Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

NY style pizza and Greek food in the US

You have a specific standard for a thin, foldable New York style slice, but you also want the option to pivot to authentic Greek food without changing your plans.

Based on 739 Opinions
+736
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Slyce of NY (Pizza) - Lombard image 1
Slyce of NY (Pizza) - Lombard image 2
Slyce of NY (Pizza) - Lombard image 3
View all

Pizza restaurant offers graffiti style artwork and retro NBA games on multiple TVs, creating a cozy, old school vibe. Comfy couches and a hand-painted mural add to the welcoming atmosphere. The space feels like a New York slice spot with a friendly, lively energy.

Offers authentic New York style pizza with a thin, foldable crust and balanced toppings. Prices reflect the quality, including halal options, making it a rare find for genuine NY pizza in the Chicago suburbs.

Chicken and gyro come together in a combo bowl that fills up well and costs $6.99. Both the chicken and gyro stand out as delicious and consistently top notch over rice or in a bowl.

People are saying

"I loved the halal pizza with unique toppings like gyro and chicken tikka."

"You have to try the gyro over rice; it's flavorful and well-seasoned."

"I finally found the authentic New York Style Pizza I was looking for."

Good to know

1

Free pizza slices available until 5 PM on September 15, 2025.

2

The restaurant offers a late-night menu during Ramadan.

3

The restaurant is halal and serves zabiha halal options.

02
Cappy's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cozy pizzeria with a dark wood interior and classic vintage decor creates a lively, neighborly vibe. Outdoor seating offers a pet-friendly space with views and room for kids to move. Busy atmosphere reflects popularity for thin crispy and deep dish pizzas.

Large pies come with an assortment of toppings and a solid crust. Cheese sticks and classic slices show a delicious, authentic New York style flavor.

Greek salad stands out with its rich, tasty dressing and hearty flavor that almost feels like it has meat. It pairs well with other dishes and is often ordered more than once because of its appeal.

People are saying

"I found Cappy's Pizza to be the best pizza in town."

"I thought the Greek salad was rich, tasty, and hearty."

"I found the New York Style Pizza to be solid compared to other Florida pizzas."

Good to know

1

Cappyโ€™s opens for sit-down service at 5 PM, earlier for takeout.

2

The restaurant can get crowded because there isn't tons of seating.

3

Prices are reasonable compared to other pizza chains.

03
TOMATO JOEโ€™S NEW YORK PIZZERIA image 1

Open layout reveals pizza-making process in a clean, cozy space with homey atmosphere and fresh-baked aroma. Energy stays relaxed and welcoming, perfect for casual meals. Known for authentic New York-style pizza and crispy wings that stand out in the area.

Authentic New York style pizza features a thin, foldable crust with a perfect balance of sauce and cheese. The pizza tastes phenomenal and captures the true flavor of classic New York slices.

Gyros come out crafted to perfection and consistently delicious. The Greek salad is fresh and zesty, often a favorite alongside the gyros and baklavas.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

"This New York Style Pizza is the real deal."

"I enjoyed the fresh, zesty Greek salad and perfect gyros."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers affordable lunch specials that are ready in minutes.

2

Expect generous portions and great value for your money.

3

The pizzeria is known for its cleanliness and quality of food.

04
Pizza & Gyro Express image 1

Nondescript restaurant offers authentic New York style pizza with a crust made from New York water. The atmosphere is casual with halal food served, including standout gyros and chicken dishes. Sodas are self-serve without ice, and wait times for pizza can reach about 20 minutes.

Authentic tasting cheese pie features a golden crispy crust with a fair amount of sauce. The pizza delivers a real New York flavor and texture.

Gyros stand out with amazing beef and chicken options served in a perfectly sized wrap. The menu also includes halal pizza and pasta, all praised for their flavor and portion.

People are saying

"I thought the food, especially the pizza and gyros, tasted amazing."

"I thought the gyro wrap was amazing and 10/10."

"I thought the gyro was amazing and worth the wait."

Good to know

1

The restaurant serves halal food.

2

Expect a 20-minute wait for pizza during peak hours.

