Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots for New York–style pizza with mortadella to Enjoy in New York City

Based on 874 Reviews
+871
User
User
User
Updated
01
Pizzazz image 1
Pizzazz image 2
Pizzazz image 3
View all
🥓 Mortadella
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🍕 Margherita Pizza
🍕 Pizza
More

Small pizza shop with two standing tables and a stone spinning oven that cooks pies evenly. Stylish, modern interior with upbeat music creates a warm and inviting atmosphere. Known for fresh, high-quality ingredients and quick, handcrafted pizzas.

People are saying

"I thought the mortadella sandwich was the best I ever had."

"The mortadella sandwich is the best I've had."

"I loved trying both the mortadella sandwich and pizza."

Good to know

1

There isn’t any indoor seating available at this pizza spot.

2

The entire process from placing the order to leaving takes only 5 minutes.

3

The restaurant imports almost all of their ingredients from Italy for quality.

02
Impasto image 1
Impasto image 2
Impasto image 3
View all
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🥓 Mortadella
🇮🇹 Italian Food
🌱 Vegan Friendly
More

Roman-style pizza with focaccia-style dough and fresh, high-quality ingredients defines the menu, offering multiple vegan options and square pies popular among locals. Takeout and delivery dominate, with limited outside seating available. The atmosphere is casual and focused on quick, flavorful slices rather than dine-in experience.

People are saying

"The Roman-style pizza here tastes fresh and amazing."

"I think this place has the best pizza in Brooklyn."

Good to know

1

The cheapest price for pizza is $3.5 and the most expensive is $10.

2

The price of a small pizza slice is $6.50.

3

The restaurant is only for take-out or delivery.

03
The Parlor Pizza Kitchen Whitestone image 1
The Parlor Pizza Kitchen Whitestone image 2
The Parlor Pizza Kitchen Whitestone image 3
View all
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🥓 Mortadella
🍽️ Dinner Spots
🎯 Authentic
More

Pizza restaurant offers an airy, open space with brick walls decorated by Italian-themed artworks and jars of homemade sauce. Atmosphere feels warm and inviting, blending a modern look with a family-owned vibe. Guests enjoy a fresh, crispy crust pizza experience in a clean, well-appointed setting.

People are saying

"I love the cozy vibe and tasty dishes here."

"The pizza is fresh, crispy, and full of flavor."

"The people here are friendly and welcoming."

Good to know

1

The Parlor has gluten-free, cauliflower, and Nutella pies available.

2

There are lots of different styles of pizza slices available.

3

The menu at The Parlor is huge, offering all sorts of Italian specialties.

04
LTD Pizza and Bar image 1
LTD Pizza and Bar image 2
LTD Pizza and Bar image 3
View all
🥓 Mortadella
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🚫🌾 Gluten Free
🛋️ Cozy
More

Pizza restaurant offers a cozy and chill vibe with private back rooms and a sunny outdoor patio. Guests enjoy free Mrs. Pac-Man arcade game and a bar serving wine, beer, and house soda. Atmosphere suits casual hangouts and dates with friendly staff and a clean, inviting space.

People are saying

"The pizza here tastes amazing and stands out."

"I can't wait to come back for more pizza."

"This New York Style Pizza is top tier."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

2

Expect longer wait times during lunch rush hours, especially on Wednesdays.

3

Most pizza slices cost around $7, including tax and tip.

05
Mona Lisa Pizzeria image 1
Mona Lisa Pizzeria image 2
Mona Lisa Pizzeria image 3
View all
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🥓 Mortadella
🇮🇹 Italian Food
🎯 Authentic
More

Bright walls display awards and pictures, creating a welcoming Italian vibe. The atmosphere feels comfortable and inviting, like visiting family. Many gluten-free options and creative specialty pies stand out on the menu.

People are saying

"The pizza tastes fresh and the specialty dishes stand out."

"They have plenty of gluten-free choices for everyone."

Good to know

1

The restaurant only accepts cash for sales.

2

Using the ATM incurs a charge from both the bank and Mona Lisa Pizza.

3

Mona Lisa Pizzeria is closed on Christmas Day.

