Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots for New Yorkโ€“style pepperoni pizza in New York City

Based on 936 Reviews
+933
User
User
User
Updated
01
The Pizza Box NY image 1
The Pizza Box NY image 2
The Pizza Box NY image 3
View all
๐Ÿ• Pepperoni Pizza
๐Ÿ• New York Style Pizza
๐Ÿ‘จโ€๐Ÿ‘ฉโ€๐Ÿ‘งโ€๐Ÿ‘ฆ Family Owned
๐Ÿ›‹๏ธ Cozy
More

Spacious pizza restaurant with a bright, airy dining room and a gorgeous outdoor garden that grows fresh produce. Atmosphere feels cozy and welcoming, suited for families and groups, with a calm, friendly vibe. Decor includes a mural and barn door, adding unique charm to the space.

People are saying

"I found the honey pepperoni pizza delicious."

"The honey garlic pepperoni pizza blew me away."

"The pepperoni pizzas were light and tasty."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers vegan and gluten-free options on the menu.

2

They do not sell pizza by the slice; whole pies only.

3

The establishment has both indoor and outdoor seating available.

02
Popโ€™s Pizza of East Village image 1
Popโ€™s Pizza of East Village image 2
Popโ€™s Pizza of East Village image 3
View all
๐Ÿ• Pepperoni Pizza
๐Ÿ• New York Style Pizza
๐Ÿ• Pizza
๐Ÿž Sourdough
More

Small pizza shop with a cozy, homey atmosphere and laid-back decor creates a warm, inviting vibe. Friendly energy reflects the community spirit of the neighborhood. Known for exceptional pizza, made with a careful fermentation process, it draws a steady crowd seeking quality and comfort.

People are saying

"The pizza has fresh cheese and a crispy crust."

"I always come back because the pizza is great."

"I experienced classic New York Style Pizza that reminded me of how it used to taste."

Good to know

1

The pizzeria is dog-friendly, allowing pets on the outdoor patio.

2

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash is also welcome.

3

Parking is limited; consider using public transport or rideshare services.

03
Pizza Spot hells kitchen image 1
Pizza Spot hells kitchen image 2
Pizza Spot hells kitchen image 3
View all
๐Ÿ• New York Style Pizza
๐Ÿ• Pepperoni Pizza
๐Ÿ• Pizza Slices
๐Ÿ• Calzone
More

Small pizza restaurant offers a cozy, neighborhood vibe with a casual, family-friendly atmosphere. The space includes charging stations and draws a crowd looking for authentic New York-style pizza with thin crusts and fresh toppings.

People are saying

"The pizza here is always fresh and delicious."

"The place feels welcoming with tasty food every time."

"I found the pepperoni pizza to be a must-try."

Good to know

1

You can order ahead and have your food ready when you arrive.

2

The prices are reasonable, making it a budget-friendly option for a tasty meal.

3

The restaurant is just one block away from the daily show.

04
Uncle Sam's Pizza image 1
Uncle Sam's Pizza image 2
Uncle Sam's Pizza image 3
View all
๐Ÿ• New York Style Pizza
๐Ÿ• Pepperoni Pizza
๐Ÿ• Pizza
๐ŸŒ™ Late Night Spot
More

Tiny shop serves authentic New York thin crust pizza with a bold spicy pepperoni topping. Bright lights and lively crowds create a warm, welcoming vibe. Outdoor seating and good music make it a cozy casual spot.

People are saying

"This New York Style Pizza is delicious and a true representation."

"They have great styles of pepperoni pizza to try."

"The New York style pizza here is delicious and top-notch."

Good to know

1

Cash and credit are both accepted.

2

The restaurant is open till 2 AM on weekdays.

3

This pizza spot has no credit card minimum.

05
Pizzazz image 1
Pizzazz image 2
Pizzazz image 3
View all
๐Ÿ• Pepperoni Pizza
๐Ÿ• New York Style Pizza
๐Ÿ• Margherita Pizza
๐Ÿ• Pizza
More

Small pizza shop with two standing tables and a stone spinning oven that cooks pies evenly. Stylish, modern interior with upbeat music creates a warm and inviting atmosphere. Known for fresh, high-quality ingredients and quick, handcrafted pizzas.

People are saying

"The pizza tastes fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked."

"I highly recommend this place for great pizza."

"I can't wait to come back and try more."

