Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Milkshakes in the US

A thick, hand-spun milkshake is the only way to satisfy a craving for something cold and sweet.

Based on 678 Opinions
+675
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Halal Flamez image 1
Halal Flamez image 2
Halal Flamez image 3
View all
Halal restaurant

Halal restaurant offers clean decor and a warm, inviting atmosphere with classical Mediterranean music setting a pleasant mood. The place often gets crowded and has no seating, focusing on takeout and delivery. The vibe is friendly and chill, making it feel familiar and welcoming.

Shawarmas come out fresh and authentic with a clear focus on halal chicken over rice. The menu sticks to delicious halal food that stays true to its roots.

Milkshakes stand out with their banana pudding flavor that tastes wild. Desserts include very good milkshakes that many enjoy.

People are saying

"The Mediterranean food here, especially the shawarma, is juicy and perfectly spiced."

"The falafel here is delicious, flavorful, and authentic."

"The owner's friendly and attentive service makes it feel authentic."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has no seating space, so you must order takeout or delivery.

2

Ordering ahead is your best bet to avoid long lines during peak hours.

3

The prices of food are great for the area.

02
Square Diner image 1

Old train carriage design creates an authentic diner atmosphere with classic booths and a rustic style. Cozy and welcoming vibe feels like stepping back in time, with sunny outdoor seating and good music enhancing the experience.

Old-fashioned train carriage setting creates a classic diner atmosphere. Presence of New York cops adds to the authentic NYC vibe. Serves traditional American breakfast with no-frills style.

Milkshakes come in classic flavors like chocolate and black and white. They pair well with breakfast combos and offer a rich, creamy texture that stands out.

People are saying

"The diner food here is simple, fresh, and delicious."

"It's an authentic diner with a classic 1950s aesthetic."

"I enjoyed the chocolate milkshake; it was amazing."

Good to know

1

The diner accepts card payments, making it convenient for most visitors.

2

Prices are high, with some dishes costing over $20.

3

Portions are generous, providing good value for the price.

03
Court Square Diner image 1

Chrome and glass decor create a classic 1950s diner look with a retro mom-and-pop vibe. The atmosphere feels authentic and nostalgic, filled with oldies music and a comfortable pace. Open 24 hours, it offers a true New York diner experience that blends vintage style with modern touches.

Classic 50's themed decor sets a cozy, authentic diner atmosphere. The menu features authentic American cuisine with good value and clean, well-kept interiors.

Thick milkshakes stand out with rich, creamy texture and flavors like chocolate and coffee brownie. Egg creams also appear as a notable option alongside these extra thick milkshakes.

People are saying

"This diner's food is hearty and pretty darn delicious."

"I experienced an authentic American diner atmosphere and style."

"I enjoyed the yummy, thick milkshakes here."

Good to know

1

The diner is open 24/7, 365 days a year.

2

Late night dining is available.

3

The diner serves brunch on Christmas Day.

04
Mr P's Homemade Ice Cream image 1

Ice cream shop showcases Caribbean-inspired flavors in a colorful, spacious setting with indoor seating and sampling options. Bright and welcoming atmosphere reflects a family-run passion for homemade treats. The vibe blends cultural heritage with a modern twist on classic ice cream.

Fresh ice cream offers an authentic Caribbean flavor with a natural texture that avoids a heavy cream feel. The taste stays true to traditional recipes without artificial heaviness.

Cookies and cream and a unique half mauby half cherry coconut flavor stand out among the milkshake options. Milkshakes come alongside ice creams and hefty slices of cake.

People are saying

"The staff here is so friendly, they really take care of you."

"You can try unique flavors like soursop and grape nut in their milkshakes."

"The authentic Caribbean flavors were amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Mr. P's celebrates Labor Day weekend with special flavors like lemon ginger and mango.

2

The establishment offers a $3 portion size for ice cream.

3

You can choose 3 flavors on arrival for a tasting experience.

05
Brooklyn Diner USA image 1

Classic diner space with cherry wood decor and vintage neon signage creates a nostalgic 1960s vibe. Atmosphere shifts from laid-back mornings to chaotic, noisy evenings with loud music. Outdoor seating offers a pleasant alternative to the lively interior.

