Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to the US

Lobster roll and gelato

Most places that serve a lobster roll treat dessert as a secondary concern, failing to provide the high-quality gelato you want to finish the meal.

Based on 616 Opinions
+613
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Black Sheep Bar and Provisions image 1
Black Sheep Bar and Provisions image 2
Black Sheep Bar and Provisions image 3
View all

Upscale bar and restaurant blends modern design with chic, inviting atmosphere in a small, cozy space. The vibe stays super chill with a mix of families and lively groups, supported by expert bartenders crafting standout cocktails. Seating is comfortable but limited, making reservations essential.

Warm lobster roll features a toasted Brioche bun and a mayo blend that adds flavor. It appears on the happy hour menu alongside other mains like risotto.

Graham cracker gelato stands out as a recommended choice. The budino and gingerbread gelato also draw attention and spark conversation after dessert.

People are saying

"The food here is incredible, especially the meat dishes."

"You have to try the graham cracker gelato; it's unreal."

"I loved the warm Lobster Roll, especially since it was on happy hour."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended on weekends due to high demand.

2

Happy hour runs from 3 to 5 PM with food specials.

3

The menu changes daily, ensuring fresh options.

02
Lake Break Restaurant at North Shore image 1

Upscale restaurant combines lake views with a unique nautical-inspired decor that feels both fun and odd. Atmosphere blends lively yacht rock music with a crowd that seems familiar and relaxed. Seating varies from plush comfort to small chairs, creating distinct experiences within the space.

Tender, buttery lobster comes perfectly cooked with a well-balanced amount of sauce. Served alongside truffle fries, the roll offers a rich, satisfying flavor.

Honeycomb gelato with edible gold leaf stands out as a unique treat. It pairs well with the brown butter cake, making the dessert experience memorable.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and packed with flavor."

"I thought the lobster roll was phenomenal."

"You have to try the brown butter cake and gelato."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for the 21+ non-ADA accessible area.

2

Expect a large menu, but many items may be unavailable.

3

Kids' meals are $12 and include gluten-free options.

03
4747LIC image 1
New American restaurant

New American restaurant with open, airy design and a welcoming, kid-friendly atmosphere. Outdoor seating includes a covered patio and sundeck with views, complemented by great background music. The space balances comfort and style with local art and natural materials.

Lobster roll comes with a watercress and pear salad and kettle chips. It stands out as a favorite dish with a fresh, satisfying taste.

Toppings include sorbet and gelato served with an optional unique-looking cone. The gelato stands out as exceptionally flavorful.

People are saying

"The food here was amazing, especially the octopus and lump crab."

"I found the gelato surprisingly delicious."

"I found the lobster roll to be super fresh and bright."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is available every weekday from 5 to 7 PM only at the bar.

2

Bottomless brunch includes unlimited mimosas for 90 minutes at a reasonable price.

3

Wednesday happy hour lasts until 8 PM with half-price bottles available.

04
Even Coast image 1
Restaurant

Open concept dining with large windows and an expansive outdoor patio creates a bright, airy space. Atmosphere stays warm and inviting with a lively yet comfortable energy. Guests enjoy expertly crafted cocktails and fresh seafood in a stylish, elegant setting.

Fresh and buttery lobster rolls stand out here. They pair well with other seafood dishes like fried oysters and crab bucatini.

People are saying

"The dinner spots here, especially the pasta and fish, were delicious."

"I thought the gelato here was some of the best I've ever had."

"The lobster roll was fresh and buttery."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs daily from 2-6pm with $10 burgers.

2

Valet parking is available for a fee; street parking can be challenging.

3

The restaurant has a covered patio area for outdoor dining.

05
San Sabino image 1
Italian restaurant

Small, beautifully designed space with art deco interior and abundant natural light creates an intimate, cozy atmosphere. Busy and vibrant vibe balances lively energy without overwhelming noise. Creative cocktails like garlic bread martini stand out alongside a menu featuring Italian small plates.

Filled with high-quality lobster and served in an Italian pastry, the lobster roll offers a tasty but somewhat difficult-to-eat experience.

Gelato viennese offers a rich, creamy flavor that stands out. The pineapple sorbetto provides a refreshing, intense taste. Gelato here serves as a satisfying, flavorful finish to meals.

