Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots for pie AND sugar cookies to Enjoy in New York City

Based on 702 Reviews
+699
User
User
User
Updated
01
Rose Valley Cakes image 1
Rose Valley Cakes image 2
Rose Valley Cakes image 3
View all
๐Ÿช Sugar Cookies
๐Ÿฅง Pie
๐Ÿšซ๐ŸŒพ Gluten Free
๐Ÿฅ Pastry
More

Quaint bakery with clean, sleek decor and upscale, classy atmosphere offers a quiet, zen setting ideal for working or meeting friends. Light music plays softly while a few tables provide space to enjoy vegan and gluten-free pastries in a warm, inviting environment.

People are saying

"I love the cozy vibe and tasty treats."

"Their vegan cakes and pastries taste amazing."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers lots of gluten-free, vegan, and sugar-free options without sacrificing taste.

2

Their prices range from $1 to $6, which is cheaper than other vegan places.

3

There is a free parking lot in the back.

02
The Pastry Box image 1
The Pastry Box image 2
The Pastry Box image 3
View all
๐Ÿช Sugar Cookies
๐Ÿฅง Pie
๐Ÿช Chocolate Chip Cookies
โ˜•๏ธ Coffee Cake
More

Small bakery with cozy seating and cute decor creates a charming atmosphere filled with natural light and soft music. The space feels inviting and cheerful, attracting those who appreciate a local vibe and world-class pastries.

People are saying

"I love how fresh and tasty the cookies and pastries are."

"I can't wait to try more of their baked goods."

Good to know

1

The store often sells out of items 20 minutes before closing.

2

Everything is baked in house using top quality ingredients.

3

Cookies are priced at $5 each, making them affordable.

03
Maretta image 1
Maretta image 2
Maretta image 3
View all
๐Ÿฅง Pie
๐Ÿช Sugar Cookies
๐Ÿ Pappardelle
๐ŸŸ Branzino
More

Italian restaurant offers a cozy, intimate atmosphere with a sleek, minimalist bar and a European vibe. Music ranges from curated playlists to a DJ who energizes the crowd, creating a friendly and fun environment. The place is dog friendly and known for authentic Italian dishes and well-balanced wines.

People are saying

"The food is delicious and feels truly Italian."

"I will definitely be back here soon."

"The atmosphere is cozy and really pleasant."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers half-price appetizers from 4-7pm on weekdays.

2

Weekend events feature a pre-fixe menu and brunch coming soon.

3

The restaurant is dog friendly, making it a great spot for pet owners.

04
Janie's Life-Changing Baked Goods image 1
Janie's Life-Changing Baked Goods image 2
Janie's Life-Changing Baked Goods image 3
View all

Janie's Life-Changing Baked Goods

๐Ÿช Sugar Cookies
๐Ÿฅง Pie
๐Ÿช Chocolate Chip Cookies
๐Ÿฏ Caramel
More

Small shop with no seating and a basement entrance creates an intimate, grab-and-go vibe. Cheerful atmosphere fills the space with the aroma of fresh cookies. Known for unique, highly praised cookies that combine salty and sweet flavors in a way that stands out in the neighborhood.

People are saying

"The cookie pies have amazing flavors and textures."

"The bakery's location is tricky but worth the visit."

"I was excited but ended up disappointed."

Good to know

1

The bakery is small with no seating available, ideal for takeout.

2

Cookies cost $3 each, with a variety of flavors offered.

3

Street parking is available in the area for easy access.

05
Avrilililly's Creamery LLC image 1
Avrilililly's Creamery LLC image 2
Avrilililly's Creamery LLC image 3
View all
๐Ÿฅง Pie
๐Ÿช Sugar Cookies
๐Ÿฎ Banana Pudding
๐Ÿง Sorbet
More

Ice cream shop showcases vibrant colors and a poetic Harlem theme with original murals and wall poetry. Comfortable indoor and outdoor seating supports a family- and vegan-friendly atmosphere with good music and WiFi. The space balances a sophisticated yet playful vibe that invites work and socializing.

People are saying

"I love how their gelato flavors always surprise me."

"Itโ€™s a cozy spot with amazing desserts I keep coming back to."

Good to know

1

They offer a 10% discount for students, teachers, and first responders.

