Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to the US

American food pumpkin pie

You appreciate the classics, and a proper slice of pumpkin pie is the only way to round out an authentic American meal.

Based on 628 Opinions
+625
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Kerber's Farm image 1
Kerber's Farm image 2
Kerber's Farm image 3
View all

Bright, spacious bakery with white and light wood decor and fresh flowers on tables creates a welcoming, cozy atmosphere blending coastal grandmother style with a clean, farm feel. Seating is limited despite generous indoor space, and vintage details add charm. Early opening hours and free WiFi support a relaxed, inviting pace.

Pumpkin pie here gets rave reviews and is considered delicious by many. It stands out as a Thanksgiving favorite for ordering.

Chicken pot pie stands out with flaky pastry and tender chicken, offering a flavorful and hot experience. Pulled pork pockets come large enough to share, while pies like pumpkin and apple add a sweet finish.

People are saying

"I thought the pumpkin pie was the best of all time."

"The chicken pot pie pocket is flaky, hot, and has tender chicken."

"I thought the pumpkin pie was the best I had ever had."

Good to know

1

Expect a 20-minute wait for food during busy weekend mornings.

2

The savory pie is a popular choice among regulars.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash is also welcome.

02
Sweet Sweetz Ice Cream and Desserts image 1

Giant checkers board anchors a cozy, family-friendly dessert shop with a fun atmosphere. Homemade pies and desserts fill the air with comforting smells, drawing a crowd that enjoys kid-friendly entertainment and a welcoming vibe.

Pumpkin pie has a slightly silky texture and comes with a very generous amount of whipped cream. It balances sweetness well and stands out among other desserts like peach cobbler and banana pudding.

Pecan pie stands out with a warm slice topped by vanilla ice cream. Other desserts include key lime pie, apple pie, pumpkin pie with whipped cream, and chocolate and Oreo pies.

People are saying

"I went back the next day for another peach cobbler."

"The American Food here, especially the pies, is life-changing."

"The pumpkin pie was delicious and perfectly sweet."

Good to know

1

Whole pies can be ordered in advance through their website.

2

Desserts include ice cream, cakes, and pies made in-house.

3

Slices of pie are available for individual purchase.

03
Pop Pie Co. image 1
Pie shop

Pie shop offers cozy outdoor seating with heated lamps and a charming storefront featuring window counters. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, attracting groups and casual meetups with a positive vibe. Location on a busy street provides good people watching and a snug, inviting environment.

Offers a vegan pumpkin pie alongside classic slices. Pumpkin pie pairs well with pecan pie and chicken pot pie. The pumpkin pie is consistently very good and satisfying.

Chicken pot pie features a flaky crust with a creamy gravy filled with chicken and veggies. Desserts like the key lime pie and salted caramel apple pie stand out for their rich flavors and freshness.

People are saying

"The key lime pie's flavor and texture were truly exceptional."

"I couldn't stop eating the Key Lime Pie, it's exceptional."

"I devoured the pumpkin pie; it was delicious."

Good to know

1

Pop Pie Co. does not accept cash; they only take card payments.

2

Parking is challenging with only street parking available.

3

There are few tables inside, but plenty of outdoor seating.

04
Little Pie Company image 1

Open kitchen reveals bakers crafting pies, filling the air with buttery pastry aroma. Small, cozy space offers outdoor shaded seating and a homey atmosphere. Constant flow of people creates a pleasant, relaxed vibe.

Mini pumpkin pie offers a fresh and tasty option, though it costs around $12. Pumpkin pie is a key part of holiday meals like Thanksgiving and Christmas here, with a delicious flavor that many enjoy.

Apple pies stand out with sour cream and walnut variations that many find excellent. Key lime pie balances tartness and sweetness well, while pecan pie offers a rich, delicious flavor.

People are saying

"I tasted the best key lime pie I have ever had."

"You have to try the sour cream apple pie; it's a must-try."

"I loved the pumpkin pie; I wished we could eat it year round."

Good to know

1

Little Pie Co offers 50% off select pies at 7 PM daily.

