining experience for those with gluten sensitivities.

People are saying
View more
gabriel vaz
gabriel vaz
best gluten free that my wife have tried

Menu
View menu
Gluten-free options are marked

491 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA
Gluten Free IconCeliac friendly
CafePizza
This kosher dairy spot offers a unique and inviting atmosphere with Israeli-inspired decor and beautiful indoor and outdoor seating. The clean, comfortable setting and attentive service sensitive to gluten allergies make it a welcoming choice for gluten-free diners seeking a real experience.

People are saying
View more
Shiffy Lichtenstein
Shiffy Lichtenstein
Food is consistently wonderful! Love their gluten free pizza. Atef Reyad was our server and he was great!

Menu
View menu
Dedicated gluten-free menu

303 Amsterdam Ave, New York, New York, United States
Unverified
DeliveryKid FriendlyLunchTake AwayDinner
Cozy, old-school pizza spot with gluten-free and dairy-free options, featuring solid crust and fresh toppings.

People are saying
View more
Bonnie Smith
Bonnie Smith

Menu
View menu

421 Amsterdam Ave, New York, New York, United States
Gluten Free IconAccommodating Gluten-Free
DeliveryKid FriendlyLunchTake AwayDinner
This spacious pizzeria features a casual yet roomy atmosphere with both indoor and outdoor seating, including an enclosed street-side dining area. It stands out for its thoughtfully prepared gluten-free options, with careful measures like separate pans and personal pizza cutters to ensure safe, cross-contamination-free dining for those with celiac disease.

People are saying
View more
Jordan Van Maanen
Jordan Van Maanen
I sometimes have to eat gluten free because of my wife. Unfortunately the GF crust just wasn’t that good. Not sure there is GF crust in NY that gets even close to the original crust. I didn’t try the regular pizza but it looked great!

Menu
View menu
Gluten-free options are marked

© 2025 Atly - Your Local Guide to Gluten-Free Dining