Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
the US' best

Consignment vintage shops

You value the transparency and quality control that comes with a well-managed consignment shop.

Based on 653 Opinions
+650
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
LA Video Games image 1
LA Video Games image 2
LA Video Games image 3
View all
Video game store

Video game store with vast collection of retro and vintage games and an arcade cabinet at the front. Atmosphere feels chill and nostalgic, with neatly organized displays creating a relaxed and welcoming environment. Offers both modern and retro games, attracting gamers looking for rare and throwback titles.

A vast collection of retro games spans back to the Atari 2600, including vintage NES games and other classic consoles. The shop offers excellent service alongside its wide selection of physical games and retro systems.

Fun consignment system includes shelves stocked with retro games and card packs alongside new titles.

People are saying

"I found an awesome selection of retro games here."

"I found amazing retro finds and a great selection of games."

"I found great games on consignment here."

Good to know

1

During their anniversary sale, everything is 20% off.

2

The store offers a wide variety of modern and retro games.

3

They have a well-organized selection, making it easy to find games.

02
Great Labels image 1
Consignment shop

Consignment shop with a chic, well-curated layout offers high-end designer clothing and accessories in excellent condition. Atmosphere stays calm and inviting, encouraging leisurely browsing and trying on items. Frequent discounts and a wide variety make it a spot for finding unique, quality pieces at reasonable prices.

Offers a lovely vintage selection focused on designer pieces. Includes beautiful vintage silk shirts at reasonable prices.

Pricing beats other consignment businesses. Designer resale focuses on clothes more than bags, with the bag selection feeling underwhelming.

People are saying

"I found lovely and unique women's clothing with a wonderful selection."

"I found this vintage shop to be the best designer vintage store."

"I considered this my favorite place for designer consignment resale."

Good to know

1

Great Labels often offers 50% off or more sales quickly to keep their inventory fresh.

2

They do an Instagram Live every Friday at Noon (Pacific time) featuring new arrivals and markdowns.

3

Great Labels has a wonderful selection of clothes, shoes, bags, and jewelry.

03
Antique Arena Inc image 1
Auction house

Online auction house specializes in Eastern European antiques with a well-organized and professional setup. Atmosphere is friendly and welcoming, supporting a smooth bidding and consignment process. Shipping services are secure and timely, often praised for excellent packaging and fast delivery.

Strong expertise in Eastern European antiques stands out here. The shop offers a well curated selection with fast delivery and careful packing for collectibles and artwork.

The consignment process is clear and straightforward with detailed explanations about percentages and payments. Items ship with a consignment form, and the auction handles them with care and sometimes offers unexpected surprises.

People are saying

"My paintings arrived safely and well-packaged thanks to Paul."

"I found the consignment process easy to understand and professional."

"I found the vintage shop staff to be very nice and respectful."

Good to know

1

Many auctions are held on weekends, but no staff are available to answer questions.

2

Expect high purchase prices, which may indicate a lack of quality service.

3

Be cautious of counterfeit items as some artworks may not be authentic.

04
avntgrdny image 1
Jewelry store

Small space with a beautiful setup and lounge chairs creates a cool vibe and authentic, welcoming atmosphere. Offers additional services like sneaker cleaning and features a rare collection of sneakers and garments. Prices are reasonable with a smooth transaction process and fast shipping.

Selection focuses on retro shoes and vintage shirts priced around $25. Staff shows deep knowledge of Jordan Retros and curates pieces with clear passion.

Consignment terms come out clearly laid out when selling items like Off White Chicago 1s. The owner handles consignment directly, making the process straightforward without any snobby attitudes.

People are saying

"Andrew at the Footwear Store is such an amazing, trustworthy person."

"The owner of this Vintage Shop is so knowledgeable and helpful."

"I found the consignment person a pleasure to do business with."

Good to know

1

The store has super competitive prices on high-end brands like Chrome Hearts and Versace.

2

Online purchase and in-store pickup are available for quick access to items.

3

The Sole Broker has all the latest Jordans and hard-to-find older models.

05
La Boutique Resale Consignments image 1

Consignment shop offers a huge selection of designer and vintage items with luxury brands like Chanel and Prada. Atmosphere feels like a treasure hunt with frequent new pieces and a large sales section. Shoppers find top quality items catering to various styles and budgets.

An unreal selection of designer and vintage collectibles fills the shelves. Unique vintage clothing pairs with a beautiful range of boutique heels and flats. Frank and Jonathan offer amazing knowledge of vintage wear.

Selection focuses on designer items with an excellent variety. Staff remain friendly and helpful throughout the shopping experience.

People are saying

"I found unreal vintage designer collectibles and trendy clothes."

"It's my favorite go-to consignment shop in NYC."

"I found this vintage shop to be one of the best in Manhattan."

Good to know

1

The store has a huge selection of great quality items.

2

Chanel, Prada, Moschino, and Stuart Weitzman are just a few luxury brands available.