Good to know

1

There isnโ€™t any indoor seating available at this pizza spot.

2

The entire process from placing the order to leaving takes only 5 minutes.

3

The restaurant imports almost all of their ingredients from Italy for quality.

06
Macoletta image 1
Macoletta image 2
Macoletta image 3
View all

Macoletta

๐Ÿ• Pepperoni Pizza
๐Ÿ• New York Style Pizza
๐Ÿšซ๐ŸŒพ Gluten Free
๐Ÿ›‹๏ธ Cozy
More

Cozy and intimate layout features a large pizza oven behind the bar and an airy, modern setting. Warm atmosphere includes live jazz music and outdoor seating with city skyline views. Guests enjoy exceptional pizza and a variety of craft cocktails in a small, romantic space.

Good to know

1

The menu has options for every dietary need.

2

Expect high-quality ingredients in every dish.

3

The restaurant is minimally climate controlled, which may affect comfort on hot days.

07
Louie's image 1
Louie's image 2
Louie's image 3
View all
๐Ÿ• Pepperoni Pizza
๐Ÿ• New York Style Pizza
๐Ÿฅฉ Ribeye Steak
๐Ÿ“ป Vintage
More

Small space with vintage style decor and diner-like seating creates an old school New York pizzeria vibe. Atmosphere feels friendly and down-to-earth, offering an intimate and welcoming setting. Regulars enjoy a comfortable, urban environment that feels like home.

People are saying

"I love their pizza and respect their courage."

"I dreamed of the grandma slice; it's the best New York Style Pizza I've ever had."

"I love how the crust tastes just like real New York pizza."

Good to know

1

Prices can be high, with three large pizzas costing around $67.

2

Cash payments are preferred; credit cards may be accepted.

3

The pizza place is known for high-quality ingredients.

08
Unregular Pizza image 1
Unregular Pizza image 2
Unregular Pizza image 3
View all
๐Ÿ• New York Style Pizza
๐Ÿ• Pepperoni Pizza
๐Ÿ• Mushroom Pizza
๐Ÿ• Pizza
More

Small, cozy pizza shop with no seating except a standing bar and a vibrant, colorful atmosphere. Music plays a retro playlist that adds to the fun, cheerful vibe. The place breaks pizza joint norms with unconventional design and a wide variety of options including vegan and gluten-free crusts.

People are saying

"I always go for the pepperoni pizza with burrata."

"The burrata pepperoni pizza tastes amazing and isn't too heavy."

"I love that this place breaks the usual New York pizza mold."

Good to know

1

There is very limited seating; it's primarily a takeout style restaurant.

2

The price of a slice of pizza is $7.62.

3

If you share 3 pizzas, you get 1 drink for free.

09
LaVista Pizza (2nd Ave) image 1
LaVista Pizza (2nd Ave) image 2
LaVista Pizza (2nd Ave) image 3
View all
๐Ÿ• New York Style Pizza
๐Ÿ• Pepperoni Pizza
๐Ÿ• Pizza
๐ŸŒ™ Late Night Spot
More

Brightly lit pizzeria offers authentic New York style pizza with a perfect crust and toppings balance. Salty pepperoni pizza shines among options like Margherita and Philly cheesesteak. Friendly vibe with garage door seating creates an open, welcoming space despite street noise outside.

People are saying

"The pizza crust is perfectly crispy and tasty."

"I found the New York Style Pizza to be truly authentic."

"I love how authentic the New York pizza tastes here."

Good to know

1

The price for one plain slice is $3.50.

2

Ordering ahead of time is recommended for a better experience.

3

They have halal options available.

10
Pop's Pizza image 1
Pop's Pizza image 2
Pop's Pizza image 3
View all
๐Ÿ• New York Style Pizza
๐Ÿ• Pepperoni Pizza
๐Ÿ• Margherita Pizza
๐Ÿ• Pizza Slices
More

Tiny spot serves authentic New York style pizza with a thin, crispy crust and simple toppings. Pepperoni slices shine with freshness and taste great even as leftovers. Outdoor standing area offers a lively, no-frills atmosphere perfect for quick, flavorful bites.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the authentic New York style pizza by the slice."

"The New York pizza tastes real and classic."

"I think this is the best pizza spot for pepperoni pizza."

Good to know

1

The restaurant does not offer dine-in service.

2

There are no seats, so you just grab your slice.

3

Four people can eat for less than $30 in New York.