Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 places for New York‑style pizza in quiet settings to Enjoy in New York City

Based on 813 Reviews
+810
User
User
User
Updated
01
The Pizza Box NY image 1
The Pizza Box NY image 2
The Pizza Box NY image 3
View all
🤫 Quiet
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🍕 Pepperoni Pizza
👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Family Owned
More

Spacious pizza restaurant with a bright, airy dining room and a gorgeous outdoor garden that grows fresh produce. Atmosphere feels cozy and welcoming, suited for families and groups, with a calm, friendly vibe. Decor includes a mural and barn door, adding unique charm to the space.

People are saying

"The pizza tastes amazing and feels like family-made."

"The spot has a warm, friendly vibe that feels like home."

"The garlic honey pepperoni pizza blew me away."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers vegan and gluten-free options on the menu.

2

They do not sell pizza by the slice; whole pies only.

3

The establishment has both indoor and outdoor seating available.

02
Vito's Slices and Ices image 1
Vito's Slices and Ices image 2
Vito's Slices and Ices image 3
View all
🤫 Quiet
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🍕 Pizza
🍕 Margherita Pizza
More

Small pizza spot with limited seating and a vintage retro vibe featuring brick walls and Italian flag colors. Atmosphere feels authentic and nostalgic, lively with great music and a busy street view. Offers a classic New York-style experience with quick service and a welcoming energy.

People are saying

"I found the classic New York pizza here to be delicious and foldable."

"The pizza slices taste just like real New York pizza."

"I had my first true New York pizza experience here."

Good to know

1

This spot is a popular choice for lunch during New York Comic Con.

2

The garlic knots cost $2.75 for 3.

3

Ordering to eating took a maximum of 3 minutes.

03
Crazy Chef Pizza image 1
Crazy Chef Pizza image 2
Crazy Chef Pizza image 3
View all
🤫 Quiet
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🍕 Pizza
🥟 Empanadas
More

Pizza restaurant with colorful murals and fun music creates a friendly, calm vibe. Seating feels small and cramped but atmosphere stays welcoming and lively during busy hours. Family-friendly energy fills the space with inspiration and warmth.

People are saying

"Their unique pizzas taste fresh and affordable."

"It’s a friendly spot with fresh, tasty food."

"They serve the best pizza in the neighborhood."

Good to know

1

The large pepperoni pie costs $20.

2

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted.

3

The restaurant has a variety of food on its menu.

04
Quality Pizza Co. Midtown image 1
Quality Pizza Co. Midtown image 2
Quality Pizza Co. Midtown image 3
View all
🤫 Quiet
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🍕 Pizza
🌙 Late Night Spot
More

Pizza spot shines with classic thin crust slices that taste like New York. Cozy, lively vibe with 80's and 90's music keeps energy up. On Thursday mornings, enjoy quiet moments in a clean, modern space with comfy seating.

People are saying

"I found the New York Style Pizza here to be great and fresh."

"I loved the classic New York style pizza here."

"This place serves some of the best New York pizza I've had."

Good to know

1

They offer a $7 deal that includes 2 slices and a drink of your choice.

2

The location is right near Penn Station.

3

Quality Pizza has an all day deal: 2 cheese slices with water or soda for $7.

05
Macoletta image 1
Macoletta image 2
Macoletta image 3
View all

Macoletta

🤫 Quiet
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🚫🌾 Gluten Free
🛋️ Cozy
More

Cozy and intimate layout features a large pizza oven behind the bar and an airy, modern setting. Warm atmosphere includes live jazz music and outdoor seating with city skyline views. Guests enjoy exceptional pizza and a variety of craft cocktails in a small, romantic space.

Good to know

1

The menu has options for every dietary need.

2

Expect high-quality ingredients in every dish.

3

The restaurant is minimally climate controlled, which may affect comfort on hot days.