3

The restaurant is located where the old Sbarro was in Westshore Mall.

05
Zeins Pizza, Subs, Mediterranean, and Wings image 1

Small, clean space with a calming atmosphere and Arabic religious music playing loudly. Late-night hours attract those seeking halal New York style pizza and homemade Egyptian desserts. The vibe feels like dining in a home rather than a typical restaurant.

Slices show classic New York style with a thin, foldable crust and balanced toppings. The pizza captures the authentic flavor typical of New York, standing out in regions where that style is rare.

Tzatziki sauce stands out with its outrageous flavor and comes as a side for dipping. The gyro pairs well with seasoned fries, and the Greek salad complements the pizza nicely.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was some of the best I've ever had."

"This New York Style Pizza is the best I've ever had."

"George can cook; the Greek food is amazing."

Good to know

1

Zeins Pizza, Subs, Mediterranean, and Wings is open late until 5am.

2

The restaurant offers late-night delivery for those craving food after hours.

3

Prices for a 14-inch pizza start at $7.99 for a special.

06
Venecia's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Recycled Pizza Hut space with bright lighting and plenty of seating creates an open, clean environment. Country music plays softly, adding to a pleasant, casual vibe. The atmosphere feels simple and functional, with hard, uncomfortable chairs and minimal decor.

Thin crust and foldable slices define the pizza here, capturing the essence of New York style. It stands out as one of the few spots nearby offering this style with a balanced sauce and cheese blend.

Gyros come with a fair portion of tasty meat. Tzatziki sauce and feta cheese are options that could enhance the flavor, while onions are present in noticeable amounts.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be amazing."

"I was so happy to find New York Style Pizza locally."

"The gyro's tasty meat had a fair portion."

Good to know

1

Kids eat free on Sunday afternoons with a purchase.

2

The pizza is served in less than 15 minutes.

3

The restaurant offers great lunch specials.

07
42nd Street Pizza and Restaurant image 1

Cozy pizza restaurant with an old 1980s diner vibe and Greek family-owned charm. Spacious, clean interior features blue chairs and round bar stools alongside a diner counter. Outdoor seating offers views of the Hudson River, creating a welcoming and warm atmosphere.

Slices offer a classic New York taste but lean toward the average side in flavor and texture.

Gyros feature well-seasoned meat, soft pita bread, and fresh vegetables with delicious tzatziki sauce. Spanakopita and baklava stand out for their authentic flavors and quality.

People are saying

"The food here is surprisingly good and delicious."

"The Greek Food here, especially the gyro platter, is juicy and flavorful."

"This New York Style Pizza is so good, it's to die for."

Good to know

1

You can choose a free dessert if you leave a review.

2

They charge many 'secret' fees that can add up to $15 extra on your bill.

3

The restaurant may autotip without mentioning it.

08
Pauli's Pizza Pasta image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, simple pizza shop with classic pizza parlour vibe and cozy, old school atmosphere. Family-friendly setting with vintage style tables and an authentic Italian feel. Known for excellent New York style pizza that many consider the best in the area.

Offers authentic New York style pizza with a classic Italian touch. The meat pizza comes packed with meat and the crust stays true to the New York style tradition.

Freshness stands out in the Greek salad, which comes in a generous portion. Some versions lean heavily on lettuce with few additions, while others pair well with dishes like lasagna or pizza.

People are saying

"The owner, Pauli, was so great and took pride in his place."

"I found the New York Style Pizza here to be excellent."

"I loved the delicious, thin crust pizza."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required but recommended for busy weekend nights.

2

The restaurant allows BYOB; bring your own beer or wine.

3

The menu lists large pizzas at $19.99, but actual prices may differ.

09
Goombas Pizza Grinder - 64th and Wadsworth image 1

Small space with limited seating creates an intimate, family vibe. Friendly atmosphere features a TV tuned to a pizza channel and encourages takeout or quick dining. Known for large portions and New York-style pizza, it stands out as a local favorite with a welcoming, casual energy.

Pizza here matches East Coast style with a thin, foldable crust. Toppings and sauce taste just like classic New York pizza.

