Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots for shrimp po boy and sandwiches in New York City

Based on 764 Reviews
+761
User
User
User
Updated
01
Bay Ridge Fish Market image 1
Bay Ridge Fish Market image 2
Bay Ridge Fish Market image 3
View all
🥪 Shrimp Po Boy
🥪 Sandwich
🦞 Fresh Seafood
🍟 French Fries
More

Seafood market offers fresh fish selection and a shaded garden patio for cozy dining. Shrimp Po Boy shines with crispy shrimp and a side of calamari. Sandwiches like soft shell crab and shrimp Banh mi feature fresh, crispy seafood and bold flavors.

People are saying

"The shrimp po' boy sandwich is amazing and delicious."

"The soft shell crab and shrimp sandwiches are amazing."

"I found the shrimp po boy sandwich to be amazing."

Good to know

1

The Bay Ridge Fishbar is BYOB, allowing guests to bring their own drinks.

2

Customers can choose the fish, which is freshly displayed and can be cooked on the spot.

3

The pricing at Bay Ridge Fishbar is incredibly fair for the quality.

02
The Sweet Tooth & Catering image 1
The Sweet Tooth & Catering image 2
The Sweet Tooth & Catering image 3
View all
🥪 Shrimp Po Boy
🥪 Sandwich
🥪 Po Boys
🍨 Desserts
More

Dessert spot with affirmations on walls and cool music creates a positive, welcoming vibe. Energy stays super chill with friendly people and a beautiful, cozy setting. Known for creative, less sweet cakes and hearty breakfast sandwiches.

People are saying

"I love their homemade food and sweet potato cheesecake."

"I found the Shrimp Po Boy to be excellent and very fresh."

"I found the breakfast sandwiches to be hefty and hearty."

Good to know

1

The shop was closed despite Google showing it as open.

2

This place does not have seating available.

3

The restaurant has breakfast specials available.

03
Cap’t Loui - 32nd st, NY image 1
Cap’t Loui - 32nd st, NY image 2
Cap’t Loui - 32nd st, NY image 3
View all
🥪 Sandwich
🥪 Shrimp Po Boy
🦞 Seafood
🥘 Food
More

Seafood boils and lobster rolls shine in a lively spot with a Cajun spice aroma. Po' boy sandwiches, especially the shrimp po boy, offer tender, filling bites with a New Orleans feel. Clean, spacious interior with thoughtful amenities adds to the experience.

People are saying

"I found the po'boy sandwich extremely delightful and tasty."

"I love the tasty and filling Po' Boy sandwiches here."

"The sandwich could use more sauce and veggies for better flavor."

Good to know

1

Oyster special on Tuesdays costs $1.50 each.

2

Lunch specials are available from 12pm to 3pm.

3

Happy hour features discounted oysters on Tuesdays.

04
KJUN image 1
KJUN image 2
KJUN image 3
View all
🥪 Shrimp Po Boy
🥪 Sandwich
🇺🇸 American Food
Unique
More

Small space with fewer than 25 seats creates an intimate vibe with chef's passion visible. Shrimp po' boy offers balanced flavor and just right size, while fried chicken sandwich shines with rich flavor and careful packing. Jazz music adds a soulful vibe to the cozy spot.

People are saying

"The fried chicken sandwich here is juicy and crispy."

"The fried chicken and po' boy sandwiches are amazing."

"The shrimp po' boy tastes delicious and satisfying."

Good to know

1

Making a reservation is recommended because the restaurant is often fully booked.

2

The lunch special is time-sensitive and can be missed if not planned properly.

3

KJUN is BYOB (Bring Your Own Bottle), so bring your favorite drink.

05
Defonte's Sandwich Shop image 1
Defonte's Sandwich Shop image 2
Defonte's Sandwich Shop image 3
View all
🥪 Shrimp Po Boy
🥪 Sandwich
📻 Vintage
🍗 Chicken Parmigiana
More

Old-school sandwich shop with Italian pictures on walls and a fast-paced, festive atmosphere. No indoor seating, but picnic tables outside offer a casual spot to eat. Only cash payments accepted, adding to the basic, no-frills vibe.

People are saying

"I had the best sandwiches I've ever had here."

"The sandwiches are huge and taste great."

"I think it's the best sandwich spot around."