3

The store has a very big sales section with opportunities for fantastic deals.

06
TROVE image 1
Second hand store

Carefully curated vintage pieces and decor create a modern, effortlessly cool vibe with a thrift shop atmosphere. The space feels chic and fun, offering a wide mix of fashion and home items at affordable prices. Shoppers find quality designer and brand name items alongside unique treasures in a clean, well-organized setting.

A carefully curated collection of vintage pieces and decor fills the store. Affordable vintage tea cup sets priced between $10 and $20 stand out among designer, vintage, and Zara items.

Consignment here involves a thorough and honest process that is also easy to navigate. The store stands out as a well-organized consignment shop with a strong reputation.

People are saying

"I always found something great at this thrift store, like unique pieces and designer finds."

"I found unique, reasonably priced vintage pieces and decor."

"I found this consignment place to be the best I've ever been to."

Good to know

1

The consignment process is straightforward and easy to navigate.

2

Expect to pay a 30% fee on items sold through consignment.

3

Street parking is available, but bring coins or a card for the meter.

07
Designer Revival image 1
Vintage clothing store

Vintage clothing store offers spacious layout with multiple rooms to explore and a curated mix of vintage and current designer items. Atmosphere feels high-end and trustworthy, attracting those seeking luxury consignment with reasonable pricing and a strong selection of bags, shoes, and clothes.

A great mix of vintage and current designer items fills the shelves. Events like sip and shop and trips to the Manhattan Vintage Show keep the vibe fresh and engaging.

Offers a strong luxury consignment focus with a reputation as a reliable sales partner. Stands out among consignment stores in NYC for quality and service.

People are saying

"I found the best vintage designer items at this thrift store."

"I found the best vintage designer items here."

"I found the best vintage designer items here."

Good to know

1

Designer Revival hosts events like the Manhattan Vintage Show and sip and shop gatherings.

2

The store has a selective bag policy that may vary based on appearance.

3

Expect to find many items in excellent condition, including bags and clothing.

08
The Blue Door image 1
Antique store

Three-story vintage home filled with eclectic antiques and mid-century modern furniture creates a curated, charming atmosphere. The space blends unique vintage and new items with a focus on quality and Americana. Dog-friendly environment invites leisurely exploration of constantly changing estate pieces.

A perfectly curated selection of antiques, 60โ€™s retro pieces, and mid-century modern furniture fills the space. Unique vintage furniture, art, clothing, and handcrafted home items create an eclectic mix with many pieces under $50.

A wonderfully curated consignment shop with a variety of styles in each corner. Pricing matches other antique or consignment shops, not a thrift store.

People are saying

"I found a nice selection of vintage furniture and clothing here."

"I found great vintage furniture and art at this thrift store."

"This vintage shop has an amazing, beautifully curated collection of unique items."

Good to know

1

The store has three floors filled with unique vintage items.

2

Expect a wide range of prices, with some items under $50.

3

The store operates on a consignment basis, showcasing various styles.

09
Beacon's Closet image 1
Second hand store

Store feels cramped and crowded with narrow aisles and tightly hung clothes, making browsing challenging. Music plays loud jazz, creating a vibrant and funky atmosphere. Organization is neat, with clothes sorted by color, and the selection includes unique vintage pieces.

Offers a unique selection of vintage and designer clothing with a strong focus on genuinely vintage pieces. Inventory includes a variety of vintage shirts and jerseys alongside contemporary items.

Offers a high-end consignment selection with a vintage focus. The shop has a cute, curated vibe that stands out among thrift stores.

People are saying

"I found so many unique designer women's clothing pieces at amazing prices."

"I found a great selection of vintage clothing here."

"I found it to be one of the best high-end consignment stores."

Good to know

1

Beacon's Closet allows you to sell items for 50% in store credit or 30% in cash.

2

Beacons has a new fitting room policy that requires customers to prioritize their first 6 items.

3

The store offers the best resale value for vintage items.

10
The RealReal image 1
Consignment shop

Sleek, airy space separates men's and women's sections like two distinct stores, creating an upscale yet welcoming atmosphere. Fashion items are beautifully merchandised, offering a curated selection of luxury pieces at reduced prices. The environment feels friendly and refined, blending style with a sense of professionalism.

Offers a curated selection of vintage Chanel, Coach, Chloe, and Ralph Lauren pieces. Includes barely-worn sneakers and unique vintage styles with accurate suggestions and variations.

Consignment here is easy and smooth with staff like Jesse and Nelson who are kind and helpful. The process includes exceptional evaluation of items, making it reliable and trustworthy.

People are saying

"The consignment staff are so friendly and knowledgeable."

"I felt so comfortable making a big purchase here."

"Kenneth made the vintage shopping experience so wonderful."

Good to know

1

Free parking is available for customers buying or consigning.

2

They do not validate parking unless it's a new purchase or consignment.

3

Reservations are recommended for high-value consignment items.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...