Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Ice cream sandwiches and caramel in the US

The sweetness of caramel elevates a simple ice cream sandwich into something more indulgent. It is a classic treat that hits the spot on a warm afternoon.

Based on 715 Opinions
+712
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Mann's Homemade Ice Cream image 1
Mann's Homemade Ice Cream image 2
Mann's Homemade Ice Cream image 3
View all

Bright, adorable ice cream shoppe with a small town vibe and family-friendly atmosphere. Smell of homemade waffle cones fills the air, creating a homey, happy place where smiles are common. Offers color-changing spoons and a wide variety of over 45 unique homemade flavors.

GIANT ice cream sandwiches stand out with their size, enough to feed four people. Chocolate chip versions taste fresh and the homemade style ranks as a favorite dessert.

Salted caramel stands out with its homemade caramel topping and pairs well with sugar cone wafers. Bing cherries also come as a house-made topping that complements the caramel flavor.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was the best around."

"The owners here feel like family, so nice and caring."

"The salted caramel ice cream here is amazing and outstanding."

Good to know

1

Mann's Homemade Ice Cream offers over 45 unique flavors, including sugar-free and fat-free options.

2

Prices for ice cream start at $8.50 for a cup, comparable to other local shops.

3

All ice creams are homemade with no additives or preservatives.

02
Power Cone image 1
Ice cream shop

Small shop with modern decor and bright, cheery vibe creates a welcoming space. Energy feels optimistic and friendly, attracting a community-focused crowd. Known for best soft serve ice cream with natural ingredients and a standout sprinkle selection.

Ice cream sandwiches feature perfectly chewy cookies and come in large sizes. The lemon-vanilla flavor stands out with its bright citrus notes.

Caramel stands out as the highlight with a warm, rich flavor. The hot caramel sundae and caramel topping pair well with other sweets like hot fudge.

People are saying

"I found the soft serve here to be the best."

"You have to try the hot fudge; it's the best I've ever had."

"I loved the warm caramel, it was the highlight."

Good to know

1

Power Cone offers outdoor service, allowing you to order while enjoying time with pets.

2

Pup cups are available for dogs when ordering outside.

3

Expect minimal to no wait times during off-peak hours.

03
BKLYN MACS image 1
Dessert shop

Dessert shop offers largest flavor selection of macarons with unique edible photo printing on treats. Space feels cozy and creative with stylish interior and small seating area. Atmosphere stays friendly and welcoming throughout visits.

Soft macarons serve as the base for ice cream sandwiches with unique flavors like Ube Toasted Coconut and Dubai chocolate. The pairing of creamy ice cream and delicate macarons creates a delicious dessert experience.

Handmade caramel adds a slight sweetness to the coffee, especially in the caramel latte. Salted caramel macarons offer a chewy texture and unique flavor.

People are saying

"I considered these the best macarons I have tasted."

"The macaroon ice cream sandwich was a perfect pairing."

"I found the salted caramel macarons to be very tasty."

Good to know

1

Almost everything is gluten-free, catering to dietary restrictions.

2

The macarons are made in-house with premium ingredients.

3

Expect a constantly rotating selection of unique flavors.

04
The Dolly Llama image 1
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop with colorful decor and a pink theme creates a lively and fun atmosphere. Games at tables and treats like cotton candy add to the family-friendly vibe. Clean, modern space offers rich, high-quality ice cream and standout bubble waffles.

Ice cream sandwiches feature horchata ice cream and a coating of cinnamon toast crunch cereal. Staff add a birthday candle on top for celebrations.

Salted caramel appears in several forms, including salted caramel ice cream and Salted Caramel Cookie Butter flavor. It pairs well with other treats like bubble waffles and hot chocolate topped with caramel sauce.

People are saying

"I thought the homemade ice cream flavors were exceptional."

"The salted caramel ice cream is delicious."

"I had the best ice cream sandwich I have ever had."

Good to know

1

The Dolly Llama offers a variety of dessert options including bubble waffles and homemade ice cream.