2

To get the college student discount, you need to print your ID card.

3

Gelatos from the day before are discounted.

06
Buttermilk Bakeshop image 1
Buttermilk Bakeshop image 2
Buttermilk Bakeshop image 3
View all
๐Ÿฅง Pie
๐Ÿช Sugar Cookies
๐Ÿšซ๐ŸŒพ Gluten Free
๐Ÿฐ Red Velvet Cake
More

Bright, airy space with vintage-themed decor creates a comfortable atmosphere. Cakes and cupcakes stand out for their moist, delicious flavors and custom designs that impress guests. Mainly a baking facility, it focuses on quick service and quality treats without seating or drinks.

People are saying

"The cakes and treats taste amazing and look great."

"The space is bright and comfy, making it a joy to visit."

"Their classic cookies are super tasty and loved by all."

Good to know

1

The bakery makes all types of birthday and holiday cakes.

2

The ordering process is easy and convenient.

3

They deliver cupcakes for special occasions.

07
Crumbl image 1
Crumbl image 2
Crumbl image 3
View all
๐Ÿช Sugar Cookies
๐Ÿฅง Pie
๐Ÿช Cookie
๐ŸŽ‚ Cheesecake
More

Small, clean space with a welcoming atmosphere and good music creates a cozy vibe. The shop fills up quickly but maintains a quiet, neat environment. Cookies are fresh and highly praised for their taste.

People are saying

"The cookies were fresh but the place felt cramped."

"I was excited about the new spot but had mixed experiences."

"I always enjoy the fresh, tasty cookies and new flavors."

Good to know

1

It is a good idea to order ahead of possible.

2

Parking can be tight.

3

Crumbl Fire has a unique rotating menu of cookies each week.

08
Carve Cafe & Pizza image 1
Carve Cafe & Pizza image 2
Carve Cafe & Pizza image 3
View all
๐Ÿช Sugar Cookies
๐Ÿฅง Pie
๐ŸŒ™ Late Night Spot
๐Ÿ• Pizza
More

Small space with spacious seating and simple furnishings creates a cozy setting. Atmosphere feels luxurious and friendly, with music adding to the vibe. Pizza draws attention for being remarkably delicious and popular, often enjoyed alongside pastries and milkshakes.

People are saying

"I love the wide selection of tasty food here."

"The atmosphere here feels friendly and inviting."

"The pizza here is always fresh and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Be prepared to take out food during busy times.

2

They let you use the restroom anytime.

3

Coffee and bagel cost $3.50 at the Carve Cafe.

09
The Hungarian Pastry Shop image 1
The Hungarian Pastry Shop image 2
The Hungarian Pastry Shop image 3
View all
๐Ÿฅง Pie
๐Ÿช Sugar Cookies
๐ŸŽ‚ Cheesecake
๐Ÿฐ Carrot Cake
More

Small, busy pastry shop with intimate layout and crowded tables creates a lively atmosphere reminiscent of an Old World Viennese cafe. Indoor and outdoor seating offer options despite limited terrace space. Walls lined with books written in the cafe add a unique, creative vibe.

People are saying

"I love the tasty pastries and cozy vibe here."

"I loved the lemon and cherry pies."

"I worry about birds hopping on my food outside."

Good to know

1

Expect a long wait on weekends, but the line moves quickly.

2

You can bring food from nearby shops, but check with staff first.

3

Prices for pastries are not displayed; ask for each item's price.

10
Crumbl image 1
Crumbl image 2
Crumbl image 3
View all
๐Ÿฅง Pie
๐Ÿช Sugar Cookies
๐Ÿช Cookie
๐Ÿจ Desserts
More

Cookie factory shines with fresh baked aroma and a modern setup perfect for photos. Pie lovers enjoy the crumbly cookie pie and balanced Key Lime Pie. Sugar cookie fans get thick frosted pink cookies served cold, offering a unique sweet treat in a calm, pink-toned space.

People are saying

"The cookies were fresh and delicious every time."

"The pink sugar cookie is super sweet with almond notes."

"The frosted sugar cookie is cold and dense, with melting frosting."

Good to know

1

The kiosk does not accept cash; bring a card for purchases.

2

A box of 4 cookies costs $17.99.

3

The menu changes every week, with new cookies every Monday.