Booth-style seating and attentive staff create an authentic diner ambiance. The place offers classic American diner vibes with reasonable prices and a genuine New York feel.

Milkshakes here stand out for their rich flavor and creamy texture. The Oreo and strawberry options are especially popular and come highly recommended.

People are saying

"The diner food, especially the pastrami sandwich, is delicious."

"I thought the milkshake was good."

"I loved the authentic American diner atmosphere."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $120 for three dishes at the diner.

2

The diner offers takeout options for those on the go.

3

You need to order one menu item per person.

06
Holy Burger image 1
Fast food restaurant

Graffiti art covers walls in a small, cozy space with comfortable seating and a modern vibe. Music plays at a pleasant volume, creating a welcoming atmosphere that feels both casual and inviting. Crayons and coloring pages add a family-friendly touch for kids under 12.

Burgers deliver a rich, authentic taste with flavors that stand out clearly.

Milkshakes come in a creamy texture with a vanilla flavor that is not overly sweet but indulgent. Sizes vary, with some milkshakes being quite small despite a $7 price tag.

People are saying

"I found the burgers here to be juicy and flavorful."

"I experienced an authentic taste with rich flavors."

"The milkshake was perfectly creamy and not too sweet."

Good to know

1

Holy Cow Burgers offers a 100% halal menu with beef bacon.

2

They have gluten-free and vegan options available.

3

Combo meals are priced at $8.

07
Diner 24 NYC image 1

Classic diner design blends with cozy, comforting atmosphere and calm, happy energy. Music ranges from Frank Sinatra classics to a jukebox with personal selections, enhancing the nostalgic vibe. Seating includes comfy chairs with outlets, supporting relaxed meetings or work sessions.

Booths and classic decor create an authentic diner feel. The menu offers a casual, quality American meal that captures the traditional diner experience.

Rich, creative milkshakes stand out here, featuring unique flavors like the baklava milkshake. The shakes offer indulgent and distinctive tastes not commonly found elsewhere.

People are saying

"The diner staff here is so friendly and attentive."

"The milkshakes here are ridiculously large and photograph-worthy."

"It's an authentic American diner experience, like stepping into a classic movie."

Good to know

1

Brunch is available any day.

2

Happy hour offers $4 beers and $7 cocktails at the bar.

3

Breakfast is served all day.

08
Bill's Bar & Burger image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Spacious, bright burger joint with a full service bar and multiple TVs showing sports. Atmosphere feels relaxed yet busy, with a fun American vibe. Tables and seating encourage quick turnover, fitting a lively, casual dining experience.

The spot offers an authentic American atmosphere with a vibe that feels genuinely classic. Burgers here capture the true American taste and the overall ambience stays consistent with that theme.

Monster milkshakes come highly recommended and pair well with juicy burgers. The milkshakes are consistently described as fantastic and a satisfying choice alongside other menu items.

People are saying

"I found the burgers here to be excellent and generous."

"You have to try the milkshakes; they were out of this world."

"It's an authentic American place with a great atmosphere."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended during the Christmas holiday season.

2

The restaurant's happy hour only applies to the bar area, not to tables.

3

The happy hour offers reduced beer prices and half-priced starters.

09
Chai Wala image 1

Cafe offers beautiful interior and charming backyard patio with plenty of seating for relaxing or socializing. Atmosphere feels welcoming and lively with clean surroundings and a good music selection. Space suits those seeking a refreshing and relaxed vibe.

Food offers flavorful and aromatic tastes with fresh ingredients and authentic spices. Traditional Pakistani sweets and snacks deliver a vibrant and genuine experience.

Milkshakes here stand out for their rich flavor and creamy texture. The Oreo milkshake is a popular choice, delivering a satisfying dessert experience.

People are saying

"I would definitely recommend trying the crepes here."

"The staff here is so friendly and welcoming, it makes the whole visit pleasant."

"The staff here are so friendly and welcoming."

Good to know

1

The restaurant charges a service charge for takeout orders.

2

They charge an automatic 3.5% service fee before asking if customers are dining in or taking out.

3

The spot is open until midnight during Ramadan.

