Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in the US

Ice cream sandwich spots

You want an authentic treat, and you know exactly what a real ice cream sandwich should taste like.

Based on 641 Opinions
+638
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Bekdash Ice cream & Desserts image 1
Bekdash Ice cream & Desserts image 2
Bekdash Ice cream & Desserts image 3
View all

Ice cream shop offers indoor and outdoor seating with a spacious, beautifully decorated interior and an authentic atmosphere. The vibe is clean, quiet, and inviting with good music and occasional live shows mixing sweets. Visitors often enjoy the wide variety of desserts in a setting that supports eating and studying.

Middle Eastern desserts come with authentic flavors and generous portions. Knafeh and baklava ice cream offer rich, creamy tastes true to tradition, paired with authentic Syrian ice cream and coffee.

Baklava ice cream sandwiches combine crunch, sweetness, and nuttiness with creamy ice cream. Variations include pistachio and chocolate sauce, creating a unique and flavorful dessert experience.

People are saying

"The Arabic ice cream here is authentic and amazing."

"The ice cream here is rich, velvety, and authentically delicious."

"The baklava ice cream sandwich was one of the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

On Tuesdays and Thursdays, they serve a breakfast platter similar to tapas but Middle Eastern.

2

During Ramadan, they offer special items.

3

They have unique desserts that are not commonly found elsewhere.

02
Tio Colo image 1
Cuban restaurant

Small space blends ice cream shop and Cuban pizza place with minimalistic decor and a family-oriented vibe. Atmosphere stays cozy and chill, mostly serving take-out with limited seating. Authentic flavors stand out, especially in Cuban pizzas and ice cream sandwiches.

Authentic Cuban flavors shine in the ice cream sandwiches and pizza here. The ice cream bites carry genuine Cuban taste that stands out from other local spots.

Guava ice cream sandwiches stand out with authentic Cuban flavor and a homemade touch. These treats offer a delicious, memorable taste that stays with you.

People are saying

"I found the Cuban pizzas here to be delicious and authentic."

"The Cuban ice cream sandwich here is authentic and delicious."

"I found the ice cream bites to have that authentic flavor from Cuba."

Good to know

1

Tio Colo is primarily a take-out place with no seating available.

2

The menu offers a variety of authentic Cuban pizzas and ice cream sandwiches.

3

Prices at Tio Colo are reasonable for the quality of food offered.

03
Mitr Thai Restaurant image 1
Thai restaurant

Large venue with beautiful artwork and dangling bamboo stick art creates a unique atmosphere. Music is loud house and club style, making conversation challenging. Tables are packed closely together, contributing to a crowded feel despite the attractive setting.

Offers authentic Thai cuisine with dishes that capture traditional flavors. Service is consistently great, enhancing the overall experience.

A warm pillowy milk bun splits open to hold sticky rice, jackfruit, and a generous scoop of ice cream. The coconut and jackfruit flavors stand out in this dessert.

People are saying

"The food here is incredibly delicious and flavorful."

"I found the Thai food here to be so flavorful and authentic."

"You have to try the Thai-style ice cream sandwich with sweet rice."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended, especially on weekends.

2

Every party has an hour and fifteen minutes to eat.

3

The wait time is 1 hour during peak hours.

04
Huarachis Taqueria image 1
Taco restaurant

Vibrant pink dรฉcor, neon lights, and Mexican trinkets create a modern vecindad vibe with an energetic, lively atmosphere. Music often plays loudly, filling the space with a club-like energy where dancing happens. The crowd is vibrant, and the design feels Instagram-worthy and trendy.

Tacos and dishes deliver authentic Mexican flavor and heat with fresh, homemade taste. Quesadillas bring a nostalgic, authentic vibe, served hot and quickly. The ambiance adds to the experience with vibrant dรฉcor and cultural accents.

The ice cream sandwich features a concha as the bread, giving it a sweet, soft texture. It pairs well with the other dishes and stands out as a super yummy dessert option.

People are saying

"The tacos here are superb, especially the tripa and asada."

"The food here tastes so authentic, like it's made fresh with love."

"I found the ice cream sandwich super yummy."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as the restaurant gets busy quickly.

2

Parking costs $30 for two hours due to limited free options.

3

The restaurant often runs out of popular menu items, so check availability.

05
Mr. Pita Mediterranean Grill image 1

Restaurant offers Arabic heritage decor with warm lighting and comfortable seating creating a welcoming atmosphere. Music enhances the relaxed vibe, making it suitable for gatherings. Space feels clean and spacious with an inviting, authentic ambiance.

Beef shawarma comes with authentic Arabic pita bread. The atmosphere and decor reflect a genuine Levantine style. Food tastes 100% authentic and stays true to Mediterranean flavors.

Baklava Ice Cream sandwich stands out with its large portion size and rich flavor. It pairs flaky pastry with creamy ice cream for a delicious dessert experience.

People are saying

"This Mediterranean food is so fresh and full of flavor."