2

Pre-order pies for holidays like Thanksgiving to ensure availability.

3

Expect high prices; pies can cost around $64 each.

05
Beets and Carrots image 1
New American restaurant

Small New American spot shines with farm-to-table freshness and a laid-back vibe. Pumpkin pie is rich and smooth, paired with pumpkin ice cream. Classic American dishes like lobster roll and biscuits with gravy offer hearty, fresh flavors.

Pumpkin pie comes with pumpkin ice cream on the side. The pie has a rich, smooth texture and deep pumpkin flavor.

Pumpkin pie comes with pumpkin ice cream and apple pie with cheddar ice cream. Lobster Roll tastes fresh and is perfectly cooked. Biscuits and gravy served with eggs and bacon offer a hearty option.

People are saying

"The Date Spots here have dishes packed with flavor, like the borscht."

"The American Food here, especially the mac and cheese, is rich and creamy."

"I thought the pumpkin pie was the best I had ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times for food due to a small kitchen and limited staff.

2

The restaurant is BYOB, so bring your own drinks to enjoy with your meal.

3

Prices are on the higher side, with a half chicken costing around $30.

06
Winston Pies image 1
Pie shop

Pie shop offers freshly baked aroma and a welcoming atmosphere with a charming outdoor area for enjoying pie and coffee. Pies feature exceptional crusts and a variety of flavors including gluten-free and vegan options. Pricing is high, reflecting quality ingredients and thoughtful design.

Pumpkin pie draws early queues during the festive season, showing its seasonal popularity. The last pies often include both apple and pumpkin, highlighting demand.

Pecan pie stands out as a best seller with a rich, nutty flavor. The apple pie offers a buttery crust and a balanced sweetness. Pumpkin pie appears regularly, especially around Thanksgiving.

People are saying

"The pie crust here is perfectly buttery and delicious."

"The pies here are heavenly, with a perfect balance of sweet and flaky crust."

"I enjoyed having the pumpkin pie every year for Thanksgiving."

Good to know

1

Winston Pies offers gluten-free and vegan options without sacrificing taste or texture.

2

The price of the slices is $10.00 each.

3

A whole pie costs $59.

07
Petee's Pie Company image 1

Small space with cozy seating and cute decor creates an intimate vibe. Warmth from baking fills the air with buttery, sweet aromas. Quiet during the day, it draws pie lovers seeking homestyle flavors and a nostalgic feel.

Pumpkin Pie stands out as the most popular pie here. It costs around $40 but sometimes has burned edges and tastes similar to supermarket versions.

Apple pie stands out with its fresh ingredients, buttery crust, and crispiness. The chicken pot pie offers a rich, savory option, while the Brown Butter Honey Pecan pie features a noticeable honey flavor and buttery crust.

People are saying

"The American Food here, especially the pies, is amazing."

"The banana cream pie here is unreal in flavor."

"I thought the Pumpkin Pie was incredible."

Good to know

1

Pies are sold by the slice or whole.

2

Prices for pies range from $7.25 to $8 per slice.

3

There is limited seating in the pie shop.

08
House of Pies image 1

Classic American diner with vintage dรฉcor and a nostalgic atmosphere that feels cozy and inviting. Offers both indoor seating and a recently cleaned outdoor patio with views of the Hollywood Hills. Known for superb pies and a casual, homey vibe suitable for breakfast and casual meals.

Pumpkin pie has a balanced flavor and a delicious taste. It pairs well with soy milk and stands out among other pies like banana cream and chocolate cream.

Steak and eggs come after a hike, with a patty melt served with grape jelly standing out. Pies like Bavarian chocolate, banana cream, and key lime offer rich, memorable flavors. Chicken wings and waffles also appear as a notable dish.

People are saying

"The lemon meringue pie had perfect meringue and lemon flavor."

"You have to try the Dutch apple pie; it's perfectly balanced."

"I thought the pumpkin pie had the best balance of flavors."

Good to know

1

Parking is available, but the lot can be limited and small.

2

Expect delayed service during peak hours as the place gets packed.

3

Prices for pie slices are over $7 each.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...