10
Junior's Restaurant & Bakery image 1
American restaurant

Large space filled with retro decor like mirrors and tin ceilings creates a vintage Brooklyn vibe. Oldies music plays, adding to the authentic American atmosphere. Known for legendary cheesecake and classic dishes, it offers a nostalgic dining experience.

Authentic New York cheesecake stands out alongside classic American breakfast and old school diner fare. The spot also serves a genuine egg cream in a setting that feels unchanged for decades.

Milkshakes here stand out for their rich flavors like the New Yorker with strawberry cheesecake and the perfect Oreo shake. Packaging keeps shakes cold and fresh, making them a solid choice for those needing soft foods.

People are saying

"I thought the cheesecake here was the best I ever had."

"The strawberry banana milkshake here is the best I've ever had."

"I thought the authentic cheesecake was the best I had."

Good to know

1

Joining the waitlist on Yelp before arriving is recommended to save on waiting time.

2

A milk shake is $10, and sandwiches start around $20.

3

There is absolutely no parking on 45th street.

11
Brooklyn Diner image 1

Large, bright diner with traditional New York decor and retro exterior creates an authentic vibe. Atmosphere feels lively and celebrity-infused, with comfortable seating and booths ideal for people watching. Design uses shutters and mirrors to avoid feeling cramped, distinguishing it from typical NYC diners.

An authentic vibe fills the space with a true Manhattan dining experience. The menu offers authentic American food and well-balanced Mexican cuisine including standout chickpea hummus.

Milkshakes come in Oreo, strawberry blonde cheesecake, and classic flavors like NY cheesecake. They pair well with desserts like an 8-inch cookie or chocolate cake and deliver a delicious, rich taste.

People are saying

"This Diner burger was juicy, flavorful, and cooked perfectly."

"I had the best milkshake I've ever eaten here."

"The food here feels truly authentic American."

Good to know

1

Breakfast is served all day.

2

The restaurant closes at 9:00 p.m.

3

Reservations are needed for this diner.

12
Tom's Restaurant image 1
American restaurant

Old-fashioned diner style creates a cozy, nostalgic atmosphere with Seinfeld memorabilia decorating the walls. The space feels family-friendly and quiet, offering a break from busy surroundings. Narrow corridors and crowded seating add a compact, intimate vibe.

An authentic diner with a 90s New York vibe and an interior that feels genuine and cool. Food offers good value and the service stays friendly throughout.

Milkshakes come in large portions that can easily be shared. Flavors like chocolate and coffee stand out for their rich, sweet taste and creamy texture.

People are saying

"This diner has really good, simple food done well."

"I enjoyed the plentiful and delicious milkshake."

"It's an authentic American diner with a cool retro feel."

Good to know

1

The total cost for an omelet, eggs Benedict, and coffee was $47.60.

2

The location is super convenient and accessible by subway.

3

Sometimes it can be very busy, so plan to go early or wait for tables.

13
Carve Cafe & Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small space with spacious seating and simple furnishings creates a cozy setting. Atmosphere feels luxurious and friendly, with music adding to the vibe. Pizza draws attention for being remarkably delicious and popular, often enjoyed alongside pastries and milkshakes.

Offers an authentic taste of New York-style pizza with flavors that stay true to the original.

Milkshakes come from a pastry counter that also serves frozen drinks. The bacon cheeseburger and milkshake combo stands out as a solid choice.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."

"This authentic New York-style pizza has the perfect balance of crisp, chewy crust."

"I found the milkshake to be great."

Good to know

1

Be prepared to take out food during busy times.

2

They let you use the restroom anytime.

3

Coffee and bagel cost $3.50 at the Carve Cafe.

14
K-Munchies image 1
Korean restaurant

Small space with limited seating creates a cozy but sometimes loud atmosphere during busy times. Korean street food flavors stand out, especially smash burgers, potato corndogs, and twist donuts made fresh to order. Casual vibe suits quick bites and late-night visits.

Food captures authentic Korean street flavors from the 1980s countryside. Dishes like twisted donuts and corn dogs bring nostalgic, old-fashioned tastes at affordable prices.