06
Secret Food Tours New York image 1
Secret Food Tours New York image 2
Secret Food Tours New York image 3
View all
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🤫 Quiet
🧭 Food Tours
🎉 Fun Activities
More

Walking tours combine charming small restaurants with quiet leafy streets and vibrant neighborhood energy. Guides create a warm, inclusive atmosphere filled with laughter and shared stories. Groups enjoy discovering unique, top-notch food stops that highlight diverse cuisines.

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for food tours, especially on weekends.

2

Expect a 3-hour duration for most food tours in the area.

3

Bring comfortable walking shoes as tours involve a lot of walking.

07
Grand Central Terminal image 1
Grand Central Terminal image 2
Grand Central Terminal image 3
View all
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🤫 Quiet
🏛️ Historical Sites
😎 Cool
More

Grand Central Terminal presents grand vaulted ceilings adorned with a celestial mural, creating a timeless and elegant atmosphere. The space buzzes with bustling energy and features unique elements like the Whispering Gallery, where sound travels across arched hallways. It combines architectural grandeur with lively cultural moments, making it a distinctive urban landmark.

People are saying

"I love the stunning ceiling and lively vibe here."

"I found quiet corners to explore, especially early morning."

"The Whispering Gallery lets you share secrets across walls."

Good to know

1

Vanderbilt Hall often hosts exhibitions and events, adding cultural flair to the space.

2

During the holiday season, the terminal is especially enchanting with festive decorations.

3

Visitors should not miss the famous 'Whispering Gallery' where voices magically travel along the walls.

08
Top of The Rock image 1
Top of The Rock image 2
Top of The Rock image 3
View all
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🤫 Quiet
🏞️ Nice View
🌇 Scenic Views
More

Observation deck offers 360° panoramic views with a clear sightline to the Empire State Building and Central Park. Multiple outdoor terraces provide an unobstructed skyline experience with a lively atmosphere, especially at night. Elevators feature interactive visuals enhancing the ascent, while rooftop amenities include a small cafe and bar serving tasty cocktails.

People are saying

"It's surprisingly quiet in the evening, especially after dark."

"The place is really quiet with plenty of space."

"I visited in the evening and it was very quiet."

Good to know

1

Make sure to show up about 10 minutes before to not risk missing your scheduled time.

2

To get the sunset view, you must reserve in advance.

3

Admission to Top of the Rock is priced from $50 per person.

09
Louie's image 1
Louie's image 2
Louie's image 3
View all
🤫 Quiet
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🥩 Ribeye Steak
📻 Vintage
More

Small space with vintage style decor and diner-like seating creates an old school New York pizzeria vibe. Atmosphere feels friendly and down-to-earth, offering an intimate and welcoming setting. Regulars enjoy a comfortable, urban environment that feels like home.

People are saying

"I love their pizza and respect their courage."

"I dreamed of the grandma slice; it's the best New York Style Pizza I've ever had."

"I love how the crust tastes just like real New York pizza."

Good to know

1

Prices can be high, with three large pizzas costing around $67.

2

Cash payments are preferred; credit cards may be accepted.

3

The pizza place is known for high-quality ingredients.

10
Pizza Loves Sauce image 1
Pizza Loves Sauce image 2
Pizza Loves Sauce image 3
View all
🤫 Quiet
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🍕 Pizza Slices
🍕 Margherita Pizza
More

Pizza restaurant offers modern, hip design with clean, cozy indoor and outdoor seating. The atmosphere feels quiet and welcoming with rap music playlists enhancing the vibe. Space is small but well-decorated, creating a boutique pizzeria experience.

People are saying

"The pizza flavors are amazing and unique."

"The place feels friendly and welcoming."

"This New York Style Pizza is the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Karaoke starts at 1:45am on weekends.

2

The viral vodka chicken parm sandwich is available from 12 PM to 6 PM on select days.

3

The establishment is completely Halal, ensuring all menu items meet dietary restrictions.