Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of US

Caprese salad and calamari

Made for those who want their light, fresh starters to transition seamlessly into crispy, salt-forward seafood.

Based on 653 Opinions
+650
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
La Rocca Rossa image 1
La Rocca Rossa image 2
La Rocca Rossa image 3
View all
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers an elegant interior with exposed stone and fireplace, creating a cozy yet upscale atmosphere. Outdoor patio provides a relaxing vibe ideal for small groups or couples. Cocktails and Italian wines receive frequent praise for their quality and balance.

The caprese salad features a pistachio twist and comes with a notably salty flavor that balances the ingredients. It includes a pesto accompaniment that adds a fresh, herby note.

Spanish Crispy Calamari stands out with its crispy texture and pairs well with homemade bread. It serves as a satisfying appetizer that complements drinks and offers good value.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the sauces, is complex and amazing."

"I'd go back just for the Spanish crispy calamari and bread."

"I loved the pistachio Caprese salad."

Good to know

1

Parking can be a hike if the lot is full.

2

The restaurant has a 1.5-hour time limit for dining.

3

There is no kidsโ€™ menu yet.

02
Prime 374 - Seafood & Steak image 1

Fine dining steakhouse with a modern, clean interior and a cozy, classy atmosphere. Bar area features live piano music and expertly crafted cocktails like espresso and lychee martinis. Space includes an upstairs private room suitable for gatherings, creating a special and inviting environment.

Fresh mozzarella pairs with flavorful, beautifully ripened tomatoes in the Caprese salad. The dish offers a simple yet incredibly tasty start to the meal.

Tender fried calamari comes with a pop of spice from cherry peppers and breaded peppers. The appetizer is full of flavor and works well for sharing.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious; the filet mignon is top 3."

"The calamari is perfectly cooked and tender."

"The Caprese salad has flavorful, beautifully ripened tomatoes and fresh mozzarella."

Good to know

1

Their $35 three-course dinners from 4pm to 5:30pm, Tuesday to Friday, are a great deal.

2

Happy hour features a light menu with discounted drinks from 4pm to 6pm.

3

Bottomless brunch is available on weekends with a set price.

03
Benny John's Bar and Grill image 1

Live guitar and jazz music create a relaxed vibe with cozy seating indoors and on a patio. Caprese salad shines with fresh ingredients, though tomatoes may need more balsamic in winter. Fried calamari is perfectly breaded and pairs well with salmon and lobster soup.

Freshness stands out with the Caprese salad offering a tasty mix of ingredients. Tomatoes sometimes need a bit more balsamic to boost flavor, especially in winter.

Fried calamari comes perfectly breaded and cooked, not rubbery or chewy. It pairs well with other dishes like salmon and lobster soup.

People are saying

"I've never had a steak cooked so perfectly to my preference."

"The calamari here is perfectly breaded and cooked, never rubbery."

"The Caprese salad was fresh and tasty."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has an all-day happy hour with a variety of appetizers.

2

Happy hour drink specials are available all night at the bar.

3

Reservations are recommended due to high demand during peak times.

04
Zia Maria Little Italy image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers homey atmosphere with live accordion music and table-side fresh pasta preparation. Outdoor seating provides a view of the illuminated Empire State Building with heaters for comfort. Staff engage guests with personalized entertainment and complimentary drinks.

Fresh tomatoes and creamy mozzarella make the Caprese salad stand out. It appeals even to those who usually avoid tomatoes.

Crispy fried calamari comes fresh and hot, paired with a spicy house sauce. The dish stands out as a must-have alongside other Italian favorites.

People are saying

"The pasta here is fresh and prepared right in front of you."

"The fried calamari was crispy, not greasy, and perfectly seasoned."

"The Caprese Salad's basil had an intensely green aroma."

Good to know

1

Birthday celebrations include a fun serenade by the wait staff.

2

The restaurant dims the lights around 4:40 PM for dinner ambiance.

3

An automatic 18% service charge is included for parties of two.

05
Cafe Fiorello image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers indoor and outdoor seating with heated outdoor dining that feels cozy despite a somewhat cramped space. Atmosphere is loud and lively, encouraging conversation but with high energy. Bar features expertly crafted cocktails and occasional treats like fresh baked cookies.