Milkshakes come in extra vanilla and smooth, refreshing styles. Some are small and very milky, priced around $8.

People are saying

"I thought the corn dog was delicious and crispy."

"I found the authentic Korean twisted bread tasted like it did 30-40 years ago."

"I really liked the burger; it tasted fresh and was satisfying."

Good to know

1

All snacks outside after 7 pm are half price every day.

2

There is a special, discounted menu available from 10 am to 2 pm.

3

Expect at least a 1-hour wait if you walk in.

15
Westway Diner image 1

Classic American diner with nostalgic decor and big red banquettes creates a genuine, hardworking vibe. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming but can be uncomfortable due to noise from dishes. Seating is cozy with comfortable booths and some outdoor options.

Offers a truly authentic American diner experience with a strong focus on classic breakfast dishes. The flavors stay true to traditional New York diner style, making each bite distinctly authentic.

Milkshakes come with a classic diner vibe and taste excellent. They pair well with pancakes and sandwiches, making them a solid choice.

People are saying

"This diner has amazing, classic American comfort food."

"The food here is delicious and traditional."

"You have to try the chocolate milkshake; it's especially good."

Good to know

1

Arrive early for breakfast to avoid long queues.

2

Happy hour offers $4 beers and $6 cocktails on weekdays.

3

Expect busy breakfast hours on rainy Saturdays.

16
Junior's Restaurant and Bakery image 1

Space combines retro diner vibe with vibrant decor featuring red and yellow hues. Atmosphere stays fun and lively, often busy and chaotic, with music that is pleasant and not overpowering. Crowd enjoys classic American comfort with standout cheesecake and a bar offering notable cocktails and beers.

Authentic American New York cheesecake stands out here, capturing the true taste of the city. Friendly, chatty staff add to the lively atmosphere that reflects classic New York dining.

Milkshakes come with generous portions and rich flavors like strawberry and banana that taste fresh. Some include cheesecake on top, making them very filling and over the top.

People are saying

"I found their famous cheesecake to be truly delicious."

"I thought the cheesecake and milkshake were really good."

"I tried the authentic cheesecake; it's rich, creamy, and perfectly balanced."

Good to know

1

You can put your name on a waitlist to plan your visit better.

2

The place is busy and open till midnight, close to Times Square.

3

On Saturday night at 6:00 PM, there was a 10-minute wait for a table for two.

17
Halal Chicken-N-Chapli image 1
Halal restaurant

Halal restaurant offers a clean, well-lit, and spacious setting with friendly, warm atmosphere. Small seating area allows views into the kitchen, creating an open feel. Known for authentic chapli kebabs and fresh grilled chicken wraps, it draws those seeking flavorful halal dishes.

Chicken chapli platter offers fresh, authentic flavors. Signature Chapli Kebabs deliver rich, flavorful halal cuisine with great hospitality.

Milkshakes taste like real milkshakes without any powder or chalky flavor. Staff take 30 to 40 minutes to prepare each one, and service is consistently very poor during milkshake orders.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

"The grilled chicken here is juicy, fresh, and delicious."

"I found the chapli kebabs here to be authentic, fresh, and juicy."

Good to know

1

The restaurant charges a credit card fee.

2

The portion size of the salads is good.

3

The amount of fries given is comparable to a Burger King Medium.

18
Harlem Shake image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Smash burger restaurant with authentic atmosphere and old New York decor creates a distinctive setting. Live music often plays on the patio, adding to a friendly, neighborhood vibe. Burgers are highly praised, considered among the best by many.

An authentic diner with a super authentic Harlem vibe offers classic burger cuisine. The atmosphere and service feel genuine and welcoming.

Milkshakes come in bold flavors like red velvet and cookies and cream. The red velvet cake milkshake stands out as a must-try with rich taste. Strawberry cheesecake milkshake features actual cheesecake, adding a creamy texture.

People are saying

"I found the burgers here to be sublime, truly the best."

"I found the red velvet milkshake to be incredible."

"It's got this super authentic Harlem vibe and old-school charm."

Good to know

1

Live jazz performances occur every Sunday at 3pm on the terrace.

2

The Mr/Miss Harlem Shake competition is held annually.