Gyros come simple and decent, paired often with a Greek salad featuring a to die for dressing. Dolmas appear separately, with two served to share rather than included in the salad.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be delicious and fantastic."

"I thought the pizza here was always on point."

"This New York Style Pizza tasted just like the real thing."

Good to know

1

Goombas is primarily a take-out place rather than a dine-in restaurant.

2

They donโ€™t open until 11.

3

I recommend taking out or getting delivery due to limited seating.

10
NY Pie (Franklin) image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small space with a pizza parlor feel and New York style pizza creates a casual, authentic atmosphere. The vibe is quiet on Sundays but can become chaotic with busy staff during peak times. Seating is tight with a narrow aisle, making navigation challenging when crowded.

Slices capture the classic New York style with a taste matching local Bronx spots. The ambiance feels like a genuine New York pizza shop, delivering a familiar vibe and flavor.

Greek salad features fresh vegetables and a really delicious dressing. Some salads miss listed ingredients or extras paid for.

People are saying

"I found the New York style pizza here to be the best in Tennessee."

"This lunch spot has big slices of authentic NY style pizza."

"The Greek salad here is so fresh with delicious dressing."

Good to know

1

They sell pizza by the slice, with popular options available within minutes.

2

A regular slice costs almost $5, and cannolis are $6 each.

3

Expect a 15-minute wait during busy times, especially on weekends.

11
Roma's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

New York style pizzeria with a warm, home-like atmosphere and fresh pizza smell fills the space. The vibe stays quiet and relaxing even on busy nights. It offers large pizza slices and good value for those seeking classic pizza and chicken wings.

Slices feature a thin, foldable crust with a classic cheesy topping and a tangy tomato sauce that nails the New York style.

Gyros stand out with a solid wrap and come with extra Taziki Sauce made from yogurt and cucumbers. The menu also includes wings, sandwiches, and dessert alongside the gyros.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was delicious and tasted great."

"This is a great lunch spot for fast, affordable food."

"This New York Style Pizza is authentic and really good."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted; it's first-come, first-served.

2

The restaurant closes at 9 PM, but may stop serving earlier.

3

No alcohol is served at this location.

12
A Slice of New York image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, cozy pizza joint with New York-style decor featuring gangster posters and photos of iconic city scenes. Atmosphere feels casual and dimly lit, evoking an authentic NYC slice shop vibe. Serves foldable pizza slices on paper plates with plastic trays, creating a relaxed, no-frills experience.

Authentic New York style pizza shines here with a thin crust and classic toppings. The pizza captures the real deal taste and texture expected from New York slices.

Baklava stands out as a sweet highlight. Gyros come with amazing sauce and are prepared well, including options like chicken and lamb.

People are saying

"I found the New York Style Pizza to be the most authentic I've had."

"The calzone was crispy, meaty, and melty."

"I thought the Greek food here was the best around."

Good to know

1

The pizza slices are large, about one-fifth of a whole pie.

2

The restaurant offers to warm up slices if picked up.

3

Delivery takes about 30 minutes, which is typical.

13
3 Corners Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza spot with extensive outdoor seating and large TVs showing sports creates a lively atmosphere. Full bar offers diverse drinks including unique beers and cocktails. New York-style pizza aroma fills the air, drawing a crowd that enjoys a relaxed, fun vibe near the riverwalk.

Slices come huge and thin, capturing the classic New York style. The pizza offers a perfect balance of sauce and cheese, making it a solid choice for those craving authentic New York flavor.

Greek salad features lots of feta, olives, and tomatoes with mostly iceberg lettuce. Dressing varies from flavorful to bland, sometimes missing green peppers.

People are saying

"I found the white pizza to be amazing and flavorful."

"This New York Style Pizza is fantastic and huge, just like in NYC."

"The Greek salad is generously portioned with lots of feta and olives."

Good to know

1

Expect busy times after events at the arena.

2

Fridays feature a live DJ from 9:30 to 12:30pm.

3

The lunch special includes 2 slices of pizza and a soda for $9.99 or $11.99.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...