Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots for toffee paired with pudding to Enjoy in New York City

Based on 665 Reviews
+662
User
User
User
Updated
01
Miss Nellie's image 1
Miss Nellie's image 2
Miss Nellie's image 3
View all
🍮 Pudding
🍬 Toffee
🛋️ Cozy
🎨 Eclectic
More

Restaurant shines with sticky toffee pudding, a rich dessert perfect to share. Savory dishes like chicken vodka parmigiana balance the sweetness. Lively vibe with live music and espresso martini cocktails make it a fun spot.

People are saying

"I love the cozy, elegant vibe and drinks."

"You have to try the sticky toffee pudding; it's divine."

"You have to try the sticky toffee pudding; it's divine."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially on weekends.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm with discounted drinks and appetizers.

3

The restaurant is popular for pre-theater dining, so expect crowds.

02
Gurumé image 1
Gurumé image 2
Gurumé image 3
View all
🍬 Toffee
🍮 Pudding
🍞 Bread Pudding
🍽️ Dinner Spots
More

Space combines chic, contemporary decor with an open bar counter showcasing cocktail preparation. Atmosphere feels refined yet lively, with soju-based cocktails standing out as a unique feature. Tables offer some privacy despite close spacing, creating a balance between intimacy and energy.

People are saying

"The black sesame bread pudding is insanely delicious and buttery."

"The black sesame bread pudding is unforgettable and delicious."

"I loved the steak, chicken, and black sesame bread pudding."

Good to know

1

Get your reservation in advance as this place gets crowded quickly.

2

If you cancel your reservation less than 6 hours prior, you get charged $10 per person.

3

The happy hour is from 4-7pm with $2 off wine, $6 beers, and $10 cocktails.

03
Langan's image 1
Langan's image 2
Langan's image 3
View all
🍮 Pudding
🍬 Toffee
🍽️ Dinner Spots
🥬 Caesar Salad
More

Cocktail bar mixes 1920s elegance with Irish charm in a lively, stylish space. Sticky toffee pudding shines with caramel sauce and vanilla ice cream, pairing perfectly with an Irish coffee martini. Burgers and fries add a hearty touch to the menu.

People are saying

"You have to try the sticky toffee pudding; it's delicious."

"You have to try the sticky toffee pudding; it's phenomenal."

"The sticky toffee pudding was delicious and buttery."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

2

Reservations are recommended during busy happy hour periods.

3

Free drinks are offered with a Broadway ticket.

04
Dish Food & Events image 1
Dish Food & Events image 2
Dish Food & Events image 3
View all
🍬 Toffee
🍮 Pudding
🎉 Celebration
🎉 Party
More

Catering service delivers meticulous planning and seamless execution with a focus on personalized menus and professional staff. Events feel joyful and polished, with food and drinks that consistently impress guests. The atmosphere balances reliability and flexibility, making celebrations smooth and memorable.

Good to know

1

Dish Food & Events specializes in full-service catering for weddings and corporate events.

2

They offer drop-off catering services for smaller gatherings and parties.

3

The planning process is smooth, with excellent communication from the team.

05
The Ragtrader & Bo Peep Cocktail and Highball Store image 1
The Ragtrader & Bo Peep Cocktail and Highball Store image 2
The Ragtrader & Bo Peep Cocktail and Highball Store image 3
View all
🍬 Toffee
🍮 Pudding
🛋️ Cozy
😎 Cool
More

Small speakeasy offers live jazz piano and retro decor for a cozy vibe. Sticky toffee pudding shines with a free fire show, making dessert a fun spectacle. Upstairs dining adds a lively feel with eclectic design and dim lighting.

People are saying

"The food and drinks were always delicious."

"I loved the cozy vibe and great atmosphere."

"It's a cool spot great for drinks and hangouts."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for the piano bar, especially on busy nights.

2

Happy hour offers half-price appetizers on weekdays from 4-7pm.

3

Wine is half price on Mondays.

06
Isla & Co. - Midtown image 1
Isla & Co. - Midtown image 2
Isla & Co. - Midtown image 3
View all
🍬 Toffee
🍮 Pudding
🛋️ Cozy
🌊 Relaxed
More

Restaurant offers a cozy, trendy vibe with Empire State views and varied seating. Sticky toffee pudding shines as a rich dessert with classic flavor and moist texture. Sticky date pudding impresses with mascarpone pairing and lasting taste.

People are saying

"The sticky date pudding is out of this world."

"The sticky date pudding is out of this world."

"I kept eating the sticky date pudding without realizing it."

Good to know

1

Wine Wednesday means half price bottles all night long.

2

Happy hour is available every day of the week.

3

Daily specials include $20 chicken parm with a drink on Tuesdays.

07
Essex image 1
Essex image 2
Essex image 3
View all
🍬 Toffee
🍮 Pudding
🥞 Brunch
🍾 Bottomless
More

Massive space with roomy seating and lively atmosphere suits large groups and animated brunches. Outdoor seating offers a luxury dining experience with pleasant ambiance. Music adds a fun, cool vibe throughout the venue.

People are saying

"Helena kept our drinks flowing and made brunch fun."

"The place had a great vibe and friendly energy all night."

"I loved the food and the chill vibes here."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended at Helena Brunch on weekends due to its popularity.

2

The bottomless brunch is available from 11am to 4pm on weekends.

3

Happy Hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

08
Marseille image 1
Marseille image 2
Marseille image 3
View all
🍮 Pudding
🍬 Toffee
🍽️ Lunch Spot
🥞 Brunch
More

French bistro style meets stunning panoramic views and a lively, bougie atmosphere. Desserts shine with sticky toffee pudding and warm pecan bread pudding, both paired with vanilla ice cream. Outdoor seating offers heated comfort for a cozy lunch.

People are saying

"The food was delicious and beautifully presented."

"The sticky toffee pudding is incredible, a perfect 10/10."

"The sticky toffee pudding is as good as it gets."

Good to know

1

Happy hour includes oysters for $1.50 until 5:30 PM daily.

2

Brunch includes bottomless Mimosas for $25.

3

Make reservations, especially if you are visiting prior to a theatre show.

09
L'Adresse NoMad image 1
L'Adresse NoMad image 2
L'Adresse NoMad image 3
View all
🍬 Toffee
🍮 Pudding
💎 Classy
🎩 Upscale
More

Modern space buzzes with live music, creating a lively vibe but tough for quiet talks. Sticky toffee pudding shines with rich texture and unique flavor, while dessert options like creme brûlée add variety. Stylish decor and private rooms offer cozy spots for special moments.

People are saying

"The food was delicious and the atmosphere cozy."

"The sticky toffee pudding was delicious and superb."

"You have to try the sticky toffee pudding; it's too good."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 5-7 PM with discounted drinks.

2

Live jazz performances are available on Tuesdays.

3

Reservations at L’Adresse can be made on OpenTable.

10
Otis image 1
Otis image 2
Otis image 3
View all
🍬 Toffee
🍮 Pudding
🇮🇹 Italian Food
🛋️ Cozy
More

Open kitchen and brick walls create a cozy, chic vibe with intimate lighting. Sticky toffee pudding is a mouth-watering dessert that guests love, alongside flan. Seating includes a chef's table and outdoor area for a unique dining experience.

People are saying

"The food and drinks are amazing and the place feels cozy."

"I can't recommend this place enough because I love it."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as seating can be limited, especially on a Friday night.

2

Reservations are required for table seating; walk-ins can only sit at the bar.

3

Outdoor seating is available.