3

There is no table service; customers order at the counter.

19
Carnegie Diner & Cafe image 1

Diner offers a clean, spacious interior with music-themed decor and a vibrant atmosphere near a busy city area. The space includes outdoor seating with pet-friendly amenities and features lively background music and sports broadcasts. Strong, well-priced cocktails and bottomless mimosas add to the energetic vibe.

Authentic New York deli flavor shines in the carefully prepared pastrami. The diner offers a reliable breakfast spot with great quality food that captures an old-school NYC dining experience.

Homemade milkshakes stand out with rich flavors like the Brownie Extravaganza. Options include towering skyscraper milkshakes and creative combos like the milkshake waffle sandwich.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, well-seasoned, and beautifully plated."

"The milkshakes here are rich and a meal unto themselves."

"The portions here are enormous; you'll definitely want to come hungry."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 3-7 PM with great prices on drinks.

2

Reservations are recommended for breakfast to avoid long waits.

3

Breakfast is available all day, so you can enjoy it anytime.

20
Jackson Hole Diner image 1
American restaurant

1950s Art Deco-style chrome diner with working jukeboxes at every table creates a nostalgic atmosphere filled with retro memorabilia and old-fashioned booths. The vibe is authentic and lively, evoking a bygone era with cash-only payment adding to the classic feel.

Classic 1950s style shines through with lots of chrome and a real orange juicer. The diner serves an authentic American burger and sits by a busy road, adding to its genuine atmosphere.

Milkshakes come with a classic diner vibe, featuring a jukebox and vintage signs. The vanilla peanut butter flavor stands out as amazing, and all milkshakes served are consistently delicious.

People are saying

"This diner has such a classic, nostalgic vibe."

"The Jackson Hole milkshake with chocolate ice cream was very good."

"It's got this really authentic diner atmosphere with lots of chrome."

Good to know

1

The establishment is cash only and does not accept credit cards.

2

The wait to be seated can be a while for brunch.

3

The restaurant offers a 2 for 1 deal on champagne, bellini, and mimosa.

21
Jackson Hole Burgers image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Old-style jukeboxes at each table create a nostalgic music experience in a setting that blends 1950s diner charm with an American country vibe. The atmosphere stays quiet and friendly, offering a leisurely, low-key place to enjoy burgers known for their juicy, flavorful quality.

Burgers here deliver an authentic American taste that stands apart from big chains. The flavors feel genuine and outside the box of typical fast food.

Spiked milkshakes stand out with alcoholic flavors like rum. They pair well with meals or as a treat. Some milkshakes may not always arrive or meet expectations.

People are saying

"I thought the burgers here were the best I ever had."

"I thought their milkshakes were the best."

"I experienced an authentic American burger here."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4 to 7pm with half-off cocktails.

2

The restaurant charges a 20% automatic tip for parties over five.

3

An extra charge applies for using a credit card.

22
Clinton St. Baking Company image 1
American restaurant

Small, busy restaurant with cramped seating and wrap-around windows offering city views. Atmosphere is warm and noisy, with fans instead of air conditioning and frequent interruptions. Popular spot known for best pancakes and a message-alert system for table readiness.

Hearty dishes and authentic pancakes define the breakfast here. The atmosphere feels friendly and true to classic American style.

Milkshakes come in boozy, coffee, and white chocolate varieties. They pair well with pancakes and biscuits, offering a delicious complement to breakfast items.

People are saying

"These pancakes are fluffy, flavorful, and worth the price."

"I thought the milkshakes were huge and delicious."

"I found the authentic American breakfast here to be unmissable."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required on weekends and highly recommended during the week.

2

Expect wait times of up to an hour during peak hours.

3

Get there early to avoid long lines, especially for breakfast.

23
Amorino Gelato - New York Times Square image 1

Gelato served in rose-shaped presentation stands out visually. Loud club music fills the space, creating a high-energy atmosphere. Self-serve ordering kiosks speed up lines, while outdoor seating expands capacity year-round.

Gelato features authentic Italian flavors with a fresh quality that matches classic Italian gelato. Rich aromas and tastes bring a genuine Italian experience.

