Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots for peanut butter and jelly sandwiches to Enjoy in New York City

Based on 887 Reviews
+884
User
User
User
Updated
01
Pearl Street Restaurant image 1
Pearl Street Restaurant image 2
Pearl Street Restaurant image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🥪 Sandwich
💕 Romantic
Unique
More

Counter seating surrounds a petite, makeshift kitchen where chefs prepare dishes in full view, creating an intimate and cozy atmosphere. The space fosters personal connection through direct interaction with chefs and attentive service. Background music complements the setting, enhancing the overall intimate dining experience and chef counter interaction.

People are saying

"The food has amazing twists, especially PB&J with foie gras."

"The PB&J with foie gras is a rich and genius dish."

"The Peanut Butter And Jelly with foie gras was pure genius."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for the chef's tasting menu, especially on busy nights.

2

The Valentine’s Day prix fixe menu is served at the chef counter.

3

The restaurant offers an 8-course tasting menu for under $100.

02
Park Cafe image 1
Park Cafe image 2
Park Cafe image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🥪 Sandwich
Cafe
🏷️ Affordable
More

Small, cozy space with well-lit interior and comfortable seating for chatting or working. Atmosphere feels friendly and nostalgic, enhanced by homemade treats and occasional free samples. Quiet vibe invites relaxed visits without rushing.

People are saying

"I had one of the best egg sandwiches I’ve had in a long time."

"I love their melty, hearty breakfast sandwiches."

"It's a nice spot to grab coffee and sandwiches."

Good to know

1

The cafe offers coffee, tea, breakfast, lunch, and sweets.

2

Pricing is very affordable.

3

The shop does not have much space to sit in.

03
da Toscano image 1
da Toscano image 2
da Toscano image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🥪 Sandwich
🍝 Pappardelle
🍝 Orecchiette
More

Italian spot shines with cozy atmosphere and dim warm lighting. Sandwiches on fresh focaccia impress, especially the tender Porchetta. PB&J Bombolone offers a bold mix with foie gras and peanut butter, creating a unique texture.

People are saying

"I always find the pasta here absolutely amazing."

"The Porchetta sandwich here is excellent and the meat is so tender."

"The Peanut Butter And Jelly bombolone was unforgettable."

Good to know

1

Make a reservation before visiting to ensure a table.

2

The Porchetta pop-up is available at lunchtime on Thursday, Friday, and Saturday.

3

The restaurant has a 90-minute limit for meals, which is mentioned in the small print on their website.

04
Leon's Bagels image 1
Leon's Bagels image 2
Leon's Bagels image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🥪 Sandwich
🥯 Bagel With Lox
🍳 Eggs
More

Small bagel shop with a charming old-school New York vibe and cute takeout window. Atmosphere feels welcoming and friendly, attracting a fun crowd. Setup focuses on grab-and-go service with outdoor benches for quick bites.

People are saying

"I thought the bagel sandwiches here were the best I ever had."

"I love their filling egg and bacon sandwiches."

"The bagel sandwiches are hearty but pricey."

Good to know

1

Leon's Bagels only offers take-away service.

2

Expect to visit early for breakfast around 8 am to avoid queues.

3

The bagels are made to order from a small storefront.

05
Daytime image 1
Daytime image 2
Daytime image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🥪 Sandwich
🛋️ Cozy
🥐 Croissant
More

Cozy cafe on a quiet side street offers limited seating with sunlit windows filled with plants. The atmosphere is chill and neighborly, though music can be loud for the small space. Frequent crowds form on weekday mornings, creating a lively but tight environment.

People are saying

"I loved their breakfast sandwich with pepper jam add-ons."

"I love their breakfast sandwiches with unique flavors."

"I can't wait to try the Lemon Lime Curd Sandwich Cake."

Good to know

1

Parking in the area is generally a nightmare.

2

The line is generally long and moves slowly.

3

The seating is insufficient at the location.

06
Gotan image 1
Gotan image 2
Gotan image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🥪 Sandwich
🍳 Breakfast
🍪 Biscuits
More

Coffee shop offers indoor and outdoor seating with power outlets everywhere and big airy windows. Atmosphere stays calm and not overly crowded, enhanced by a great jazz soundtrack. Outdoor patio provides a sunny, pleasant spot for drinking and eating.

People are saying

"I love the herb omelet and tuna-avocado sandwiches."

"I found the tuna avocado sandwich shockingly delicious."

"The sandwiches and coffees are a bit pricey."

Good to know

1

This café does NOT have wifi.

2

Reservations are recommended at Trends, especially on weekends.

3

They do not accept bills larger than $20.

07
787 Coffee image 1
787 Coffee image 2
787 Coffee image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🥪 Sandwich
😎 Chill
🛋️ Cozy
More

Coffee shop offers natural light, plants, and varied seating for working or relaxing. Atmosphere combines welcoming decor with a curated playlist and occasional acoustic acts. Patrons engage with unique touches like writing gratitude notes on coffee filters, creating a distinct community vibe.

People are saying

"I love the cozy vibe and relaxing atmosphere here."

"Their coffee flavors like horchata and dulce de leche are amazing."

"Xavier always makes the place feel welcoming and fun."

Good to know

1

The coffee shop closes at 7PM.

2

Expect live music events regularly throughout the month.

3

Discounts are available for healthcare workers.

08
Joey Roses image 1
Joey Roses image 2
Joey Roses image 3
View all
🥪 Sandwich
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
😎 Cool
🏘️ Local Spot
More

Small spot with fresh ingredients and rich peanut butter flavors crafts sandwiches that never fall apart. Retro decor with vinyl records and classic game vibes sets a unique hangout. Loud dubstep and hip hop fuel a punk-friendly energy.

People are saying

"The sandwiches are tasty, well-priced, and satisfying."

"Joey Roses serves some of the best sandwiches in the city."

"I thought the sandwiches here were incredible."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm with great drink specials.

2

Joey Roses offers a "buy 2 get 1 free" sandwich deal during happy hour.

3

Expect to wait over an hour for your sandwich during peak hours.

09
Bear Donut image 1
Bear Donut image 2
Bear Donut image 3
View all
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🥪 Sandwich
🍞 Brioche
🍰 Tiramisu
More

Small shop offers colorful mochi donuts and Asian-inspired soft serve in a clean, trendy space with limited seating mostly for quick visits. Atmosphere feels cute and upbeat with a warm, homemade vibe. Facade is understated, blending into a small-town style setting.

People are saying

"The breakfast sandwich here is great, with a nice vinegary sauce."

"I can't get enough of the peanut butter and jelly donut."

"The limited edition peanut butter and jelly donut really hit the spot."

Good to know

1

The breakfast waffle donut is only available between 8AM - 2PM.

2

Mochi donuts cost $3.75 and larger donuts cost $5.

3

Bear Donut does not have seating inside.

10
375° Chicken 'n Fries image 1
375° Chicken 'n Fries image 2
375° Chicken 'n Fries image 3
View all
🥪 Sandwich
🥜 Peanut Butter And Jelly
🥘 Food
🍟 Fast Food
More

Small, brightly lit fast food spot with a cramped dining area featuring a few high-top tables. Atmosphere feels clean and inviting with art on the walls creating a chill vibe. Space suits quick meals rather than long stays.

People are saying

"I love how flavorful the chicken sandwiches are."

"I thought the chicken sandwich was the best I ever had."

"I really enjoyed the variety of sandwiches here."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is halal and a certificate is posted on the notice board inside.

2

Make sure you're hungry, it's a large portion.

3

There isn’t a lot of seating available.