Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Williamsburg

Jewelry stores

Made for those who view jewelry as a permanent extension of their wardrobe and only invest in pieces that hold their own.

Based on 616 Opinions
+613
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Keila Jewelry image 1
Keila Jewelry image 2
Keila Jewelry image 3
View all
Jewelry designer

Store blends family-owned warmth with a clean, organized space. Jewelry shines with handmade craftsmanship and offers unique helix and tragus piercing options. Quick sizing and repairs add practical value to the inviting atmosphere.

Custom jewelry features handmade designs with incredible craftsmanship. The store offers a changing selection of high-quality pieces, including options for helix and tragus piercings.

People are saying

"Sandra's kindness and skill at the jewelry store are amazing."

"I had a custom necklace made that was more beautiful than I expected."

"They do amazing, fast watch repair and battery replacement."

Good to know

1

Keila Jewelry offers jewelry repair services at reasonable prices.

2

They provide personalized design services to create custom pieces.

3

The store has a wide selection of jewelry for all budgets.

02
Tivoli Jewelers image 1

Family-owned jeweler offers a welcoming atmosphere with high-quality jewelry and custom fine jewelry. Skilled on-site jewelers provide quick, reliable repairs and work with various budgets. Shop blends authentic pieces with affordable and custom designs.

Wedding rings and custom fine jewelry work happen here with care. Frank handles all types of jewelry work, including repairs, making it a spot for excellent jewelry repair and custom pieces.

People are saying

"Jenny at the Jewelry Store was super helpful with my repair."

"They fixed my necklace and made it look like new, free!"

"Jenny fixed my watch band quickly and efficiently."

Good to know

1

Tivoli offers free necklace shortening services for customers.

2

Jewelry repairs are completed within 2-3 weeks.

3

Tivoli has a variety of jewelry from affordable to high-end custom pieces.

03
Bario Neal image 1
Jewelry designer

Showroom blends minimalist aesthetic with a warm atmosphere that welcomes all. Jewelry offers ethical sourcing and custom engagement rings crafted with care. Staff provide personalized guidance in a clean, secure space.

Custom engagement and wedding rings are crafted with care and ethical values. Staff offers knowledgeable, responsive service and helps find styles that fit individual tastes.

People are saying

"Seth helped me find a beautiful ring that captured my style."

"The staff at this jewelry store are so helpful and thoughtful."

"Seth helped my partner and I design something unique and nontraditional for our Couples."

Good to know

1

Bario Neal creates jewelry with sustainable and recycled materials that are all ethically sourced.

2

The store has a satin finish option for wedding bands, which is unique.

3

The process of getting an appointment is easy and straightforward.

04
Mandala Tibetan Store image 1

Shop offers silver rings with fair prices but mixed durability. Crystals and singing bowls add to the chill vibe. Jewelry quality looks good but may wear fast, so expect some issues with gemstones.

Extensive selection of silver rings priced around $18 to $19 each offers many options. Jewelry quality is visually appealing but shows wear quickly, with rings yellowing and gemstones falling out within a week.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are really kind and helpful."

"Sonam at the Ring Store is a really good guy."

Good to know

1

The prices for rings are either $18 or $19 each.

2

There is an extensive selection of jewelry, singing bowls, clothing, and crystals.

3

The quality of the jewelry is inconsistent, especially with the rings.

05
Rowan Williamsburg image 1
Ear piercing service

Boutique studio shines with hypo-allergenic jewelry that feels fresh and cute. Staff are kind and helpful, creating a cozy vibe. Clean, well-lit space keeps energy fun and welcoming, backed by strict sanitary care.

Hypo-allergenic jewelry stands out here, offering a cute alternative to typical metal ball or bar pieces. Staff are kind and helpful, making it easy to find an amazing set of earrings.

People are saying

"Getting a piercing at this jewelry store was quick, painless, and seamless."

"The staff is so patient and kind with kids."

"They made the piercing process so comfortable and easy."

Good to know

1

Each piercing costs $35, and earrings are an additional $59-250 per hole.

2

All piercings are done by licensed nurses.

3

After getting pierced, a follow-up visit costs an additional $25 per hole.

06
Grand Jewelry Pawn Shop image 1

Shop offers quick repairs on earrings and necklaces with transparent pricing. Selection ranges from small gold hoops to high-end watches like Rolex. Customers enjoy generous valuations and positive energy throughout.

Jewelry repairs on the spot happen quickly, including fixing earrings and broken necklaces. The shop offers a wonderful selection from small gold hoops to high-end watches like Rolex and Patek Philippe, with great customer service throughout.

People are saying

"I found the staff at this jewelry store to be very helpful and attentive."

"They fixed my necklace right in front of me, super quick!"

"The Ring Store staff was so helpful and quick with repairs."

