Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
the US' best

Cookies and cream carrot cake

You want a menu that offers both cookies and cream ice cream and a slice of carrot cake.

Based on 665 Opinions
+662
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Heartland Homemade Ice Cream image 1
Heartland Homemade Ice Cream image 2
Heartland Homemade Ice Cream image 3
View all

Small shop with cozy atmosphere and family-friendly vibe offers unique homemade ice cream flavors including dairy-free options. Customers enjoy voting on new flavors and sitting inside or outside on benches. The space feels welcoming and lively, perfect for casual visits.

Creamy texture and Oreo-tasting flavor define the Cookies and Cream here. The ice cream is rich, chocolaty, and shows strong attention to dietary preferences with a dairy-free option.

Carrot cake appears as a sheet cake baked into ice cream, creating a unique texture. The flavor stands out as very good and is consistently noted among the favorite ice cream flavors.

People are saying

"The homemade ice cream here has unique, delicious flavors like cornbread."

"The Cookies and Cream ice cream here is amazing and superb."

"I thought the carrot cake ice cream was amazing."

Good to know

1

All ice cream is made in store daily for freshness.

2

They offer a wide variety of ice cream options, including dairy-free choices.

3

New and unique flavors are regularly introduced.

02
Love and Cake image 1

Bakery showcases unique cake designs with creative decorations and a Star Wars and Steelers theme. Atmosphere feels detailed and inviting, enhanced by flower decorations and even a lit R2D2 figure. Cakes offer distinctive flavors like coconut rum, combining visual appeal with moist, tasty quality.

Cookies and cream appears as a filling and frosting in various cakes like white, chocolate, and blue velvet. It pairs with chocolate fudge and cream cheese frosting for layered desserts.

Moist and flavorful textures define the carrot cake here, with options like gluten free cupcakes decorated for special occasions. Unique combinations like German chocolate with carrot cake add a delicious twist.

People are saying

"The cakes here are gorgeous and taste great."

"The Cookies and Cream cake was exactly what we wanted."

"I found the carrot cake here to be the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for custom cake orders, especially during peak seasons.

2

Orders can be placed online or by phone, with a minimum of 48 hours notice required.

3

The bakery can accommodate dietary restrictions, including gluten-free and vegan options.

03
Buttercup BakeShop image 1
Cupcake shop

Small cupcake shop with pink, cute interior offers a warm vibe and soft jazz tunes. Cookies and cream cupcake is moist and sweet, a top pick. Carrot cake shines as both slice and cupcake, insanely tasty and popular with staff.

Cookies and cream cupcake stands out for being moist and sweet. It ranks as a favorite flavor among several options tried.

Carrot cake comes as both a classic slice and a cupcake, known for being insanely tasty and amazing in flavor. Staff often save slices for last-minute requests, showing care for this popular item.

People are saying

"The cupcakes here are amazing and delicious."

"The carrot cake here is super soft and flavorful."

"The Cookies and Cream cupcake is light, soft, and tastes amazing."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers gluten-free options, ensuring a variety for dietary needs.

2

Prices for baked goods are clearly posted outside the shop.

3

There is usually no long wait at this cupcake shop.

04
The Benjamin Hollywood image 1

Art deco design blends old Hollywood glamour with modern class in a cozy, velvet-lined space. The atmosphere feels vibey and intimate, with dim lighting and a lively bar scene. Cocktails like the Ben's Martini stand out for their presentation and taste.

A standout dessert features Cookies and Cream with a unique twist not commonly found elsewhere. It pairs well with drinks like the pornstar martini and espresso martini with Japanese whiskey.

Carrot cake stands out with its incredible flavor and serves as a perfect ending to meals. Even those who usually avoid carrot cake find it enjoyable alongside the notably good cookies.

People are saying

"The burgers here are thick, juicy, and flavorful."

"I love their Cookies And Cream; it's a taste of community."

"You shouldn't skip the carrot cake; it's that good."

Good to know

1

Reservations open one week in advance at 9 am PST and fill quickly.

2

Expect to pay $20-40 for appetizers and $30-80 for main dishes.

3

The upstairs bar is a great spot for drinks after dining.

05
Fireman Derekโ€™s Bake Shop image 1

Bright, cozy bakery with colorful murals and a cheerful vibe filled with the aroma of freshly baked goods. Energy feels hip and trendy, attracting those who appreciate creative desserts and a community atmosphere.

Cookies and cream cheesecake stands out with several variations like the original and Cookie Monster. Other desserts include a cookies and cream pie and an acceptable cookies and cream ice cream.

Rich and huge slices of carrot cake stand out here. The cake pairs well with other treats like chocolate chip cookies and pies.

People are saying

"I found the cakes here to be moist and delicious."

"I found the Cookies and Cream pie excellent."

"I thought their carrot cake was the richest I ever had."

Good to know

1

The key lime pie slice now costs $11.

2

The price of $10 for a slice of cake in plastic was definitely too high.

3

I appreciated that it was one of the few places with a parking lot.

06
Deep Sea Sugar And Salt image 1

Cake shop occupies a cute retro house with spacious seating and a walk-up pickup window. Atmosphere feels cozy and inviting despite some dark lighting and occasional drafts. Regulars appreciate the friendly, calm vibe and the space suits groups well.

Cookies and Cream appears as a popular cake flavor, featured in slices and whole cakes for events like weddings. It pairs well with other favorites like vanilla custard and salted caramel.

Pineapple carrot cake stands out with its moist texture and large pineapple bits. The carrot cake often evokes strong reactions due to its rich flavor.

People are saying

"The cake here is crazy delicious and not too sweet."

"I loved my slice of Cookies and Cream."

"I loved the carrot cake; it was so moist with large bits of pineapple."

Good to know

1

Arrive early on weekends to avoid sold-out cakes and long lines.

2

Parking is not available at the shop; use the paid lot next door.

3

A slice of cake costs $11, and preorders are recommended for whole cakes.

07
CamiCakes Cupcakes image 1

Small bakery with a vibrant festive atmosphere and cheerful decorations. Offers 21 cupcake flavors featuring both classic and innovative options, made fresh daily with real butter and cream. The space includes a compact counter and kiosk for ordering.

Cookies and cream appears as a cupcake flavor alongside options like double chocolate and turtle. It features in selections with other rich tastes such as banana cream and cookie butter.

Moist carrot cake cupcakes come with shaved coconut and pecans mixed in. Texture can be a bit gummy but flavor stays strong.

People are saying

"These cupcakes are so moist and loaded with rich flavors."

"The Cookies and Cream cupcakes were moist and melted in my mouth."

"I loved the flavorful carrot cake with coconut and pecans."

Good to know

1

CamiCakes makes their cupcakes fresh daily.

2

There are 21 cupcake flavors available, including unique and classic options.

3

All cupcakes are baked the same day for maximum freshness.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...