Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
the US' best

Consignment ring stores

Made for those who hunt for pre-owned treasures and want to find a ring that carries a history of its own.

Based on 604 Opinions
+601
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Dover Jewelry & Diamonds image 1
Dover Jewelry & Diamonds image 2
Dover Jewelry & Diamonds image 3
View all

Jewelry store offers an incredible selection of estate, antique, and vintage pieces with honest gem verification and transparent pricing. Atmosphere feels relaxing and welcoming, creating a smooth buying and selling experience. Customers find expert custom design and professional appraisals readily available.

Custom engagement rings get crafted with care, tailored exactly to preferences. Services include ring resizing and appraisals, with secure shipping available.

Consignment involves an easy online process through eBay with clear explanations of fees and payment handling. Results often exceed expectations, making the process worthwhile for gold jewelry pieces.

People are saying

"Vrunali at this Jewelry Store was so helpful and stayed within my budget."

"Ally made the consignment process feel safe and secure."

"Vrunali at the Ring Store helped me find the perfect ring and get a great price."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for special events or classes.

2

Expect a 30-minute wait for appraisals during peak hours.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash is also welcome.

02
avntgrdny image 1
Jewelry store

Small space with a beautiful setup and lounge chairs creates a cool vibe and authentic, welcoming atmosphere. Offers additional services like sneaker cleaning and features a rare collection of sneakers and garments. Prices are reasonable with a smooth transaction process and fast shipping.

A much larger collection of Chrome Hearts rings stands out here compared to other stores. Staff help with trying on rings and assist in selling pieces, making it easy to find and trade chrome rings.

Consignment terms come out clearly laid out when selling items like Off White Chicago 1s. The owner handles consignment directly, making the process straightforward without any snobby attitudes.

People are saying

"Andrew at the Footwear Store is such an amazing, trustworthy person."

"Drew at the Ring Store is super friendly and knowledgeable."

"I found the consignment person a pleasure to do business with."

Good to know

1

The store has super competitive prices on high-end brands like Chrome Hearts and Versace.

2

Online purchase and in-store pickup are available for quick access to items.

3

The Sole Broker has all the latest Jordans and hard-to-find older models.

03
The Jewelry Source image 1
Jewelry store

Store offers a family atmosphere with a beautiful, inviting space. Energy feels comfortable and friendly, supported by knowledgeable staff who handle repairs and customizations on-site. Selection includes high-quality, unique jewelry with antique pieces and quick, reasonably priced services.

They handle ring resizing and restoration with care, including family heirlooms and wedding rings. Services include stone replacement, resetting diamonds, and rebuilding ring settings after damage.

Barb S handles consignment, including luxury items like a Rolex watch. Estate consignment jewelry features prominently, offering a range of unique pieces.

People are saying

"The Jewelry Store staff are so friendly and professional."

"Annika at the Ring Store was so helpful with my custom wedding band."

"I had a great experience with Barb for consignment."

Good to know

1

The Jewelry Source offers quick turnaround times for repairs and customizations.

2

Resizing services are reasonably priced and completed in a timely manner.

3

They have skilled bench jewelers for any customization or repair needs.

04
Jeffrey's Jewelry Design Studio image 1

Jewelry store offers skilled craftsmanship and affordable pricing with a wide selection including unique and men's rings. Atmosphere feels like shopping with family, with no pressure and honest advice on care and repairs. Repair work is precise, often surpassing other shops in quality and cost.

Quick and flawless ring repairs happen while you wait. They resize and convert rings into pendants, asking just enough personal questions to match the ring to the bride's personality.

A full-service custom jewelry shop offers a good selection of estate pieces on consignment. Prices of consignment jewelry do not reflect the rise in gold costs, making them a great deal.

People are saying

"The staff at this Ring Store are so kind, helpful, and knowledgeable."

"I trusted this Watch Store for quality items and fair prices."

"I experienced wonderful, friendly service here."

