Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
the US' best

Keto cookie spots

A cookie that fits a keto lifestyle makes it possible to enjoy a treat without the compromise.

Based on 518 Opinions
+515
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Heavenly Keto Dessert - Online Store image 1
Heavenly Keto Dessert - Online Store image 2
Heavenly Keto Dessert - Online Store image 3
View all

Online bakery offers gluten-free, sugar-free keto desserts delivered nationwide. Products have a moist, rich texture without any bitter aftertaste from sweeteners. Both children and adults enjoy these treats, which taste like regular pastries despite being low-carb and healthy.

Cookies have a crispy outside and soft inside texture, tasting like regular cookies even when low-carb. The chocolate chip cookies use dark chocolate, giving a rich, decadent flavor without much sugar. Keto options are popular and well-liked.

Keto desserts here have no aftertaste and use the most healthy natural sugar replacement. Blueberry cake, keto cheesecake, and keto cookies taste like regular treats and fit strict ketogenic diets.

People are saying

"I couldn't believe how moist and tasty this keto cake was."

"I loved the chocolate cookies; they were so delicious."

"These keto cookies taste amazing and have no sugar aftertaste."

Good to know

1

Heavenly Keto Desserts ships nationwide directly to your doorstep.

2

All desserts are gluten-free and sugar-free, suitable for keto diets.

3

Gift boxes are available for special occasions or events.

02
GuilTea Cravings image 1
Bubble tea store

Cozy bubble tea shop with chill atmosphere and updated trendy decor featuring neon lights and fake plants. Space includes large tables and outlets for working, plus books and board games. Offers keto-friendly desserts and a variety of treats like macarons and ube cheesecake.

Cookies feature Oreo inside, Dubai-style pistachio with chocolate, and flavors like Thai tea and ube. Varieties include macarons, pineapple, Dulce de leche, and brown chocolate chip.

Keto options include a keto cheesecake, chaffle, and lemon cookies. The menu offers low sugar treats and a small selection of keto foods and drinks.

People are saying

"Their Vietnamese coffee is so creamy and has a nice kick."

"I loved their keto cheesecake; it was to die for."

"These cookies are so tasty, I thought they were the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Parking is much easier at GuilTea Cravings compared to other shops on Convoy Street.

2

The menu offers a variety of options, including a 2 for $5 spam musubi deal.

3

They cater to keto dieters with various options.

03
Cookie Plug image 1
Cookie shop

Cookie shop with a cute, trendy interior and fun, relaxing vibe creates a welcoming atmosphere. Music adds to the casual, cool energy, attracting a diverse crowd including families. Unique features include doggie treats and keto-friendly cookies, setting it apart from typical cookie spots.

Fire cracker cookies stand out as addictive and flavorful. The campfire cookie ranks as a top choice, described as extremely delicious and straight ๐Ÿ”ฅ and dope.

Keto options include peanut butter chocolate chip cookies that taste really good. These Keto-friendly cookies are delicious and satisfying.

People are saying

"I thought the cookies here were amazing and fire."

"The cookies and lemonade were both a perfect 10."

"I found the Keto cookies to be delicious and satisfying."

Good to know

1

They do not accept cash, only card payments.

2

The prices are $25 for 7 cookies or $35 for 12.

3

There are no seating options; cookies are to go.

04
Half Baked Goodness - Energy Corridor image 1

Bright, clean bakery with a mural saying 'Let's Get Baked' sets a chill vibe. Offers huge, creatively flavored cookies including keto and paleo options. Family-owned spot known for fresh, high-quality treats and a welcoming atmosphere.

Cookies come out hot, fresh, and huge, with edges that are crispy and centers perfectly gooey. Flavors like Crรจme Brรปlรฉe, Sโ€™mores, and Lemon offer a soft, chewy texture packed with bold, fresh tastes.

Offers keto options alongside paleo and gluten-free choices for health-conscious eaters. Staff helps customize orders, and the keto cookies come in weekly flavors and get positive feedback.

People are saying

"I found the cookies to be huge and ridiculously good."

"You have to try the Celebration cookie; it's one of the best."

"The keto cookies here are delicious and huge."

Good to know

1

Half Baked Goodness offers weekly flavors and keto options.

2

They have a revolving menu of seasonal cookies, but the staples are always available.

3

They offer paleo, keto, and gluten-free options for health-conscious customers.

05
ChocZero Inc. image 1
Chocolate factory

Chocolate factory produces sugar-free candy sweetened with pure monk fruit, offering keto-friendly and diabetic-suitable treats. Packaging includes ice packs to protect chocolates during shipping, maintaining quality despite transit challenges. Products feature clean ingredients and deliver flavors close to traditional sweets.

Speculoos and morning cookies stand out with their distinctive spice and texture. New items include pumpkin spice jollies and chocolate chip cookies, alongside favorites like honey and hazelnut chocolates.

Products include keto-friendly chocolate suitable for diabetics. Chocolate keto barks stand out as a notable item, though availability can vary.

People are saying

"This chocolate is healthier, with no sugar and cleaner ingredients."

"I loved their keto chocolate barks and speculoos."

"These cookies are keto-friendly with no sugar and cleaner ingredients."

Good to know

1

ChocZero's products are sugar-free and suitable for keto diets.

2

Most items are sweetened with monk fruit, avoiding erythritol.

3

Shipping is quick, but consider extra ice packs in hot weather.

06
Lilly's Cafรฉ image 1

Whimsical cafรฉ with colorful decor and a cozy atmosphere offers keto treats and takeout-only service. Indoor space is limited, and outdoor seating is exposed to sun and wind. The vibe is friendly with a clean, organized setup.

Chocolate chip walnut cookies stand out with their consistent rich flavor and nutty crunch. Seed-filled cookies also appear, offering a unique texture alongside classic options.

A solid selection of keto donuts and banana bread stands out among the treats. The moist texture of the keto donuts pairs well with a variety of drinks and gelato options.

People are saying

"This cafe is so cute and aesthetically pleasing."

"I thought the keto donuts were the best, moist, and delicious."

"I bought their chocolate chip walnut cookie for the third time."

Good to know

1

Lilly's Cafรฉ only offers takeout service.

2

There is no indoor seating at Lilly's Cafรฉ.

3

I paid $30 for two drinks and two pastries.

07
Erewhon image 1
Supermarket

Supermarket combines modern, bright decor with spacious, minimalistic layout and luxurious product displays. Loud pop music and blender sounds fill the interior, contrasting with heated outdoor seating and a cozy patio area. Crowds gather inside and outside, creating a busy, energetic atmosphere.

Vegan oatmeal chocolate chip cookies stand out with a soft texture and rich flavor. The cookie options include chia seed and coconut milk varieties that complement the sweet treats.

Keto options include biscuits and blueberry cupcakes that stand out for flavor. The salmon belly tends to be overcooked.

People are saying

"The hot bar at this grocery store is excellent and restaurant-quality."

"I loved their delicious keto blueberry cupcakes."

"These Madchip cookies are among the best I've ever eaten."

Good to know

1

Food is not set out until 7:30 am, even if you arrive at 7 am.

2

Parking can be a nightmare, but there is ample parking available.

3

The hot food bar is considered one of the best in the city.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...