2

They have a special promotion where buying two pints gets you a third free.

3

Expect a line out the door during peak hours, especially on weekends.

05
Stack Creamery image 1
Ice cream shop

Cozy shop with a retro-style ambiance and the smell of fresh baked cookies fills the air. Customers create custom ice cream sandwiches from a variety of unique flavors and cookies. No seating is available, encouraging quick visits in a clean, updated space.

Customers create their own ice cream sandwich by choosing any flavor of ice cream and any cookie. Staff provide helpful recommendations and assist with custom orders like birthday sandwiches.

Sea salt caramel pretzel stands out with its salted pretzel caramel flavor and a rich caramel brown color. Cookie Monster and salted caramel are popular choices, often recommended and served alongside a free pup cup.

People are saying

"Jill's service made my ice cream experience super pleasant."

"Jill was super helpful making custom ice cream sandwiches."

"Jill was so friendly and helpful with the Caramel."

Good to know

1

Stack Creamery offers a variety of ice cream flavors and cookie options.

2

Prices for cookies are $11.99 for 6, but may vary.

3

Generous portions make it easy to get full from a single order.

06
Heap's Ice Cream image 1
Ice cream shop

Cozy ice cream shop with an old school vibe and bright natural light fills with families enjoying treats. Creative flavors like mango sticky rice and stroopwafel stand out alongside fresh waffle cones. Ample outdoor seating complements a friendly, welcoming atmosphere.

Fresh cookie ice cream sandwiches sell quickly and look appealing. They cost around $10.50 and stand out for their quality.

Banana bourbon caramel stands out as a key flavor, featured in sundaes and as a favorite choice. The Stroop Waffle Caramel also offers a distinct taste experience.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was delicious and artisanal."

"The caramel ice cream here is super delicious."

"I thought the ice cream sandwich was possibly the best I'd ever had."

Good to know

1

One scoop of ice cream costs $6.50.

2

There are non-dairy options available.

3

Heap's offers unique flavors and fresh ingredients.

07
Jeremiah's Italian Ice image 1

Small ice cream shop offers family-friendly atmosphere with tabletop games like giant Uno and Jenga. The space feels inviting and fun, often lively with music and activities for kids. Customers enjoy authentic Italian ice and soft serve with generous sampling options.

Ice cream sandwiches feature prominently and taste delicious. They recently started offering these sweet treats.

Salted caramel appears as a swirl and a flavor option alongside others like black raspberry. Caramel apple jelati offers a distinct caramel twist paired with fruity notes.

People are saying

"The staff is so patient and friendly with kids."

"The salted caramel swirl jelati was amazing."

"You have to try the ice cream sandwich; it's delicious."

Good to know

1

The menu offers a huge variety of flavors, ensuring something for everyone.

2

Prices are affordable, making it a great spot for families.

3

You can sample any flavor before making your decision.

08
Manhattan Beach Creamery image 1

Ice cream shop offers colorful decor and small outdoor seating with a nostalgic ambiance. It features a wide variety of flavors and creative ice cream sandwiches. Atmosphere is lively and pleasant, attracting those seeking a sweet treat near the beach.

Made-to-order ice cream sandwiches come with a wide variety of flavors like Sea Salt Caramel and cookie dough. Cookies and cream ice cream adds a rich taste, and the sandwiches pair well with milkshakes.

Salted caramel appears in several treats like Ice Cream Sandwiches and a Salted Caramel Sandwich that balances sweet and salty flavors but can get messy. Hot caramel sauce tops the Sticky Bun Sundae, adding a warm, rich touch to the dessert.

People are saying

"I thought the homemade ice cream was rich and smooth."

"I loved the made-to-order ice cream sandwiches."

"The salted caramel ice cream is rich with a perfect sweet-salty balance."

Good to know

1

The shop offers a wide variety of ice cream flavors and products.

2

Expect long lines, but they move quickly.

3

Ice cream sandwiches can be customized with any cookie and ice cream.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...