Good to know

1

Jeffrey's offers a wide range of services and can accommodate specific requests.

2

The jewelers are skilled and provide honest opinions on jewelry care.

3

They charge significantly less than other jewelry repair shops.

05
Atlas Jewelers image 1

Beautiful jewelry store with a friendly atmosphere and comfortable environment. Offers custom design services, repair and cleaning with timely, quality work. Presence of a Labrador Retriever adds a charming touch to visits.

Ring repair and resizing services include fixing prongs, refinishing, and cleaning. Custom design changes and affordable replacements are available, with options to buy and sell jewelry as well.

A large assortment of consignment items offers unique pieces like a teal sapphire ring. The selection focuses on items ready to be reloved and includes options for coins and custom work.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so friendly and helpful."

"The staff at this Ring Store are so friendly and helpful."

"They really worked with me on the price for my consignment."

Good to know

1

The battery replacement costs $35 and includes a lifetime replacement.

2

The turnaround time for repairs is typically three weeks.

3

Atlas Jewelers offers fine jewelry at competitive prices.

06
St. John's Jewelry image 1
Jewelry store

Store offers a relaxed shopping experience with a beautiful, sparkling display of jewelry and watches. Atmosphere reflects a vintage charm reminiscent of decades past, attracting those who value personal relationships over quick sales. Prices are fair and competitive, with quick turnaround on custom work and repairs.

Ring sizing, cleaning, and repairs happen with care and precision. Staff like Sonja and Adrian help find the right fit and even source specific stones. Rings come back looking brand new after restoration and resizing.

Unique pieces fill the consignment section, featuring jewelry and watches. A consignment case holds rings and other items for selection.

People are saying

"The service at this jewelry store is always friendly and helpful."

"Adrian and Sonya are so helpful with the Ring Store."

"The staff here are so helpful and friendly when looking at consignment."

Good to know

1

St. John's Jewelry offers quick turnaround for custom orders, often ready the next day.

2

They provide engraving services with a turnaround of less than a week.

3

The store has a consignment section featuring unique jewelry pieces.

07
Claydon Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Store combines family-owned warmth with impeccable craftsmanship in an immaculate setting. Friendly atmosphere includes a welcoming dog at the entrance. Offers custom designs, repairs, and a diverse, tasteful jewelry selection with reasonable pricing.

Staff provide custom designs and help with engagement and wedding rings. They offer ring resizing and deliver quality rings at prices below other jewelers.

Beautiful jewelry fills the consignment area, with a nice selection of turquoise pieces. They accept and sell jewelry on consignment, offering space for personal items.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so knowledgeable and helpful."

"The people at this Ring Store are patient, friendly, and helpful."

"The people here are so helpful and knowledgeable about consignment."

Good to know

1

Claydon Jewelers offers watch and jewelry repairs, custom designs, and engagement rings.

2

The cost for jewelry cleaning and repairs is very reasonable.

3

Claydon Jewelers provides resizing services for rings and custom orders.

08
Olde Town Exchange Consignment Store image 1

Bright, well organized consignment shop with boutique vibes and an upscale atmosphere. Relaxing space feels like shopping with friends, featuring unique, high-quality pieces and a stellar selection of clothing and accessories. Dressing rooms and kid-friendly amenities add to a comfortable, inviting experience.

Offers sterling silver rings with unique designs. Wedding rings available for around $40.

Upscale consignment shop offers incredible quality items and lots of quality clothes. Shopping here provides a fantastic experience with items at a fraction of the cost.

People are saying

"I found beautiful, high-quality women's clothing at amazing prices."

"I found this consignment shop to be an absolute gem."

"The staff at Ring Store were so nice and helpful."

Good to know

1

The store offers a variety of items suitable for every occasion.

2

They have a wide selection of shoes, jewelry, handbags, and clothing.

3

Expect high-end luxury pieces like Louis Vuitton and Chanel.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...