Good to know

1

The jewelry repair shop does excellent work with quick turnaround times.

2

The price for a necklace chain repair is great compared to other places.

3

They offer fair prices for scrap gold and a quick selling process.

07
haricot vert's dreamworld image 1

Former furniture showroom offers a quirky space with unique pictograph charms. Custom earrings crafted by Jess make jewelry high quality and special. Upstairs cafΓ© and quiet workroom create a dreamy atmosphere for creativity and relaxation.

Custom earrings and charms get crafted with help from Jess, making each piece feel special. Jewelry here is high quality and unique, perfect for personal moments like weddings.

People are saying

"I loved creating my unique charm necklace with vintage and picto charms."

"The staff here are super friendly and helpful for all the fun activities."

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so friendly and helpful."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers $5 glasses of wine from 3-5 pm.

2

The 'Creative Charmscapes' workshop is a fun activity for groups.

3

Expect to spend at least $100 on jewelry pieces.

08
IRIS - a piercing studio image 1
Body piercing shop

Small studio offers a warm atmosphere and queer-friendly vibe. Staff are chill and inclusive, making visitors feel safe and cozy. Jewelry selection is high-quality with services like ear piercing and jewelry changes done without pressure.

Multiple visits include ear piercing and jewelry changes. Satisfaction comes from the new jewelry offered.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so kind and patient."

"The staff made me feel so comfortable and welcome."

"The LGBTQ piercers here are talented, funny, and kind."

Good to know

1

Be sure to book an appointment online for availability because they book fast, especially on weekends.

2

The studio is very clean and takes cleanliness very seriously.

3

The pricing for standard jewelry at IRIS is wallet-friendly.

09
Fewer Finer image 1
Jewelry store

Townhouse showroom offers hand engraving that makes each piece unique and refined. Custom jewelry projects transform heirlooms into daily wear rings and bracelets. Engagement rings and wedding bands show deep personal craftsmanship with classic style and a twist.

Custom projects include transforming heirlooms into rings and bracelets worn daily. Engagement rings and wedding bands show care and craftsmanship with deeply personal designs.

People are saying

"I had an awesome experience designing a custom engagement ring."

"This jewelry store's custom designs are creative and thoughtful."

"They helped me create a unique custom design that was exactly what I envisioned."

Good to know

1

Custom designs can take several weeks to complete, so plan ahead.

2

Appointments are recommended for personalized consultations.

3

Returns are accepted within 30 days with a receipt.

10
Fitzgerald Jewelry image 1
Jewelry store

Showroom features original designs and a top-notch selection of jewelry. Custom rings get flexible sizing and expert repair shows exemplary craftsmanship. Classes offer hands-on experience with minimal instructor help in a warm, inviting space.

Custom rings get flexible sizing and detailed design work. Jewelry repair and resizing show exemplary craftsmanship and care. Classes teach hands-on skills with expert guidance.

People are saying

"This jewelry store is amazing for custom pieces and repairs."

"The staff at this Ring Store are so nice and friendly."

"I saw some beautiful and unique pieces of jewelry."

Good to know

1

Fitzgerald Jewelry offers custom jewelry creation services.

2

Classes allow students to work independently with minimal instructor intervention.

3

Expect a 16-day wait for quotes and alterations.

11
Brilliant Earth image 1
Jewelry store

Showroom features a spacious design and a calm, professional vibe. Jewelry includes ethically sourced stones with clear pricing. Staff are warm and helpful, making ring selection educational and organized.

Wide variety of rings sits alongside beautiful jewelry in a welcoming showroom. Staff stays warm and kind without any pushiness, helping pick out perfect wedding rings.

People are saying

"The staff at this Ring Store made my experience so much easier."

"The staff at this jewelry store are so helpful and patient."

"The consultants here offer specialized attention and guidance for your date spots."

Good to know

1

Brilliant Earth offers a smooth appointment booking process for customers.

2

The store provides complimentary water and chocolate during visits.

3

Brilliant Earth has a wide variety of ethically sourced engagement and wedding rings.

12
Mejuri image 1
Jewelry store

Modern jewelry store shines with stylish designs and a welcoming atmosphere. Staff offer personalized advice with kindness, making shopping easy. Spacious, well-lit interiors showcase quality pieces that suit many occasions.

Staff provide personalized sizing and styling advice with patience and kindness. Jewelry features high quality, stylish designs that are well made and long lasting. The store offers a friendly atmosphere and a well stocked selection for various occasions.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so kind and helpful."

"The staff here makes your Date Spots visit fun and safe."

"I got excellent service even though I only bought an affordable piece."

Good to know

1

The Mejuri Williamsburg store has a great selection of jewelry.

2

Not every store welcomes returning items; check the policy before purchasing.

3

This location is less accessible for tourists compared to the one in Soho.

Discover more

Williamsburg, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...