Milkshakes feature pista and coffee hazelnut flavors with a gelato-like texture. They take a long time to serve and are not thick or traditional in style.

People are saying

"You have to try their specialty hot chocolate with gelato inside."

"I loved the authentic Italian gelato flavors."

"I found the pistachio and caramel milkshake flavors to be special."

Good to know

1

Customers must go to a kiosk to place their order and pay before standing in line.

2

In the event of a large crowd, expect a long wait.

3

Customers are not allowed to taste flavors before purchasing due to long lines.

24
George's image 1
American restaurant

Two-floor diner with retro decor and clear plastic screens creates a cozy, bustling atmosphere. Outdoor seating offers a lively spot to watch people, while inside feels authentic and homey with a steady flow of locals. Music adds to the energetic vibe despite some cramped spaces upstairs.

The diner offers an authentic New York City vibe with a bustling atmosphere full of locals. It serves a traditional American breakfast featuring surreal pancakes and some Mexican influences.

Milkshakes taste fresh and creamy with flavors like chocolate and Oreo standing out. They pair well with other dishes and offer a satisfying treat.

People are saying

"The Breakfast service here is quick and friendly."

"I loved the authentic American breakfast here."

"I highly recommend the milkshakes because they tasted fresh and creamy."

Good to know

1

Breakfast is served all day.

2

The diner has a break in the afternoon.

3

There is a $2 fee for non-cash payments.

25
Black Iron Burger Theater District | Hamburger restaurant Bar image 1

Spacious sports bar with plentiful screens showing live games and a lively atmosphere fueled by harmonious music and enthusiastic fans. The bar area offers a social spot for drinks, featuring a top-tier playlist blending 80s rock and pop. The vibe balances energetic and chill, making it a popular hangout for sports enthusiasts.

Very good burgers capture the authentic American style with classic onion rings and fries. The bar offers an authentic and friendly atmosphere with a laid-back vibe that feels true to New York.

Milkshakes come in vanilla flavor that is not overly sweet or heavy. They cost around $11 each and pair well with burgers and fries.

People are saying

"I thought the burgers looked fantastic and were very, very good."

"I thought the burger was the best I had ever tasted."

"These authentic American burgers are the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Happy hour beers are available until 7 PM for 6 euros.

2

The restaurant has a happy hour every day with great specials.

3

The restaurant can get very crowded after shows, so arrive early.

26
Nathan's Famous image 1
American restaurant

Outdoor seating with stone tables and umbrellas offers a classic boardwalk vibe and ocean breeze. Crowds gather around a bank-style line system feeding multiple cashiers, creating a lively atmosphere. Known for best hot dogs and cheese fries, it draws fans of iconic American beach food.

Street food comes fast and tasty with a typical American vibe. The authentic hot dog and New England Chowder deliver classic flavors true to their roots.

Milkshakes come thick and sweet with a rich, succulent flavor. Chocolate is a standout, delivering a deliciously creamy treat.

People are saying

"I loved the chili dog; it's the best American food I've ever had."

"You have to try the fast food here; it's a Coney Island boardwalk experience."

"I tasted the authentic hot dog, just like the original."

Good to know

1

The hot dog eating contest takes place annually on July 4th.

2

Happy hour includes discounts on Coney Island beer with hot dogs.

3

Expect long wait times during peak summer events like the hot dog contest.

27
Namkeen image 1
Chicken restaurant

Chicken restaurant offers a beautiful interior with an open processing area visible to diners. The atmosphere blends chill vibes with Desi music, creating a lively yet welcoming space. Board gamers often occupy much of the seating, adding to the energetic and social environment.

Food delivers authentic flavors and spices with a clear Pakistani flair. Chai comes creamy and genuine, and fries have authentic individual components.

Kulfi milkshake stands out with its unique flavor and richness. The kofi milkshake offers a delicious, not too sweet taste, providing a fresh twist on traditional shakes.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the halal options."

"The food here bursts with authentic Pakistani flavors and spices."

"I thought the milkshakes here were rich and delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant serves HALAL food.

2

There are no public bathrooms available for customers who dine in.

3

WARNING: HOT IS ACTUALLY HOT; be cautious with spice levels.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...