Fresh burrata stands out in the caprese salad here. The appetizer version offers a solid balance of flavors.

Grilled calamari stands out with its tender texture and pairs well with fresh leafy greens. It consistently appears as a delicious choice alongside other dishes.

People are saying

"I loved the amazing Italian food, especially the pasta."

"The Caprese Salad's burrata and fresh tomatoes were delicious."

"The calamari here was nice and fresh."

Good to know

1

Reservations are essential due to the restaurant's popularity.

2

They allow dogs in the outdoor seating area when it's not crowded.

3

Brunch and an all-day Italian menu are available on weekends.

06
ai Pazzi image 1
Italian restaurant

Elegant interior with an open kitchen and fireplace creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. Lighting balances between bright and dim, fostering a relaxing calmness throughout the space. Semi-private room and comfortable seating support both intimate and group dining experiences.

Tableside presentation highlights the freshness and visual appeal of the Caprese salad. It pairs well with meatballs and satisfies as a light, flavorful option.

Soft, not chewy, with a spicy dipping sauce. Portions come large and crispy.

People are saying

"The fresh pasta and meatballs here are divine."

"The calamari here is perfectly prepared, light and crisp."

"I loved the Caprese Salad; it was delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to the restaurant's growing popularity.

2

The restaurant does not have its own bathroom; guests must use the casino facilities.

3

Portions are large enough to share, making it great for groups.

07
La Bella Pizza Trattoria Italiana image 1

Small restaurant offers authentic Italian flavors with a cozy, intimate atmosphere that encourages casual conversation. Both indoor and outdoor seating accommodate guests, often accompanied by live music. The vibe feels warm and homey, making it suitable for quiet dinners or date nights.

A ball of mozzarella sits in the middle of a tomato ring in the La Caprese salad. It comes with a drizzle of balsamic from Italy, making it refreshing and tasty.

Fried calamari comes out light and cooked just right with a delicious sauce on the side. Portions tend to be smaller than expected, sometimes requiring extra sauce from other dishes.

People are saying

"The pasta here is al dente and deliciously rich."

"The La Caprese salad was super refreshing and tasty."

"The calamari here is delicious and cooked just right."

Good to know

1

There is easy parking available in the back lot, which is free.

2

Ask for the price of the specials before ordering.

3

Pasta dishes can range from $28 to $50.

08
Brisa Do Mar image 1
Italian restaurant

Upscale Italian restaurant with riverside patio and bright, airy dining room offers a peaceful water view and live Italian soprano music. Guests arrive by boat or on foot, enjoying a contemporary style that blends classic and creative dishes. The atmosphere stays welcoming and classy, suited for relaxed dinners or special occasions.

Salad features burrata and fresh avocado alongside classic Caprese ingredients. It pairs well with woodfire grill dishes like Pesto Chicken Pizza and Prawns Al Ajillo.

Calamari comes out crispy and flavorful. It pairs well with drinks and other starters like eggplant chips and garlic bread.

People are saying

"The pizza here is amazing, especially the wood-fired kind."

"I found the calamari and eggplant chips to be amazing."

"I've never had a Caprese salad this good, made with burrata and avocado."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended during events to avoid inconvenience.

2

Fashion shows and house music events are hosted regularly.

3

Gluten-free pasta options are available, but may vary seasonally.

09
Osteria Nonnino image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers tableside pasta preparation and live culinary shows in a cozy, beautifully decorated space with outdoor seating. Atmosphere is lively but can be noisy due to cramped seating and sound reverberation. Guests enjoy a warm, inviting vibe with a mix of contemporary and rustic design elements.

Fresh mozzarella stands out in the Caprese salad, paired with tomatoes that sometimes lack seasoning. The salad appears as a special and a starter alongside other Italian dishes.

Fried calamari comes out crispy and delicious. It pairs well with other dishes like arancini and polenta with sausage ragu.

People are saying

"The tableside Cacio e Pepe pasta is phenomenal."

"Our server Luca made the calamari experience unforgettable."

"The Caprese salad has some of the freshest mozzarella Iโ€™ve had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended due to high demand.

2

Expect long wait times for walk-ins, especially during peak hours.

3

Happy hour runs until 7pm with discounts on drinks and snacks.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...