"The food here is delicious and 100% authentic."

"The baklava ice cream sandwich is amazing."

Good to know

1

The prices at Mr. Pita Mediterranean Grill are very reasonable.

2

Portion sizes are generous, providing great value for the price.

3

The restaurant is known for its cleanliness and hygiene.

06
Eyval image 1
Persian restaurant

Warm, dark interiors blend with unique Iranian decor and LED Farsi lettering to create a cozy, inviting atmosphere. Three distinct rooms offer varied seating, some tucked away for privacy. Cocktails with saffron and black lime add a distinctive twist to the dining experience.

Flavors come through as authentic and rich. Dishes like Eggplant Cured Yogurt and freshly baked bread carry genuine tastes, with seafood grilled to perfection.

Saffron ice cream sandwiches deliver a rich, aromatic flavor that matches their online reputation. They stand out as a distinctive dessert option here.

People are saying

"The Persian ice cream sandwich was the best I had."

"You have to try the lamb ribs; they're a standout dish."

"I found authentic Persian food with an elevated twist."

Good to know

1

Reservations at Eyval open on Resy three weeks in advance; highly recommended on weekends.

2

The average wait with no reservations is about 2 hours.

3

If you do not have a reservation, you may get turned away after traveling to Bushwick.

07
Always Summer Ice Cream Cafe image 1

Small shop with bold yellow colors and fun interior design creates a cheerful, cozy vibe that invites lingering. Families and kids find plenty of seating and board games to enjoy. Unique, inventive ice cream flavors, including dairy-free options, set it apart from typical ice cream spots.

Flavors stay true to their roots with authentic Pakistani-Indian tastes. The pistachio-cardamom ice cream and Indian chai deliver perfectly balanced and genuine flavors.

Offers vegan ice cream sandwiches and affogato. The peanut butter cookie with chocolate ice cream stands out. Uses fresh ice cream and espresso from Olympia Coffee Roasters.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is the best I ever had."

"The ice cream flavors here are so authentic and delicious."

"The staff here is great and super friendly."

Good to know

1

One scoop of ice cream in a cup costs over $6.

2

The cafe offers dairy-free options for customers who need them.

3

Parking is easy and available near the cafe.

08
Hobak Korean BBQ image 1
Korean barbecue restaurant

Remodeled warehouse with an 80's Korean street theme creates an immersive, nostalgic setting. Thick smoke fills the air as staff cook meat tableside, adding to the authentic Korean BBQ experience. BTS music plays throughout, energizing a lively atmosphere that suits both casual dinners and special nights out.

Tender meats of various cuts come with many authentic Korean banchan. The setup reflects a 70s style nostalgia and the cooking stays true to traditional Korean BBQ.

Korean-style ice cream sandwich features oreo cookie ice cream in a tempura sandwich with red bean paste as glue. Green tea flavor stands out as a delicious dessert ending.

People are saying

"The meat here is marinated well and cooked to perfection."

"I found the Korean BBQ here to be really authentic, with tender meats and great banchan."

"The ice cream sandwich was a delicious ending to the meal."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to limited seating capacity.

2

Expect to pay around $200 for a meal for a party of four.

3

The restaurant offers a 20% discount for Nevada locals from Monday to Friday with ID.

09
Passerine image 1
Indian restaurant

Space combines modern cozy design with lush textures and moody lighting to create an immersive, warm atmosphere. Unique cocktails and an elevated bar and drawing room add to the sophisticated vibe. Guests find the setting inviting and the energy calm yet vibrant.

Flavors and textures capture authentic Indian cooking rarely found outside home kitchens. The dishes blend genuine ethnic tastes with a luxurious NYC vibe.

Elevated cocoa notes give the ice cream sandwich a nostalgic yet refined taste. It pairs well with other desserts like pistachio cremeux and offers a sweet, satisfying finish.

People are saying

"The food here was amazing, I can't wait to return."

"The flavors here are so authentic, they remind me of home cooking."

"The ice cream sandwich dessert was perfection."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to high demand, especially on weekends.

2

Prices are on the higher side, with naan costing $8 each.

3

The restaurant has limited vegetarian main courses available.

10
Sofreh image 1
Persian restaurant

Small space combines Persian-inspired decor with a laid-back, inviting atmosphere. Backyard patio offers quiet outdoor seating away from the street. Unique cocktails complement the setting with distinct flavors.

Menu offers a tantalizing array of authentic Persian dishes with incredible flavors. Food delivers a true culinary journey into Persian cuisine.

Outstanding flavor and texture make the ice cream sandwich stand out. It offers a special, memorable taste that many find life changing.

People are saying

"The food here is refined, deeply flavorful, and beautifully executed."

"I found the authentic Persian flavors here were masterfully executed and creative."

"The ice cream sandwich was particularly outstanding."

Good to know

1

Reservations must be made almost a month in advance.

2

Expect to spend some cash.

3

Reservations are recommended as they take the first five people for bar seating each night and the rest are waitlisted.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...