People are saying

"The food here is inventive, flavorful, and unforgettable."

"The Gelato Viennese was amazing and rich in flavor."

"The lobster roll was delicious, served in a tasty pastry."

Good to know

1

Reservations are necessary to secure a table, especially on weekends.

2

The restaurant can seat you at the bar between 5:45-6:30 PM.

3

The total cost for two people is about $215 after tax and tip.

06
Forbes Meat Company image 1

Butcher shop with a modern industrial design and a beautiful open kitchen creates a lively, welcoming atmosphere. Small, intimate seating surrounds refrigerated meat displays, blending market and dining experiences. The vibe is authentic and fun, with a semi-upscale feel that invites relaxed enjoyment.

Lobster roll melts in your mouth with rich, tender lobster. Chef Ben offers it as a standout seafood option that pairs well with dishes like steak frites.

Chocolate stands out as a rich gelato flavor here. Gelato pairs well with cake for a sweet dessert combo. They recently added gelato to the menu.

People are saying

"The steaks here are melt-in-your-mouth tender."

"I've never had a lobster roll that melted in my mouth like this."

"I enjoyed their chocolate gelato."

Good to know

1

Happy hour features a micro menu, suitable for brunch, lunch, or dinner.

2

The place is small with limited seating, so arrive early.

3

They have a full meat market with a large selection of meats.

07
Blu Ember image 1
Restaurant

Sleek dining room, outdoor patio, sushi bar, and intimate cocktail lounge create a modern industrial and stylish yet cozy vibe. Warm, dim lighting fosters a quiet, relaxing atmosphere suitable for casual hangouts and date nights. Unique cocktails and elevated, comforting food complement the upscale yet approachable setting.

Buttery lobster rolls come packed with big chunks of meat and are less oily than typical butter rolls. They stand out as a must-try for brunch with a solid balance of flavor.

Sake gelato offers a rich, bold flavor that stands out. Matcha gelato is also deeply flavored, though the green tea version lacks a refreshing quality.

People are saying

"The food here is flavorful and delicious."

"The lobster roll is buttery and packed with big chunks of meat."

"The sake gelato was to die for."

Good to know

1

Reservations are suggested to ensure a table during busy hours.

2

There is limited street meter parking available in the area.

3

Paid hotel parking service is available at the corner.

08
Chelsea Market image 1

Large covered market inside a restored industrial factory blends historic architecture with modern culinary culture. Vibrant atmosphere fills the space with diverse shops and food stalls, attracting many visitors. Outdoor heated booths offer comfortable spots to eat despite the busy, sometimes warm environment.

Fresh lobster shines in the lobster rolls here, making them a standout choice. Multiple vendors serve these rolls with quality seafood and a variety of preparations.

Long lines form for gelato from L'arte de Gelato among other options. Portions can be small, with some flavors served as half scoops. The taste varies, sometimes just so so.

People are saying

"This market has endless food options and great shopping."

"You can find a great Lobster Roll here among many other options."

"I enjoyed the variety of food choices, including gelato."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers half price on oysters and beers/wine.

2

Chelsea Market hosts various events, including cooking classes and pop-up shops.

3

Expect a 20-minute queue outside every restaurant during peak hours.

09
Windy City Social image 1

Open, airy space with floor-to-ceiling windows and a rooftop patio creates a bright, breezy setting. Warm lighting and stylish decor set a welcoming atmosphere that suits both casual and special occasions. Music plays softly, and the outdoor fireplace adds cozy charm to the patio area.

Whole pieces of real lobster fill the roll, lightly seasoned and tossed without filler. The lobster roll stands out from others that use minimal or imitation lobster.

Desserts feature blueberry gelato paired with coffee cake and strawberry gelato alongside champagne shortcake. Gelato serves as a sweet finish to meals here.

People are saying

"The food here is phenomenal, fresh, and flavorful."

"I highly recommend the warm lobster roll here."

"Kiyah was so sweet and attentive during my gelato."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs Monday to Friday from 3 to 5 PM with special menu deals.

2

Reservations are recommended, especially for special occasions.

3

A 20% service charge is automatically added to all bills.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...