Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to the US

Key lime pie and cobbler

When you have a craving for both key lime pie and cobbler, you need a menu that respects both traditions.

Based on 616 Opinions
+613
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Sweet Sweetz Ice Cream and Desserts image 1
Sweet Sweetz Ice Cream and Desserts image 2
Sweet Sweetz Ice Cream and Desserts image 3
View all

Giant checkers board anchors a cozy, family-friendly dessert shop with a fun atmosphere. Homemade pies and desserts fill the air with comforting smells, drawing a crowd that enjoys kid-friendly entertainment and a welcoming vibe.

Light yet creamy texture combines with tangy and tart flavors in the key lime pie. Variations like the raspberry key lime pie add a unique twist, while the homemade style stands out for authenticity.

Peach cobbler stands out with its amazing flavor and is often described as the best since homemade. Multiple visits include buying several slices, highlighting its delicious, comforting taste that draws repeat orders.

People are saying

"I went back the next day for another peach cobbler."

"I thought the pie here was the best I've ever had."

"I found the homemade Key Lime Pie to be the most incredible I have ever had."

Good to know

1

Whole pies can be ordered in advance through their website.

2

Desserts include ice cream, cakes, and pies made in-house.

3

Slices of pie are available for individual purchase.

02
Richard's Super Premium Ice Cream image 1

Ice cream shop inside a church offers a warm, inviting atmosphere with peaceful background music. Customers enjoy endless free samples and unique flavors like vodka-infused ice cream. Setup focuses on takeout and delivery without traditional seating.

Offers a perfect balance of tangy and sweet in the key lime pie. Also features key lime pie paired with vodka ice cream and available as a sample alongside mango vodka.

Ice cream features unique flavors like Peach Cobbler, Sweet Potato Pie, and Banana Pudding. The peach cobbler and sweet potato pie flavors stand out as favorites.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was rich and delicious."

"I found this place to be a hidden gem with great treats."

"You have to try the peach cobbler ice cream; it's amazing."

Good to know

1

They have weekly specials every Wednesday.

2

The ice cream shop offers a rotating selection of unique flavors.

3

Parking is available in the industrial park where the shop is located.

03
Gregory's Gourmet Desserts image 1

Small shop offers wall-to-wall sweets with takeout only service. Atmosphere feels like a fun hole-in-the-wall with a strong dessert aroma. Desserts, especially cheesecakes and pies, receive consistent praise for quality.

Bright, tangy flavor and a crisp, well-made crust define the Key Lime Pie here. It delivers a perfect balance of sweet and tart with a smooth, creamy texture.

Peach cobbler stands out with a perfect balance of sweetness and texture, often enjoyed cooled without ice cream. Key lime pie also draws repeat visits, making both desserts popular choices here.

People are saying

"The cakes here are exceptional, especially the sweet potato."

"The peach cobbler is great, but a little too sweet."

"The Key Lime Pie here is so delicious and tart."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for holiday specials at Gregory's Gourmet Desserts.

2

Expect a wait during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

Street parking can be difficult; there's a garage across the street.

04
Big Ed's BBQ image 1
Barbecue restaurant

Huge, clean space with a cafeteria-style dining area creates a spacious, casual vibe. Live jazz and a full bar add to the lively atmosphere, while comfy couches offer spots to relax. Known for top-tier barbecue and a variety of sauces, it blends great food with a fun, family-like energy.

Homemade Key lime pie offers a delicious texture and excellent taste with a silky, decadent feel. It rivals well-known versions from Florida and stands out for its appealing appearance.

Peach cobbler stands out with a warm, satisfying texture and a generous serving size. It pairs well with ice cream and matches the quality of other desserts like key lime pie.

People are saying

"You have to try the brisket; it's some of the best American food around."

"I loved the key lime pie; it was divine and heavenly."

"You gotta try the peach cobbler, it's amazing."

Good to know

1

Arrive early to avoid missing out on menu items as they sell out quickly.

2

Free meals are offered on Thanksgiving Day, making it a popular time to visit.

3

Some menu items are only available on specific days, so check ahead.

05
Southern Chicago image 1

Elegant space features beautiful dรฉcor and a warm, comfortable atmosphere with great music enhancing the vibe. Guests enjoy thoughtfully crafted cocktails and high-quality Southern-inspired dishes in a setting that feels both inviting and refined.

Key lime pie stands out as a delicious dessert option. It consistently delivers on flavor without disappointment.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, fresh, and thoughtfully prepared."

"The desserts here are phenomenal, sealing the deal for me."

"Rich's hospitality made the cobbler truly special."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers great prices on food and drinks.

2

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially on weekends.

3

Valet parking is available for guests.

06
Crustees image 1
Restaurant

Tiny restaurant offers outdoor dining with a clean, cheerful space and neo-soul/house music creating a super chill vibe. The atmosphere feels welcoming and relaxed, attracting a community-focused crowd. Pot pies and desserts stand out as signature features.

Tart and creamy with an authentic Key West flavor, the Key Lime Pie stands out among a variety of desserts like peach cobbler and banana nut pie.

Warm peach cobbler features a flaky crust and a moist, fresh peach filling. Pairing it with two scoops of ice cream adds a cool, creamy contrast to the sweetness.

People are saying

"The pot pie crust is perfect, flaky, and savory."

"The peach cobbler's crust is perfectly flaky and warm."

"I swear this Key Lime Pie is flown in straight from Key West."

Good to know

1

The pies cost approximately $10 each with tax.

2

The cost is about $20 per person for a pot pie and dessert.

3

They offer a buy one get one free coupon on any item.

07
Yardbird Table & Bar image 1

Dark interior with warm lighting and loud atmosphere creates an upscale yet laidback vibe. Frequent crowd noise rises to concert levels on busy nights. Dedicated gluten-free southern cooking and a well-stocked whiskey selection distinguish the experience.

Gluten-free key lime pie delivers a rich, tangy flavor that stands out. It pairs well with other desserts like fried Oreos and leaves a strong impression.

Crumbles have the right level of sweetness and a sugar dome tops the presentation. Served with vanilla ice cream, the Strawberry Peach Cobbler stands out as a southern dessert.

People are saying

"The fried chicken is crispy, juicy, and perfectly seasoned."

"The gluten-free Key Lime Pie made my wife cry tears of joy."

"The strawberry peach cobbler is amazing, especially with vanilla ice cream."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to avoid long wait times, especially on weekends.

2

Yardbird Table & Bar offers dedicated gluten-free fries and fried chicken.

3

The menu is clearly labeled for allergies, making it easy to identify gluten-free options.

08
Cobblers Cakes & Kream image 1

Small bakery with a warm, friendly atmosphere and a sweet, savory aroma. Quiet but steady flow of customers reflects its fresh daily baked goods that often sell out early. Known for exceptional cookies and peach cobbler, it offers some of the best sweets in the area despite limited indoor space.

Key lime pie stands out for its intense sweetness and rich, condensed sugar flavor. It pairs well with other desserts like peach cobbler and sweet potato pie.

Peach cobbler stands out as a highlight, often described as delicious and worth sharing. Other cobblers like blackberry and apple also impress with their fresh and wonderful flavors.

People are saying

"I thought the cookies here were the absolute best I ever tasted."

"I loved their peach cobbler; it was delicious."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was the highlight."

Good to know

1

All items are made fresh daily and they sell out of most popular ones by 2PM.

2

Reservations are recommended for pies to ensure availability.

3

Parking at Cobblers Cakes & Kream is limited or inconvenient.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...