06
Pizza Collective image 1
Pizza Collective image 2
Pizza Collective image 3
View all
🥓 Mortadella
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🥛 Dairy Free
🌱 Vegan Friendly
More

Small, cozy pizza restaurant with a pink design and live DJ outside. Offers outdoor seating and a modern, clean interior with creative decor. Atmosphere is cool and comfortable, attracting those seeking both classic and vegan pies.

People are saying

"The pizza has fresh ingredients and tasty crust."

"The vegan pizzas here are some of the best."

"I’ll definitely be coming back here."

Good to know

1

Happy hour deal is $12 from Monday to Friday.

2

The carbonara pasta is available from 12 p.m. to 4 p.m.

3

Buying any 2 slices allows you to get 1 cheese slice for $1.

07
Rome to Brooklyn, pizza & panzerotti image 1
Rome to Brooklyn, pizza & panzerotti image 2
Rome to Brooklyn, pizza & panzerotti image 3
View all
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🥓 Mortadella
🌭 Sausage
🇮🇹 Italian Food
More

Open, airy dining space offers a relaxed, welcoming vibe with bright, clean surroundings. The atmosphere stays calm without hype or wait times. Guests enjoy generous portions featuring high-quality, fresh ingredients and unique pizza varieties.

People are saying

"The pizza slices are fresh, crispy, and full of flavor."

"The garlic pinwheels are cheesy and unforgettable."

"I think Warsaw's pizza is top tier and unmatched."

Good to know

1

All slices, triangle and square, are $5 or $5.5 each.

2

They offer slices and pies.

3

There are about 8 varieties of grandma square slices to choose from.

08
Motorino Pizza image 1
Motorino Pizza image 2
Motorino Pizza image 3
View all
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🥓 Mortadella
🍰 Tiramisu
🧆 Meatballs
More

Neapolitan pizza cooks in a genuine Italian wood-burning oven, delivering a thin and chewy crust with a balance of crunch. Outdoor seating offers covered areas with umbrellas and trees for shade, creating a relaxed vibe. The space features a beautiful mosaic pizza display and welcomes dogs inside, adding to its casual atmosphere.

People are saying

"I love their tasty pizza and cozy vibe."

"Some pizzas were great, but others felt cold or undercooked."

"The outdoor seating is nice, but the vibe needs work."

Good to know

1

The lunch special includes a salad and a 12" pizza for $17.

2

Motorino has vegan options available on the menu.

3

Customers can eat inside or outside, depending on preference.

09
Filaga image 1
Filaga image 2
Filaga image 3
View all
🥓 Mortadella
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🥓 Prosciutto
🍕 Pizza Slices
More

Open kitchen design lets diners watch pizza chefs craft pies with intricate dough tossing and fresh ingredients. Atmosphere combines cozy seating with colorful decor and lively music, creating an engaging and vibrant vibe. Outdoor covered tables offer a quieter option near bustling market streets.

People are saying

"The pizza is fresh, tasty, and feels like Italy."

"Filaga serves great pizza at good prices inside Chelsea Market."

"I got authentic New York Style Pizza with great customer service."

Good to know

1

The pizza is found inside of Chelsea Market.

2

The Prosciutto E Funghi pizza slice costs 9.74.

3

Expect to share seating as the pizzeria is often full.

10
Joe & Sal's Pizza image 1
Joe & Sal's Pizza image 2
Joe & Sal's Pizza image 3
View all
🥓 Mortadella
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🍕 Pizza
🏘️ Local Spot
More

Small joint offers authentic Italian vibe with vintage décor and lively atmosphere. Pizza varies but often features creative Mortadella combos like Gorgonzola. Seating is tight, adding to the neighborhood feel while delivering some of Brooklyn's best pies.

People are saying

"It's a beloved local spot with great pizza."

"The pizza tastes fresh and full of flavor."

"The place has a cozy, authentic vibe."

Good to know

1

The price of a single slice of pizza is $10.

2

Prices for pizza slices are mostly $3-$5.

3

It's cheaper to pay with cash at Joe and Sal's.