Good to know

1

They only accept cash; the ATM on site has a $3.50 fee.

2

Customers should come hungry because they serve large portions.

3

They only serve shrimp sandwiches on Fridays.

06
Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar image 1
Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar image 2
Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar image 3
View all
🥪 Shrimp Po Boy
🥪 Sandwich
🥘 Food
🍾 Bottomless
More

Seafood restaurant with a Cajun theme and beach-inspired decor creates a lively, welcoming atmosphere. Music ranges from old school to disco, often featuring a live DJ that energizes the space. Seating varies from compact and crowded to spacious, attracting guests who enjoy all-you-can-eat seafood options.

People are saying

"I can't get enough of their tasty food and drinks."

"The lively vibe and seafood always hit the spot."

"The seafood boils are fresh and full of flavor."

Good to know

1

Happy hour only applies if you sit at the bar.

2

The all-you-can-eat price is $45.99 per person.

3

Customers are charged a gratuity fee even if only two people are eating.

07
Kakes NYC image 1
Kakes NYC image 2
Kakes NYC image 3
View all

Kakes NYC

🥪 Shrimp Po Boy
🥪 Sandwich
😎 Chill
🍗 Chicken And Waffles
More

Indoor space has retractable roofing and loud live DJ music, making it lively but noisy. Shrimp po boy offers seasoned shrimp cooked perfectly, while sandwiches like short rib and hot honey chicken bring bold flavors. Outdoor seating provides fresh air and a unique social atmosphere with smoking allowed.

People are saying

"You have to try the short rib sandwich with truffle fries."

Good to know

1

Tickets for events cost $25 per person, charged at entry.

2

The establishment requires ID checks and waiver signing for entry.

3

Infused and non-infused food and drink options are available, including vegan choices.

08
NBHD Brulee image 1
NBHD Brulee image 2
NBHD Brulee image 3
View all
🥪 Shrimp Po Boy
🥪 Sandwich
🍳 Breakfast
🇺🇸 American Food
More

Spacious coffee shop offers a Cajun French aesthetic and cozy covered outdoor seating. Shrimp po boys feature fresh, high-quality ingredients with a flavorful grilled option. Egg, Cheese, and Biscuit sandwich feels homey and inviting, pairing well with coffee and homemade lemonade.

People are saying

"I loved the tasty food and great coffee here."

"I loved the homemade sandwiches, especially the bacon egg and cheese."

"Some sandwiches were cold, but others tasted great."

Good to know

1

The establishment offers a variety of breakfast and lunch options, and drinks.

2

You can dine in, sit outside, or take food to go.

3

The coffee shop is located at the heart of Harlem.

09
Shipwreck Seafood Boutique image 1
Shipwreck Seafood Boutique image 2
Shipwreck Seafood Boutique image 3
View all
🥪 Sandwich
🥪 Shrimp Po Boy
🦞 Fresh Seafood
🦞 Seafood
More

Small, cozy seafood market with open windows and outdoor seating creates a fresh, upscale feel. The atmosphere is welcoming and clean, with good music adding to the positive vibe. Regulars enjoy fresh, high-quality seafood in a boutique neighborhood setting.

People are saying

"The sandwiches here are delicious and fresh."

"The fish sandwiches are tasty but a bit pricey."

"The seafood sandwiches and sides hit the spot."

Good to know

1

The shop accepts credit cards and mobile payments.

2

Parking is available on the street, but can be limited during peak hours.

3

Expect longer wait times during weekends due to higher foot traffic.

10
Lowerline image 1
Lowerline image 2
Lowerline image 3
View all
🥪 Shrimp Po Boy
🥪 Sandwich
🍲 Étouffée
🍲 Crawfish Étouffée
More

Small space with intimate setting offers cozy New Orleans charm. Shrimp po' boy delivers balanced Cajun flavors, paired well with fresh bread keeping sandwiches crisp. Menu variety includes roast beef and brisket sandwiches, enhancing the approachable vibe.

People are saying

"The roast beef po' boy sandwich is a 5-star affair."

"This Shrimp Po Boy offers authentic New Orleans flavors."

"The sandwiches are fresh and really big."

Good to know

1

The oyster happy hour is from 5:30 to 6:30 PM with half-off oysters.

2

Seating is limited if you want to sit indoors.

3

You can order half portions of most entrees for easy sampling.